Microsoft Shrugged
John Heilemann has written a book critically adulatory of each and every possible competitor of Microsoft, suggesting, in Marxian economic substructure analysis, that the San Francisco Bay area dollar sources supporting him have perhaps produced a certain moral viewpoint here In fact, the strange triumphalism pervading ¿Pride Before the Fall¿ reminds me of how Ayn Rand might have written about Microsoft during some brief hallicinatory experience during which she convinced herself that she was really a socialist. We have all the elements of character-adoration and character demonization, with which the author paints Gates as sort of an anti-Hank Reardon character (whereas the Seattle people would probably endorse Gates as the new Hank Reardon) and then Heilemann goes on to portray the various vicious and petty government functionaries and regulators as larger than life heroes. Very disturbingly, these government crusaders turn out to have all kind of furtive little conference calls and meetings with a very highly organized group of Microsoft-haters, all of whom want to co-opt the federal executive power, to get the United States judicial power to beat up Bill, and with the help of the legislative branch in the form of Orrin Hatch, who pals around with the general counsel of Sun Microsystems, and whose staff guy apparently leaks great scoops to journalists. What this tells you is that politics does indeed create strange bed fellows, and the reporting of the synchronized relationships between Joel Klein, Kleiner Perkins Caulfield & Byers, as well as Apple, Intel, IBM, and various other disgruntled software companies, is incredible. Not only do they concoct and feed the case to Joel Klein, but now (after this book was written) Klein has gone ahead and joined AOL (following AOL¿s recombination with Netscape and CBS, as well as its strategic relationship with Sun Microsystems ¿ and guess what Sun Microsystems does? It passes out a free suite of office programs containing a free browser all of which can run on a free Linux operating system!) Then the only difference between what the AOL/NetScape/Sun people are doing and Microsoft has done better, is that Microsoft has simply done it better. The central flaw in the anti-Microsoft mania started by Netscape is laid bare on page 140 of this book, but Heilemann refuses to understand the point he has made. Heilemann states ¿at the end of 1994, Netscape sales were zero, its capital was evaporating, and it was facing a potentially crushing intellectual-property lawsuit by the University of Illinois.¿ This is a convenient starting point for any analysis claiming Netscape was harmed by Microsoft giving away a browser (and I guess we have to use that point since Sun now gives one away for free as well). Step back from that timeframe for just a few months, and you will step into a world where browers were always free, until Netscape essentially copied what was developed for free at the University of Illinois and put a different name on it, hyping itself into a multi-billion dollar IPO. But the norm for browers before Netscape was always that they were free. But Microsoft must be demonized before being disembowled, and part of the campaign is to accuse Microsoft and its Chairman of having a 'bad attitude.' As if this were junior high and Joel Klein were the principal. An alternative explanation is that this whole legal charade could be more like 'Ferris Buehler's Day Off,' and that Gates may get away with actually producing more functional software for a better price, in spite of his well-connected competitors. So we really have to take this book as a sociological expression of the anti-Microsoft forces, and at that level, it is true to itself, and helpful to anyone seeking to diagnose the forces at work seeking to destroy Mr. Gates. The character profiles and interesting insider information about Senator Hatch, Joel Klein, Gary Reback, David Boies, and John Warden, make
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
The humbling of Bill Gates and Microsoft is the last great business story of the 20th Century and the first great riddle of the 21st. How did the richest man in the world, the most powerful icon of the New Economy, wind up being pursued and attacked by his own government? And how did a company that had utterly dominated the technology landscape find itself weakened, vulnerable, and under threat of a court-ordered breakup?John Heilemann's Pride Before the Fall uncovers the secret history of the trial that shook an economy: United States v. Microsoft. Drawing on years of reporting - including extensive interviews with Gates and other top Microsoft executives, Justice Department trustbuster...