Good and Bad; Right and Wrong
Good and bad; right and wrong; they don't always go together as we think they should.
The Seeker by Ann Gabhart is romance, and romance lovers won't mind the cheesiness that creeps in very occasionally. Fans of Gone with the Wind will eat up the opening party scene on the verge of the American Civil War. The female lead, Charlotte Vance, daughter of a Kentucky state senator, has all the spunk of Scarlet O'Hare as well as her love for the land. There is even a Rhet Butler character who steals passionate kisses in the rose garden, but from there the story takes completely different directions.
Charlotte follows Edwin (the "Ashley" character) to the local Shaker village where her plans to win him back fail completely. She must learn to submit her plans to the Lord, take her needs to him in prayer and trust him even as she cannot commit herself to the Shaker way of life. Meanwhile Adam Wade, illustrator for the popular newspaper Harper's Weekly, goes his way to draw the scenes of war, haunted by memories of the beautiful girl in the garden.
Gabhart knows the Shakers well and presents them with sympathy. I find myself identifying with their values of simplicity, peace, equality and hard work, and yet from a Biblical standpoint, they were heretics. They believed their founder, Ann Lee, was the second coming of Christ in female form. After all, if God made both male and female in his image, he must be feminine as well as masculine. This gender equality sounds very twenty-first century, but elevating Mother Ann to the level of Christ and praying to her as well as the Eternal Father is blasphemous to any biblical Christian.
Gabhart presents some Shakers as grim; others as finding serenity in the Shaker way of life. Edwin, Charlotte's intended at the beginning of the book, blossoms and seems to find confidence in a way that he never had growing up in his grandmother's shadow. But as Charlotte's former maid, Mellie, says, "We'd best keep our eyes fastened on Jesus till we know more about this Mother Ann and her spirit fruit." (p.162)
So how is right thinking related to righteous behavior? The Shakers were guilty of gross heresy, but their reputation for peace, a strong work ethic and feeding the hungry (as many as 14,000 in one day after the Battle of Perryville!) has been handed down for more than a century. (They are also known for the "lively" worship that gave them their popular name and the weird doctrine forbidding marriage, which played no small part in their dying out.)
Gabhart doesn't examine the question theologically. She presents people with strengths and weaknesses, joys and pain, growing as they interact with one another in the context of a Shaker village and a terrible war. Her writing is excellent, and she left me with a great deal to think about.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.