- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Undoubtedly the most influential advocate for birth control even before the term existed, Margaret Sanger ignited a movement that has shaped our society to this day. Her views on reproductive rights have made her a frequent target of conservatives and so-called family values activists. Yet lately even progressives have shied away from her, citing socialist leanings and a purported belief in eugenics as a blight on her accomplishments. In this captivating new biography, the renowned feminist historian Jean H. ...
Undoubtedly the most influential advocate for birth control even before the term existed, Margaret Sanger ignited a movement that has shaped our society to this day. Her views on reproductive rights have made her a frequent target of conservatives and so-called family values activists. Yet lately even progressives have shied away from her, citing socialist leanings and a purported belief in eugenics as a blight on her accomplishments. In this captivating new biography, the renowned feminist historian Jean H. Baker rescues Sanger from such critiques and restores her to the vaunted place in history she once held.
Trained as a nurse and midwife in the gritty tenements of New York’s Lower East Side, Sanger grew increasingly aware of the dangers of unplanned pregnancy—both physical and psychological. A botched abortion resulting in the death of a poor young mother catalyzed Sanger, and she quickly became one of the loudest voices in favor of sex education and contraception. The movement she started spread across the country, eventually becoming a vast international organization with her as its spokeswoman.
Sanger’s staunch advocacy for women’s privacy and freedom extended to her personal life as well. After becoming a wife and mother at a relatively early age, she abandoned the trappings of home and family for a globe-trotting life as a women’s rights activist. Notorious for the sheer number of her romantic entanglements, Sanger epitomized the type of “free love” that would become mainstream only at the very end of her life. That she lived long enough to see the creation of the birth control pill—which finally made planned pregnancy a reality—is only fitting.
—Women’s Review of Books
“Baker doesn’t rose-tint when it comes to Sanger’s difficult personality . . . and she remains an engaging writer even in her subject’s later years, where many biographies wilt . . . [Baker] has a knack for the well-chosen detail[.]”
—The Wall Street Journal
“Baker’s biography succeeds in taking readers on a fascinating journey into the world of the 1920s and ’30s, when the Comstock laws made even the act of distributing information about birth control a crime. The strength of Baker’s book is in her ability to contextualize Sanger within her own time, which may prompt even her harshest critics to reassess her legacy. Baker makes it clear that Sanger believed, above all else, that every woman should have the right to control all aspects of her reproductive life through the diligent use of birth control.”
“Baker accepts her subject, warts and all, and believes that by situating her in the context of her own times, Sanger emerges as a far more complex and sympathetic figure than her latter-day critics acknowledge.”
“Baker mixes impressive research and her own fierce analysis into an engaging narrative.”
—The Boston Globe
“Baker’s book is a thorough and engrossing portrayal of the relentless passion that drove Sanger to fight for the rights of women to access safe and easy birth control.”
—The Washington Independent Review of Books
“Best known as an advocate for spearheading the birth control movement, Margaret Sanger was an often-polarizing figure whose life Baker, a historian at Goucher College, expertly parses . . . This unbiased account underscores the ferocity of the fighter and the necessity of the fight.”
“Baker ably illuminates the time period, making clear the attitudes that Sanger confronted and the political and religious forces that were arrayed against her . . . A wealth of information about the birth-control movement and the dedicated woman who was long at the center of it.”
“Here is a lucid, compelling story about a long, complicated, and ultimately society-altering American life. For too long, the women’s movement has paid too little tribute to brave but difficult Margaret Sanger. Jean H. Baker has finally, firmly, and unforgettably placed her within the pantheon of feminist history.”
—Harold Holzer, historian and former press secretary to Bella S. Abzug
“It is a mark of the still controversial nature of birth control that Margaret Sanger remains a controversial subject. Now, finally, she has the biography she deserves. Jean H. Baker has restored Margaret Sanger to history and history to Margaret Sanger.”
—Ellen Dubois, Professor of History, UCLA
“Jean H. Baker’s fine book gives us a believable Margaret Sanger—brave, shrewd, attractive, and flawed.”
—Dorothy Ross, Arthur O. Lovejoy Professor Emerita of History, Johns Hopkins University
Now is a fitting time to reconsider the life of Margaret Sanger. The United Nations marked October 31, 2011 as the day the global population reached 7 billion, a milestone greeted with both celebration and consternation around the world. Sanger would have no doubt felt the latter: after World War II, the activist who worked for decades to make contraception legal and available for women in the United States and around the globe condemned "the worldwide congestion of population which cannot continue without worldwide misery, famine, and wars." She was, as historian Jean H. Baker demonstrates in Margaret Sanger: A Life of Passion, tenaciously single-minded, adept at linking any social problem to the need for birth control.
Though she's been dead for forty-five years, Sanger herself made it into the headlines around the time of the UN announcement, after Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain told Bob Schieffer on Face the Nation that Sanger's aim in founding the forerunner to Planned Parenthood was "preventing black babies from being born." Cain's ill-considered assertion demonstrates the extent to which Sanger's legacy has been distorted, but one need only turn to the first page of Baker's fine biography to discover the pervasiveness of such beliefs. Sanger, in addition to sounding prescient early warnings against overpopulation, was a visionary in her advocacy for female sexual autonomy, driving scientific research on a "magic pill" to prevent women from conceiving and exhorting women to enjoy sex whether or not its aim was reproduction. Yet Baker opens the book not with a summary of her accomplishments but with a rebuttal aimed at those who have, since Sanger's 1966 death, dismissed her as a eugenicist and a racist. Bemoaning the "inaccuracies, misrepresentations, and sound-bite misquotations that now encrust her historical reputation," the author marvels that even a staffer at a New York branch of Planned Parenthood — which grew out of Sanger's American Birth Control League — admitted that he avoids any mention of Sanger.
Without giving Sanger a complete pass — Baker acknowledges that her subject's backing of involuntary sterilization is "indefensible" - - she constructs a vigorous defense of Sanger's career as a whole, assessing Sanger's positions on eugenics in the context of her time and noting that her support for eliminating the unfit never focused on "a specific race or religion, only genetic or behavioral unfortunates." Baker argues that Sanger allied herself with the eugenics movement for pragmatic reasons. Up until the late 1930s eugenics enjoyed widespread approval; associating herself with what was seen as a progressive, scientific field offered increased legitimacy to her own program, which was then both marginal and shocking.
The author concludes that Sanger's support of eugenics reveals "her passion for the cause of birth control" — indeed, that passion is never in doubt. Sanger, born in 1879, grew up poor in a large family in Corning, New York, and she saw her mother ravaged by the effects of a whopping eighteen pregnancies (eleven births and seven miscarriages) during a thirty-year marriage. Later, working as a nurse on New York's impoverished Lower East Side, Sanger claimed to have been moved by a young mother — possibly a composite of several women — who, unable to care for any more children, died after a self-inflicted abortion; Sanger turned this episode into the "creation story of her movement." (One quibble: despite calling Sanger an "adroit fabulist" and her 1938 Autobiography "at best incomplete propaganda," Baker relies heavily on that book, as well as another memoir, 1931's My Fight for Birth Control, to flesh out Sanger's early life.)
From that point on Sanger worked tirelessly to promote birth control, pounding out books, periodicals, and pamphlets, giving speeches around the country and then the world, organizing conferences, and opening the nation's first free family-planning clinics for women. In 1914, she was arrested for violating the Comstock Act, which defined birth control as obscenity, for sending her journal The Woman Rebel through the mail. She was arrested again in 1916 for violating New York's obscenity laws by discussing birth control methods at her Brooklyn clinic; that case, on appeal, resulted in a ruling allowing doctors to discuss contraception with any married person who required the information for health reasons, part of the slow chipping away at birth control's illegal status.
Sanger's all-encompassing activism left her little time to raise her three children. The book's most heartbreaking passages quote letters from her two young sons, desperate to see the mother who had passed them off onto relatives and boarding schools; worse yet, her five-year-old daughter died after contracting pneumonia at a radical socialist boarding school where children endured harsh conditions, including insufficient food and a lack of heat. But somehow she found time for a fascinating and tumultuous private life. In addition to being a political cause, birth control was, in Baker's words, "a personal necessity" for Sanger, who, throughout two marriages, conducted sexual relationships with a wide variety of men. Though Sanger was not a remarkable beauty, Baker says she had a "seductive presence," evidenced by the many ardent letters she received from smitten lovers, including H. G. Wells, whom Sanger, confiding to her diary, called a "naughty little boy man."
Late in her career, in addition to spearheading funding and research for the Pill, Sanger adopted an increasingly internationalist approach, forming the International Planned Parenthood Federation and organizing conferences on overpopulation in Stockholm, Bombay, Tokyo, and New Delhi. She had always been loath to share control of her movement or credit for its accomplishments, and she became increasingly demanding and imperious. But there were some things she couldn't control: Sanger apparently grew irritated as her son Grant's family expanded to include six children born within ten years. It's difficult to resist theorizing that Grant kept procreating as payback for years of maternal neglect. One of those grandchildren, Alexander Sanger, now chairs the International Planned Parenthood Council. The debate over Herman Cain's remarks shows that Sanger's legacy is still contested, but her cause, in Baker's words, "lives on."
Barbara Spindel has covered books for Time Out New York, Newsweek.com, Details, and Spin. She holds a Ph.D. in American Studies.
Reviewer: Barbara Spindel
1 Maggie Higgins: Daughter of Corning 9
2 Mrs. William Sanger of Hastings-on-Hudson 27
3 Comrade Sanger 45
4 Creating Margaret Sanger 75
5 On Trial 101
6 The Birth Control Review 127
7 Voyages 159
8 Spreading the Word 195
9 All Things Fade 231
10 World Leader 267
Epilogue: Last Years 299
Posted July 29, 2014
Margaret Sanger was arguably one of, if not THE, most influential women of the twentieth century. Birth control
and family planning would never be the same, due to her strong force of personality and calculated efforts to
raise awareness of the issue of birth control. She got America: 1) to talk about it openly for the first time, and
2) agree that spacing children within marriage was actually a good idea. Then she built coalitions to support
clinics, to form national frameworks of supporters, then international networks, AND served as matchmaker/fairy
godmother to the researchers who developed The Pill, after she introduced an interested sponsor with deep
What I liked about this book is that Sanger's warmth, vibrancy comes through, but also, the author herself does
not seem 100% sold on "Saint Margaret." Her flaws and strengths are clearly depicted, along with a good feel
for the times when she was born, when she was a teen, and each succeeding social transition. America - and
the world was changing rapidly, from rural, agricultural nations to cities with automobiles and telephones.
Women got to vote!
This is an engaging look both at how one woman changed the world, but also a fascinating look at the history of
20th century America.