Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions: The Comparative Politics of Russia's Regions

by Vladimir Gel'man, Sergei Ryzhenkov, Michael Brie, Vladimir Avdonin, Boris Ovchinnikov

Overview

Focusing on the vastly different outcomes of post-Soviet regime transitions, this study explores why some societies have become more democratic and some have not. Based on in-depth comparative analyses, the book assesses political developments in six of Russia's regions (Saratov, Nizhnii Novgorod, Volgograd, Ryazan', Ul'yanovsk, and Tver' oblasts) since 1988. The authors consider the influence of Soviet governance systems on the emergence of cleavages and new actors in the post-Soviet period. They also analyze the impact of institutional changes on regional regimes and the success or failure of formal institutions as a framework for political competitiveness. Placing their detailed field data within the larger comparative and theoretical context of political transitions, the authors are able to explain the mixed outcomes of post-communist regime change in Russia and other post-Soviet nations. With its innovative model of path-contingent democratization and its new typology of political regimes and regime transitions, this book will be essential reading for all scholars of democracy.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780742525610
Publisher:	Bloomsbury Academic
Publication date:	01/12/2005
Series:	The Soviet Bloc and After
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	320
Product dimensions:	6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x 0.72(d)

About the Author

Vladimir Gel'man is associate professor, faculty of political sciences and sociology, European University at St. Petersburg. Sergei Ryzhenkov is deputy head of the Center for Modern Politics Studies, Moscow. Michael Brie is head of the foreign department of the Rosa Luxemburg Foundation, Berlin. Vladimir Avdonin is professor at the Center for European Politics and Law, Ryazan' State Pedagogical University. Boris Ovchinnikov is a leading expert at the International Institute for Humanities and Political Studies, Moscow. Igor Semenov is an independent political analyst and consultant in Saratov.

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Introduction
Chapter 2 Transformations and Regimes: Uncertainty and its Consequences
Chapter 3 Regional Political Regimes and Governance Systems in Russia
Chapter 4 Saratov Oblast': Winner Takes All
Chapter 5 Nizhnii Novgorod Oblast': The Limits of Elite Settlement
Chapter 6 Volgograd Oblast': Structural Pluralism and Fragile Bicentrism
Chapter 7 Ryazan' Oblast: From Structural Dualism to Elite Settlement
Chapter 8 Ul'yanovsk Oblast': Transition without Elite Change
Chapter 9 Tver' Oblast': Proto-Politics
Chapter 10 Comparative Perspective: Political Dynamics of Regime Change
Chapter 11 Conclusion

Editorial Reviews

[Gel'man's] summaries of transitology and Russian political science will be useful to specialists both in Russia and the west, and this is a powerful statement of the need for systematic comparison.

Slavic Review

Provides a broadly-structured assessment of the politics of regional regime transformation.

Europe-Asia Studies - Derek S. Hutcheson

This is a profoundly important contribution to the field of Russian studies likely to influence how we conceive political change in Russia for many years to come.

The Russian Review

Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions marks a major contribution to the literature on comparative politics from the younger generation of Russian political scientists. An authoritative analysis of developments in Russia's regions is placed within a refreshingly intelligent new model of regime change. Not only is this a pathbreaking book in the study of post-Communist regimes, and of Russia in particular, but it will interest anyone thinking and writing about transitions-of all kinds....

Mary McAuley

Advanced undergraduates, postgraduates and academics will find this to be an essential text that aids our understanding both of politics in Russia and the nature of political transitions in general.

University Of Plymoth Karl Cordell

Vladimir Gel’man and his colleagues add enormous depth to our picture of Russia’s troubled transition by systematically comparing dynamics and results across the regions of the country. This study tells us all more, not only about the Russian experience, but about regime change in the contemporary world.

Timothy J. Colton

Gel'man tweaks the existing theories to bring them into better line with Russian reality and provides a useful framework for telling the story of political change during the last 15 years. The case studies are the most coherent histories of the regions that have come along yet.

Robert Orttung

An essential text that aids our understanding both of politics in Russia and the nature of political transitions in general.

Slavonic & East European Review

This volume illustrates how the collapse of Soviet communism has unevenly affected the political and social dynamics of six Russian Oblasts (Saratov, Nizhnii Novgorod; Volgograd, Ryazan', Ul'yanovsk, and Tver') and more importantly, how the elite class of each region has managed to deal with (or take advantage of) unique structural conditions and variants of a Soviet legacy. This book effectively mixes normative assertions with concrete examples to reveal just how complicated the world of post-authoritarian politics is. Gel'man Ryzhenkov and Brie's normatively driven analysis of the Russian transition has wider application as it raises important questions about the hueristic value of the transition paradigm.

Political Studies Review - Neil A. Cruickshank

Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions is required reading for anyone interested in understanding Russia's protracted transition from communist rule. Most importantly, the book deploys the comparative method to discuss the often-neglected regional dimensions of transition. The regional focus makes important insights about transitions in large states that contributes to our more general understanding of democratization beyond the Russian case. It is a serious book by a superb collection of authors that mixes interesting theory and original empirical research.

Michael McFaul

Provides a broadly-structured assessment of the politics of regional regime transformation.--Derek S. Hutcheson "Europe-Asia Studies "

Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions is required reading for anyone interested in understanding Russia's protracted transition from communist rule. Most importantly, the book deploys the comparative method to discuss the often-neglected regional dimensions of transition. The regional focus makes important insights about transitions in large states that contributes to our more general understanding of democratization beyond the Russian case. It is a serious book by a superb collection of authors that mixes interesting theory and original empirical research.--Michael McFaul, Stanford University

Gel'man tweaks the existing theories to bring them into better line with Russian reality and provides a useful framework for telling the story of political change during the last 15 years. The case studies are the most coherent histories of the regions that have come along yet.--Robert Orttung, American University

From the Publisher

Vladimir Gel’man and his colleagues add enormous depth to our picture of Russia’s troubled transition by systematically comparing dynamics and results across the regions of the country. This study tells us all more, not only about the Russian experience, but about regime change in the contemporary world.

Timothy Colton

An essential text that aids our understanding both of politics in Russia and the nature of political transitions in general.

Slavonic and East European Review

This volume illustrates how the collapse of Soviet communism has unevenly affected the political and social dynamics of six Russian Oblasts (Saratov, Nizhnii Novgorod; Volgograd, Ryazan', Ul'yanovsk, and Tver') and more importantly, how the elite class of each region has managed to deal with (or take advantage of) unique structural conditions and variants of a Soviet legacy.

This book effectively mixes normative assertions with concrete examples to reveal just how complicated the world of post-authoritarian politics is. Gel'man Ryzhenkov and Brie's normatively driven analysis of the Russian transition has wider application as it raises important questions about the hueristic value of the transition paradigm.
— Neil A. Cruickshank, University of Saint Andrews

Political Studies Review

Provides a broadly-structured assessment of the politics of regional regime transformation.
— Derek S. Hutcheson

Europe-Asia Studies