Inevitably,
Modern Man will be compared to the 1966 output of
the George Benson Quartet -- an organ combo who the famous guitarist/singer led back when
hard bop was still his primary focus.
Benson is among guitarist
Bobby Broom's various influences, and this 2000 date favors the same guitar/organ/baritone sax/drums format that
Benson's 1966 combo was known for. Further, half of that outfit (organist
Dr. Lonnie Smith and baritone saxman
Ronnie Cuber) is employed on
Modern Man, with veteran drummer
Idris Muhammad rounding out the lineup. But while comparisons to the classic
Benson group are unavoidable,
Broom is his own man -- and this
hard bop/
soul-jazz effort isn't a
Benson tribute.
Broom and his colleagues don't play
Benson Quartet items like
"Clockwise" and
"The Cooker," and their choice of material ranges from
Broom and
Cuber originals to
Hank Mobley's
"A Peck a Sec," Stevie Wonder's
"Superstition," and the
Burt Bacharach/
Hal David favorite
"I'll Never Fall in Love Again" (which is one of the more lyrical offerings on a CD that tends to be aggressive and hard-swinging). To his credit,
Broom doesn't limit himself to the Great American Songbook;
"Old Devil Moon" is the album's only beaten-to-death warhorse. Especially surprising is
Broom's interpretation of
Derek & the Dominos'
"Layla," which ends up sounding perfectly natural as a moody, smoky,
jazz-noir instrumental.
Broom's interesting
"Layla" makeover reminds listeners how sad it is that so many
bop and
post-bop musicians insist on ignoring the
rock and
R&B songs of the '60s, '70s, '80s, and '90s -- if they would open up their minds, they would realize that worthwhile popular music didn't die with
George Gershwin or
Cole Porter. Is
Modern Man innovative? Certainly not, but it has its share of surprises and is well worth picking up for die-hard organ combo enthusiasts. ~ Alex Henderson
