Barbara Ostafin, Folia Orientalia, 1995.
'...un outil exceptionnel...Un tel ouvrage...permet aussi, mieux que toutes les introductions à la poésie arabe, de se faire une idée plus précise des conditions dans lesquelles la poésie préislamique était composée...il serait souhaitable que la lecture de ces travaux soit conseillée, et même fortement recommandée à ceux qui entreprennent de s'initier à la langue et à la littérature arabes anciennes.'
Bruno Paoli, Bulletin d'Etudes Orientales, 1995.
'Throughout its considerable length, this second volume displays the same literary insight, sociological acumen, and meticulous attention to scholarly detail as the first volume. It is an entertaining as well as erudite study, beautifully produced, and, like its predecessor, is frequently illuminated by flashes of a refreshing and self-deprecating humor. Would that all academic monographs were as readable as this...This book is a must for a wide variety of readers: social and cultural anthropologists of every hue, but especially of Arabia; literary historians of Arabic; and, last but not least, Arabic dialectologistss. On the strenght of these first two volumes, there seems little doubt that Kurpershoek's odyssey through the oral culture of Arabia is destined to take its place as a classic work in the field.'
Clive Holes, Journal of the American Oriental Society, 1998.
'The book lives up to the expectations earned by the previous volume, Kurpershoek has filled in important gaps in our knowledge of the poetry, history and dialects of the region and provided an encyclopedic reference work on the 'Utaibah, in particular, who have not up till now been treated extensively in any language and not at all in English. We look forward to the appearance of the third volume in the series.'
B. Ingham, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, 1998.