Red Light Women of the Rocky Mountainsby Jan MacKell
Pub. Date: 03/16/2009
Publisher: University of New Mexico Press
These profiles of the soiled doves who plied the oldest trade in the Rocky Mountains explain many of the facts of life in the nineteenth and twentieth century West. See more details below
These profiles of the soiled doves who plied the oldest trade in the Rocky Mountains explain many of the facts of life in the nineteenth and twentieth century West.
- University of New Mexico Press
- Publication date:
- Edition description:
- New Edition
- Sales rank:
- Product dimensions:
- 6.30(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.50(d)
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >
Jan MacKell has done it again; she has written a fine book on old west prostitution. Her first book, BROTHELS, BORDELLOS, & BAD GIRLS: PROSTITUTION IN COLORADO 1860-1930 was an outstanding addition to American pioneer prostitute literature. She has expanded her horizons with this new book and focuses on the profession of prostitution as it operated in the states of Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming. MacKell addresses the profession of prostitution, prostitutes and madams, and the societal reaction to prostitution. The author's writing style is smooth and comfortable. The material she presents is well-documented and she provides numerous endnotes. It is clear that she has spent years gathering information through extensive travel and research. This is a big plus for researchers such as myself. The text is liberally illustrated with photographs, some which have never been published. She uses many primary sources to introduce the reader to numerous prostitutes and madams. Many of these women have not been discussed in contemporary prostitute literature. This book is not a rehash of other books; rather, MacKell presents new information on an old topic. This text will serve well as a basic reference book. It will hopefully make its way into libraries across the United States. This book will provide material for those writing articles, books, theses, and dissertations. Although well-documented, the book is no dry academic publication. MacKell is a good storyteller with rich information. She brings the ladies to life and explains the conditions in which they worked, telling their stories in a very readable fashion. This book will appeal to those who wish to know what prostitution was like back then. RED LIGHT WOMEN OF THE ROCKY MOUNTAINS is a must read for anyone interested in pioneer prostitution on the American frontier.
This is a sound history on the presence of prostitutes in the Rocky Mountain region in the latter 1800s and into the first couple of decades of the 1900s. No racy photographs or snide comments. During this time, the area was mostly in the early stages of its development. Areas of it were still territories, not yet states. Yet the areas were settled enough and populated enough to support the prostitutes' trade. One vein of MacKell's history is the changing attitudes toward and position of prostitutes as the area became more developed and new waves of populations moved in. At different times, prostitutes could have an important economic role in a community, exert political influence, and in ways not acknowledged or much studied contribute to the growth and stability of location. The book is in a popular style with an academic underpinning of extensive research well-documented in over 60 pages of notes. MacKell focuses attention of the presence, activities, and effects of prostitutes in the several territories/states of the region in chapters with witty titles such as Amazons of Arizona, Illicit Ladies of Idaho, Nubians of New Mexico, and The Undoing of Utah's Soiled Doves. One learns a good deal about prostitutes in the western states in this era of their early development. With economical biographies of many madams running establishments and of particular prostitutes, including true-crime like stories of some, the history is as colorful as any about the Old West. Wyatt Earp consorted with a prostitute for a while, and there were ones involved in murders, robberies, and other crimes. The changing acceptance, views, visibility, influence, etc., of prostitutes in the several territories/states--a dimension of the subject MacKell also gives attention to--reflect the varying levels of development in them and also their varied particular paths of development. Despite the acceptance of prostitutes and in some cases, invitations for them, they inevitably remained on the margins. Even when they were politically influential or economically important, their standing was always contingent and almost always discreet. The author has some fun with the subject, which is fun for the reader. But basically her work is a solid history to go alongside others on particular aspects of U.S. western history and lore. The amount of experienced research and great volume of content mark this book as a fundamental work on the subject.
I found this book amazing. Mis-catagorized as non-fiction, a simple editor slip, probably because the author holds an MA in history from the University of Colorado, but amazing even so. Prostitution history is discussed covering seven states, with only a few new discoveries to the avid reader on the topic, despite hefty 400+ page book. The most amazing new discovery is found on page 2: "Lewis and Clark notably held that respect for the famed Sacajawea. This strong and courageous woman who gave birth along the trail while leading the men West may actually have functioned as a part-time prostitute for them as well." While the author is careful to use the words "may have" she directs the reader to footnote source #9 for verification. That source is esteemed author and professor Dr. Volney Steele of the Montana State University. Problem is on page 60 of his book, Bleed, Blister and Purge, Dr. Steele says nothing of the sort regarding Sacajawea's possible "part-time" prostitution employment. So goes the rest of this book with copious footnotes that lead to other conclusions or interpretations of the matter rather than those of the writer. In fact, the author draws no conclusions of her own on anything, rather regurgitates other writer's views that are old or have been furthered by new research which the author doesn't see fit to bring into her speculation on the subject. Repleat are the internet sources including wikipedia and various drinking bar web sites taking up much of the nearly 75 pages of footnote sources. This is a great example of late night surfing research. Scholarly research-not so much.
Glancing through the book before reading, I looked over Chapter 9 "Where Did They All Go?" In the Colorado section I read about the Crooked Creek Saloon in Fraser and the supposed ghost, Rosie. And her note for her research??? The bar's website!!! Good follow up. My grandparents came to Fraser before 1907 - my parents built the present-day Crooked Crook in 1931. I have abstracts of the property back to the platting of the town. There was nothing on the property before 1931. (Also Jan Mackell says it was built 25 years later - again wrong) And the painting of Rosie? Where is that fictional creation supposed to be? Through the years of "around the kitchen table talk" the locations of the brothels and individual houses were discussed. I know where many of them were. The tale of Rosie was made up by two of the later bar owners Tim Kinney and Mike Winey. And now according to this book it is entered as "history". Good going. Jan why didn't you talk to the Grand County Historical Association or any of the old-timer locals? Bar's webside indeed. On to Mary Jane - she was an actual person - but the small daughter of a miner who named his mining claim after her. This claim was south of Winter Park. Nowhere but in this book was the fictional whore Mary Jane associated with Fraser proper. The research of other people may have been tweaked by Ms Mackell. All in all - knowing what I do of this specific portion - it makes all of her book pretty shaky.