"An informed and sympathetic portrait of a troubled mind and humble heart." —Kirkus Reviews
The New YorkerIn 1796, in a fit of insanity, Mary Lamb, aged thirty-one, murdered her mother with a carving knife. Thereafter, despite periodic spells in asylums, she played host to Coleridge and Wordsworth and was the principal author of the famous “Tales from Shakespeare,” written with her better-known brother Charles. Charles was an alcoholic with a stutter and a limp who had a blistering sense of humor, and who, under the pen name Elia, artfully reinvented the personal essay. It was only a matter of time before modern biographers rediscovered the unconventional pair. Hitchcock’s is the third biography of the Lambs to appear in the past couple of years, and capably rescues Mary from the footnotes of her brother’s story. But this somewhat bland account fails to convey the quirkiness of the Lamb siblings, or to illuminate a literary partnership that lasted for nearly forty years.
Publishers WeeklyOne afternoon in 1796, Mary Lamb, aged 31, killed her mother with a carving knife at the dinner table. Like Kathy Watson in her recent The Devil Kissed Her: The Story of Mary Lamb, Hitchcock diagnoses manic-depression at the heart of Mary's matricidal act and her subsequent stays in Britain's early mental asylums. Hitchcock (Coming About: A Family Passage at Sea), however, is far more willing to speculate about the gaps in the record of Mary's life, not to mention her thoughts and feelings as she regained something like a normal existence after the murder, which was judged an act of madness. Despite eventual bestselling collaborations with her brother, essayist Charles Lamb, in Tales from Shakespeare and Poetry for Children, Mary left an erratic documentary trail, with only one significant personal essay, which Hitchcock sees as proto-feminist. Charles, her lifelong protector, remains the best source about his sister and their shared life. But his letters to such friends as Samuel Coleridge and Robert Southey show some reserve about the delicate subject of his sister's mental health. With such gaps, Hitchcock often resorts to reading into existing texts or inferring details of Mary's asylum experiences from typical practices of the time, which only partially resuscitates this tragic but elusive life. 32 illus. not seen by PW. Agents, Miriam Goderich and Jane Dystel. (Jan.) Copyright 2005 Reed Business Information.
Library JournalMary Lamb is the little-known sister of essayist Charles Lamb, with whom she coauthored the much-loved Tales of Shakespeare. What few of her contemporaries realized was that Mary suffered from severe mental illness, probably bipolar syndrome, which led to her stabbing her mother in a manic fit. In this well-researched book, Hitchcock (Geography of Religion) traces Mary's life and social circle in detail, drawing on historical accounts, letters, and literature to reconstruct the circumstances of the stabbing and its resulting impact on the Lamb family. Interestingly, Mary had to endure only about six months' treatment at Fisher House, a moderately priced, private madhouse, smaller than the infamous Bedlam, before she was allowed to move into her own room. Mary's illness would recur throughout her life, often requiring hospitalization; upon recovery, she would resume her normal activities of reading, writing, and serving as her brother's companion (Charles never married). Together, they entertained writers and thinkers of the time, such as Coleridge, Wordsworth, Godwin, and Hazlitt. This book adds an important dimension to our understanding of an era dominated by men, highlighting Mary's contributions to Charles's work as well as documenting the effect of madness on her life and creativity. Recommended for college and large public libraries. [See Prepub Alert, LJ 9/1/04.]-Nancy R. Ives, SUNY at Geneseo Copyright 2005 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus ReviewsAnother deft portrait (see The Devil Kissed Her, p. 680) of the woman who murdered her mother and later joined with better-known brother Charles to write Tales from Shakespeare. Hitchcock (Coming About, 1998, etc.) dives into a deep and rich sea teeming with literary life. Problem is, though, that once you begin writing about the Lambs, well, here come Coleridge (their dear friend) and Wordsworth and Hazlitt and Godwin and Wollstonecraft and Mary Shelley. And once you mention Claire Clairmont (as the author does), then lubricious Lord Byron also swims among this vast school of Romantics, all of whom seem to have corresponded with one another, many of whom kept diaries. How to keep the focus on talented and mad-if often demure-Mary Lamb (1764-1847), with all these other fascinating creatures splashing nearby, clamoring for attention? Hitchcock manages quite well. Although she takes numerous glances elsewhere (how can she not?), she proceeds in steady, professional fashion to tell Mary's story, revealing a knowledge of the major biographies of the principal Romantics and of the correspondence and writings of Charles and Mary. She imagines a rather sensational reenactment of the murder-a flash of a knife in the Lambs' kitchen in 1796, excused by a coroner's inquest as an act of patent lunacy. After time in a madhouse, Mary eventually joined her brother Charles for what would be the rest of their lives. Born into the servant class, the Lambs rose into the middle class by virtue of their pens (and Charles's reliable labors for the East India House), finding their niche in a circle that included most of the literary luminaries of the age. Mary periodically returned to the madhouse for weeks andmonths, slipping into virtually permanent twilight after her brother's death in 1834. Hitchcock persuades us that she was a major contributor to the Lambs' literary creations. An informed and sympathetic portrait of a troubled mind and humble heart. (32 illustrations, not seen)Agents: Miriam Goderich & Jane Dystel
- Norton, W. W. & Company, Inc.
- Publication date:
- Product dimensions:
- 5.64(w) x 8.52(h) x 1.20(d)
Write a Review
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >