River: A Song

River: A Song

by Bill Staines, Kate Spohn

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
A nostalgic, '60s feel colors this illustrated version of Staines's song about the metaphorical river of life, ``ever moving and winding and free.'' Like many lyrics presented independently of their music, these lose much of their rhythm and depth here. The narrator, serenading the ``changing old river,'' tells of being ``born in the path of the winter wind / and raised where the mountains are old.'' Spohn's impressionistic paintings, with their thick brush strokes and almost primitive human figures, particularize the story, depicting a woman artist who feels ``the music within her rise / like the wind in the autumn trees'' and who, having had a good life, offers a toast: ``Here's to the rainbow that followed me here'' and ``to the song that's within me now.'' In keeping with the haziness of the memories that suffuse the text, Spohn's art is muted, emptied of the momentum of her paintings for Hide and Seek in the Yellow House and of the precision of the colored-pencil drawings for Ruth's Bake Shop . The backward glance adopted in this volume, however, will probably appeal more to adults than to children. All ages. (Mar.)
School Library Journal
Gr 2-4-Staines's song paints an eloquent image of a ``rolling...changing old river.'' His love for the subject is evident, and the lilting rhythm of the poetry carries readers ``down to the sea.'' However, Spohn's highly impressionistic art gets in its way. Her double-page paintings are vague and simplistic. They are uninteresting and unlikely to hold readers' attention. In the hands of a singing storyteller, this title could succeed. However, Staines's All God's Critters Got a Place in the Choir (Dutton, 1989) is a more appealing choice.-Dot Minzer, North Barrington School, Barrington, IL

Product Details

Penguin Young Readers Group
Publication date:
Product dimensions:
8.32(w) x 10.28(h) x 0.37(d)

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Post to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews