This set documents the four-night stand by
John Coltrane (sax) and his quintet at the
Village Vanguard in New York City, November 1 -- 5, 1961. Although these are not newly discovered tapes -- as the majority of the selections have turned up on no less than five separate releases -- their restoration is significant in assessing motifs in
Coltrane's [read: multi-show] live appearances.
Coltrane is accompanied by an all-star ensemble of
Eric Dolphy (alto sax/bass clarinet),
Garvin Bushell (oboe/contrabassoon),
Ahmed Abdul-Malik (oud),
McCoy Tyner (piano),
Jimmy Garrison (bass),
Reggie Workman (bass),
Elvin Jones (drums), and
Roy Haynes (drums). Their presence is as equally vital as
Coltrane's -- inspiring as well as informing the dimensions of improvisation. With the knowledge that the entire run was being documented to create some sort of retail document,
Coltrane chose nine specific compositions to concentrate on. The choice of material likewise had a tremendous impact on the personnel of the band -- evidenced by
Bushnell's contributions during
"Spiritual" and
Abdul-Malik's within the context of the extended
"India." Each set bears its own distinctive shading and emphasis. Parties wishing to hear the run in its entirety are encouraged to check out the multi-disc
Complete 1961 Village Vanguard Recordings (1997) as there are multiple takes of the same songs. This allows even the most unsophisticated jazz consumer the opportunity to note the difference in the various versions, while contrasting the player's widely diverse performance styles. The highly recommended box set also includes a nine-panel fold out poster, 48-page liner notes booklet -- with a complete discography for the included material -- and other ephemera, such as rarely published photographs. ~ Lindsay Planer
