Merit: The History of a Founding Ideal from the American Revolution to the Twenty-First Century

Merit: The History of a Founding Ideal from the American Revolution to the Twenty-First Century

by Joseph F. Kett
     
 

View All Available Formats & Editions

The idea that citizens' advancement should depend exclusively on merit, on qualities that deserve reward rather than on bloodlines or wire-pulling, was among the Founding ideals of the American republic, Joseph F. Kett argues in this book.See more details below

Overview

The idea that citizens' advancement should depend exclusively on merit, on qualities that deserve reward rather than on bloodlines or wire-pulling, was among the Founding ideals of the American republic, Joseph F. Kett argues in this book.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly
Kett's survey provides a thorough and engaging account of the long history of and many paradoxes surrounding the American ideal of merit. A professor of American history at the University of Virginia, Kett begins this study by distinguishing essential merit, an innate quality only made visible by one's success in public life, from institutional merit, a quality defined by institutional measures such as standardized exams and professional credentials. America has long held various anxieties regarding the difficulty of accurately measuring or recognizing merit, and Kett suggests that this struggle has long complicated America's ambitions regarding equal rights and rule by popular consent. He traces the demands of valuing merit from their roots in English and European governance through American political, academic, business, and professional institutions, demonstrating how our changing relationship to this ideal casts a telling light on the development of American identity and values. Dense but well written, Kett's rigorous approach is appropriate for scholars, and though he periodically veers into Byzantine descriptions, the book is an approachable resource for anyone interested in his topic.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
From the Publisher
"The young American republic seemed a nation peculiarly conducive to recognizing merit, or a 'quality deserving reward' in public life. Here Kett traces the evolution of this ideal from the revolution forward, pointing out how merit frequently clashed with other ideals such as equality. . . . He succeeds in a tightrope performance, tying what seem disparate phenomena together in a frequently delightful narrative . . . . . Kett’s book has opened new historical avenues."—Library Journal (22 February 2013)

"Historian Kett (Univ. of Virginia) provides a wide-ranging history of the idea of merit, tracing its shaping of the US over the course of three centuries. Much has been written about the importance of 'equality' and 'consent' to the American experience; comparatively, 'merit' has been overlooked. For Kett, the US was 'born meritorious,' as advancement by merit was a pillar belief of American revolutionaries. . . . Summing Up: Recommended."—M.G. Spencer, Choice (September 2013)

"Kett's dense and detailed history argues that the ideal of merit was vital to the founding and development of the United States. . . This ambitious and wide-ranging book is an apt complement to such indispensable studies of the subject. . . " —Darrin M. McMahon, The Journal of Interdisciplinary History (April 2014)

"How societies recognize and reward talent is a fascinating historical subject. When the subject is studied properly, a nation's entire inner circuitry is exposed. A fair number of scholars have undertaken the task, and we are truly lucky to have Joseph F. Kett among them. An accomplished historian has written a wonderful book about American struggles to define merit ('worth,' 'desert') since the colonial period. A large and formidable body of source material has been perfectly digested, and national comparisons, notably with France and England, are accurate and to the point. They help readers understand the different national route the American Republic took to reach modernity. A compressed book review of a volume with so much on offer can only hint at the treasures within. Kett is in superb control of a complex narrative, which he never simplifies. The path to the present was scarcely straightforward. It was full of nuances, unintended consequences, and surprises, Clio at her most fickle. The necessary and fascinating detail notwithstanding, not for a moment does the historian lose sight of the logic of his main argument."—American Historical Review

"This book provides a veritable treasure trove of historical anecdotes, facts, statistics, and studies relating to American educational history and its intersections with American political history. The book is impressively researched throughout and provides a number of insightful suggestions at the intersections of American political history/theory and educational history/theory. For these reasons, Kett's book should prove valuable to a wide range of scholars of American political thought, including both historians and political scientists."—S. Adam Seagrave, Political Science Quarterly (Winter 2014-2015)

"Kett's history of decision making about talent is consistently strong and readable. . . . The bittersweet legacy for American history is a partial triumph of meritocracy. There is a perennial tension in attempts to reconcile equality and excellence. Setting asside abuses of blatant favoritism, a typical situaion is as thus: whether in admission to an academically selective college, in selecting candidates for a judgeship or cabinet position, in being hired as a CEO, or in choosing an award-winning book, the social fact is that often most applicants are qualified, perhaps highly qualified. The corollary is that even talented people can be left out in high-stakes competition. That may not be the way of the world, but as Kett's excellent book documents, it is the American way."—John R. Thelin, The Journal of Southern History(November 2014)

"A great virtue of this book—really a stunning notion—is that there are such things as a history of merit and a history of the idea of merit and its associated institutions in America. No one has ever written this book or anything close to it."—Michael Schudson, Columbia Journalism School, author of The Good Citizen: A History of American Civic Life

"In this brilliant book, Joseph F. Kett traces the history of merit in the United States as its meaning shifted from a personal quality to an institutionally certified warrant for allocating social rewards. As he shows, this evolution made schooling the central mechanism for distributing opportunity while at the same time subjecting schools to continual criticism for failing to distribute merit fairly."—David Labaree, Stanford University, author of Someone Has to Fail: The Zero-Sum Game of Public Schooling

"What is it you've earned and think you deserve but haven’t got? Joseph F. Kett takes this question all the way back to the Founding era, tracing meritocracy and its discontents up to the present. This is a tough-minded, contrarian book that takes a stand: the Founding ideal of the United States was not equality but rather merit. Kett’s historical insights on the origins of report cards, legacy admissions, the civil service, and intelligence testing add up to a challenging and bold argument that although life in these United States has never been fair, on the whole this nation is the fairest of them all."—Scott A. Sandage, author of Born Losers: A History of Failure in America

Library Journal
The young American republic seemed a nation peculiarly conducive to recognizing merit, or a “quality deserving reward” in public life. Here Kett (history, Univ. of Virginia) traces the evolution of this ideal from the revolution forward, pointing out how merit frequently clashed with other ideals such as equality. He shows how “essential merit,” possessed owing to inner qualities, gave way to “institutional merit,” awarded by schools, colleges, and corporate or governmental bureaucracies. In Kett’s story, readers will encounter politicians operating spoils systems, progressives attempting to rationalize the civil service, college students vying for commencement addresses, educators instituting grading systems, university officials bent on professional credentialing, psychologists developing a multitude of testing instruments, and others devising systematic gradations among Americans who lacked the visible record of public achievement characteristic of “Men of Merit” in early America.

Verdict While occasionally readers may wonder if they are actually still reading about merit, as Kett traces one manifestation of it to another, he succeeds in a tightrope performance, tying what seem disparate phenomena together in a frequently delightful narrative that interested academic readers will relish. Kett’s book has opened new historical avenues, as he has done before in books like The Pursuit of Knowledge Under Difficulties, his study of self-education.—Robert Nardini, Niagara Falls, NY

(c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Read More

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780801451225
Publisher:
Cornell University Press
Publication date:
01/15/2013
Series:
American Institutions and Society Series
Pages:
344
Sales rank:
1,429,051
Product dimensions:
6.10(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.30(d)

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >