Principles of Social Justice / Edition 1

by David Miller

Overview

Social justice has been the animating ideal of democratic governments throughout the twentieth century. Even those who oppose it recognize its potency. Yet the meaning of social justice remains obscure, and existing theories put forward by political philosophers to explain it have failed to capture the way people in general think about issues of social justice. This book develops a new theory. David Miller argues that principles of justice must be understood contextually, with each principle finding its natural home in a different form of human association. Because modern societies are complex, the theory of justice must be complex, too. The three primary components in Miller’s scheme are the principles of desert, need, and equality.

The book uses empirical research to demonstrate the central role played by these principles in popular conceptions of justice. It then offers a close analysis of each concept, defending principles of desert and need against a range of critical attacks, and exploring instances when justice requires equal distribution and when it does not. Finally, it argues that social justice understood in this way remains a viable political ideal even in a world characterized by economic globalization and political multiculturalism. Accessibly written, and drawing upon the resources of both political philosophy and the social sciences, this book will appeal to readers with interest in public policy as well as to students of politics, philosophy, and sociology.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780674007147
Publisher:	Harvard University Press
Publication date:	09/30/2001
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	352
Product dimensions:	6.12(w) x 9.25(h) x 1.00(d)

About the Author

David Miller is Official Fellow and Professor of Political Theory at Nuffield College, Oxford.

Table of Contents

Preface

1. The Scope of Social Justice

2. A Sketch of a Theory of Justice

3. Social Science and Political Philosophy

4. Distributive Justice:What the People Think

5. Procedures and Outcomes

6. Virtues, Practices, and Justice

7. The Concept of Desert

8. Deserving Jobs

9. Two Cheers for Meritocracy

10. "To Each According to His Needs"

11. Equality and Justice

12. Prospects for Social Justice

Notes

Credits

Index

Editorial Reviews

This groundbreaking book explores…how extremely divergent views about what is required to bring about justice might be reconciled when they stem from shared beliefs at a deeper level… This is a complex and ambitious book. Instead of proposing a normative theory of social justice, Miller illustrates how different principles are used in different social contexts. His theory of justice does more than simply report popular beliefs, however. It presents principles of need, desert, and equality that are philosophically coherent and blended together to form a cohesive theory.

Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare - Dorothy Van Soest

As with all David Miller’s work, a high level of scrupulousness marks Principles of Social Justice. He remains unswayed by ideological and philosophical background noise—no mean feat with this topic—and, as always, displays a distrust of grand generalization. The exposition, lucid and wholly unpretentious, is a model of its kind. And the argument is impressively sustained throughout, with some particularly acute remarks about the role of luck in judgments of desert, and about the relevance of procedures to just outcomes.

Times Literary Supplement - Glen Newey

This groundbreaking book explores...how extremely divergent views about what is required to bring about justice might be reconciled when they stem from shared beliefs at a deeper level...This is a complex and ambitious book. Instead of proposing a normative theory of social justice, Miller illustrates how different principles are used in different social contexts. His theory of justice does more than simply report popular beliefs, however. It presents principles of need, desert, and equality that are philosophically coherent and blended together to form a cohesive theory.
— Dorothy Van Soest

Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare

As with all David Miller's work, a high level of scrupulousness marks Principles of Social Justice. He remains unswayed by ideological and philosophical background noise—no mean feat with this topic—and, as always, displays a distrust of grand generalization. The exposition, lucid and wholly unpretentious, is a model of its kind. And the argument is impressively sustained throughout, with some particularly acute remarks about the role of luck in judgments of desert, and about the relevance of procedures to just outcomes.
— Glen Newey

Times Literary Supplement

As with all of David Miller's work, a high level of scrupulousness marks Principles of Social Justice.
—Times Literary Supplement

Glen Newey