"I have learnt much more from Leary about the Upper Midwest's vernacular music than I have from the many books and articles I have read on Dylan."Michael Pickering, Folk Music Journal
"It's an intriguing title, and Leary makes a cogent case for a hybrid music of the Upper Midwest, a mix of American, English, German, Scandinavian and country music that's developed over the last century or moreAt the very least it's an interesting tale that gathers several strands of American and immigrant history. As a history of upper Midwestern fold music, this makes a very interesting and informative read." Sing Out!
"This is a well-researched look at an overlooked form of American folk music."Anything Phonographic
"Jim Leary has written a rich masterpiece about people and music, cultural processes, and meanings in a part of America long misunderstood or ignored. His treatment of the Goose Island Ramblers is as engaging as their personalities and the music they play from neighborhood bars to country fairs ...Full of the humor of the real folks from places defined too often by stereotypes, Polkabilly is a fine personal and musical history."Nick Spitzer, Professor of Folklore, University of New Orleans, and Host, American Routes, Public Radio International
"Jim Leary has produced a rich, scholarly, and lively account of the making of the little known folk music of the Upper Midwest. He has thus at last raised that style from its local base to its proper place alongside the more familiar, nationally known musics, such as jazz, country, zydeco and others. Leary shows how this regional style is unique in its blending of resident ethnic cultures, from groups originating from the Baltic to the Balkans. The result is indeed Polkabilly, and its promoters, the Goose Island Ramblers."Victor Greene, Emeritus Professor of Ethnic History, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
"This is an impressive and convincing piece of scholarship! Those who read it will come away with not only a more sophisticated and nuanced understanding of the vernacular music of the Upper Midwest, but also a broader perspective of what American rural music really is. Jim Leary reminds us, too, that the infectious polkabilly music of the Goose Island Ramblers is both a tribute to American pluralism and a testimony of the marvelous ways in which our working people have sustained their lives and identities."Bill C. Malone, Professor Emeritus of History, Tulane University
"Polkabilly is one of the most important books on American music in recent years. It is meticulously documented and tells an important story, not just about the Goose Island Ramblers, but dozens of other polkabilly musicians of the Upper Midwest." Journal of American Folklore
"As much as I enjoyed this book for my nostalgic romp through the familiar and exotic Wisconsin locales of Lodi, Oulu, Rice Lake and Boscobel, I enjoyed it even more for its informative account of the origins and context of the Goose Island Ramblers, for its passionate argument for a re-evaluation of Midwestern U.S. musical culture, and for its insights into the everyday musical life of the region...Meticulously researched." Gage Averill, Yearbook for Traditional Music