Can't Recommend It.
My mom read this book when she was in school. The book has always been on our shelf and since the story plot sounded similar to an even that happened to one of my ancestors, I decided to read it. I thought this story was going to be a white boy who had grown to love his adopted Indian family, but when taken back to his original white family, he slowly learns to love them again. I was wrong. I didn't realize that the author's intent to show us why different ethnic groups around the world hate white people (he states this is his goal in the preface). If you're looking for a happy-ending-story, this is not for you. I'm not saying the book was pointless exactly, but I did feel at the end like I would have rather spent my time reading something else. I could acknowledge the main character's feelings, but kept hoping he'd eventually see some benefits of the white culture and love for his family. Instead, True Son harbors a seething hatred toward white men up to the last punctuation mark. This book says it attempts to present both sides of the issue. But there were many sides of the issue, and not all white men back then were racist or murderers. So why are almost all of them presented as racist cowards? At one point in the story, the protagonist hacks away at a living man's scalp with no sign of remorse for it later. This book is often chosen for kids to read in school as a way to learn history and tolerance and educate them about racism. I think there are more worthwhile books that would accomplish the same thing more effectively. Okay, apart from the agenda, my thoughts on the rest of the book: Since I am originally from Pennsylvania, different characters, settings and places in the story (like Carlisle, Fort Pitt, Paxton Township, Colonel Bouquet, and the Bedford Road) were familiar to me, and it was fun to read about them in a novel. But when True Son and Half Arrow return to the Tuscarawas, the book mentions they pass many streams, certain mountains, and a natural rock formation without mentioning specific place names. I assume these are real life landmarks he based them on, but I would have liked to have known where the characters were at in the story, instead of "and they passed another stream which branched off into another stream which they followed for three days..." etc. I do not understand the meaning of the title. Maybe I'm just dense. What was the point of the character Del? The story is told from his point of view in the first few chapters, but then he disappears. The story told from True Son's father and the clergyman also seemed to throw the book off balance and did not seem to contribute the story. And the ending left the reader hanging completely. What happened to True Son? Did he go back to his family? Did his Uncle live or die? What happened in his future? Perhaps at least an epilogue would have been appropriate. Or maybe this book is part of a series I wasn't aware of. Frankly, I wouldn't really recommend this book to anybody, as I don't think it is a great piece of classic literature. But it does include some historical places and events, so I suppose some benefit could be gleaned from it.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
When John Cameron Butler was a child, he was captured in a raid on the Pennsylvania frontier and adopted by the great warrrior Cuyloga. Renamed True Son, he came to think of himself as fully Indian. But eleven years later his tribe, the Lenni Lenape, has signed a treaty with the white men and agreed to return their captives, including fifteen-year-old True Son. Now he must go back to the family he has forgotten, whose language is no longer his, and whose ways of dress and behavior are as strange to him as the ways of the forest are to them. A beautifully written, sensitively told story of a white boy brought up by Indians, The Light in the Forest is a beloved American classic.