Top-Notch Mystery
With A Matter of Fear, Seymour Shubin has produced one of his finest and most compelling novels. To say that he has outdone himself would be to imply he has gone beyond some of his other fine works, but of course that's impossible. However, A Matter of Fear will certainly rank high on anyone's list of Shubin's best, along with his Edgar-nominated The Captain. Let's say that he at least equals his other literate and compelling crime novels here. In a 1970s era setting, Tom Loberg, age 28, lands a job with a vanity arm of a medical publishing house. The imprint issues books the editors don't think will sell particularly well, but that doctor authors will pay to have in print. Tom, though he doesn't like the job or respect his supervisor Sam Glennie, is glad to get a position that will possibly lead to better editorial jobs elsewhere. In the meantime, he meets a girl and falls in love--and acquires a manuscript through her connections. All is day-to-day routine at work until Tom's boss Glennie turns up drowned in the river--a suicide. But maybe not. Maybe Glennie had every reason to live. When Tom begins to think the death was murder, he tries to work out who and why against a peculiar background filled with odd, yet thoroughly believable characters. Shubin's greatest gift to his readers with this book is his authenticity. The realness of his people and their environment set fire to the suspense, and we, along with Tom, feel for Glennie and the bereaved wife and want to find out how such a thing could have happened. We're carried along right with our protagonist in no uncertain terms. Tom is purely sympathetic, from his reactions to his job, to his growing relationship with Tina, to his identification with Glennie whose life was sucked dry by this terrible workplace. Tom is a wonderful character, a young man who is wise to the world and growing weary, but who can be caught by the genuineness of a new love and who has a wonderful sense of humor he isn't afraid to exercise. Shubin, who has had many prior successes, has triumphed with this one, the pages of which readers will scarf up like potato chips. This is a fast and riveting read, different from the numerous pre-plotted stories that have proliferated in the marketplace over the last decade or so. I would definitely suggest this one to real crime fiction fans. No, it's not a cozy, nor is it hardboiled--neither cats nor bloody corpses spoil the fun. G. Miki Hayden, author of Writing the Mystery, a Macavity winner and Agatha and Anthony nomination.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Editorial Reviews
Kirkus Reviews
Shubin, who's been freelancing wide-ranging articles and stories since his last novel (Voices, 1985), settles on pharmaceutical chicanery for his return to full-length fiction. When drug manufacturer Packer-Hill Laboratories loses a patent, writer Tom Loberg finds himself jobless and in no position to refuse the only work offered to him: junior editorial hack under downtrodden Sam Glennie at the vanity-press division of medical publishers Mallory & Mallory. Sam is soon found floating in the river, an apparent suicide, but murder is the verdict more strongly implied when Tom goes through his files. For one thing, there's the ...