After 20 years in jail for a murder he may not have committed, a man is pursued by the detective who put him away.
In this cop-and-robber tale, Blauner (The Last Good Day, 2003, etc) does admirable work trying to get inside the robber’s head, leaving readers truly mystified as to whom the good guy might be until the jaw-dropping conclusion. Back in 1983, a young doctor was murdered in the apartment building where 17 year old Julian Vega’s dad was the super. Julian’s blood was found at the scene and he had no alibi. Zealous interrogation by eager young detective Frank X. Loughlin elicited other damning details that got the boy convicted. After two decades in jail, Julian is released (but still presumed guilty) when a judge rules that his lawyer gave him bad counsel. While he’s having a hell of a time acclimating, another young doctor is murdered under similar circumstances. Loughlin suspects the man he nailed 20 years ago, but a DNA test finds that the blood at the new murder scene belongs not to Julian but to the woman he supposedly killed in 1983. Blauner switches between the two men, each floundering in his own way. Francis is the classic overextended NYPD dick; trying to keep his addictions to alcohol and danger under control, holding out for that pension and slowly going blind as well. Julian is the same mixed-up, socially miscast teenager who went to jail, now hardened and reflexively violent, with a grudge against the world. Both have something to prove Francis that he didn’t convict the wrong man, Julian that he’s not a killer and for both, the other man stands in his way.
A gripping crime story with an unusually powerful sense of character.
An excellent mystery novel, written with a certain literary flair that elevates it above the usual cop-versus-ex-con yarn.
Read an Excerpt
As soon as he walked through the wrought-iron gates and out into the pastoral green expanse of Cricklewood Cemetery, Francis X. Loughlin heard the tranquility of a mid-October afternoon being torn open by the crunk and whine of a hard-working backhoe.
He looked around, trying to figure out where they were making the hole. Nothing was where it was supposed to be anymore. Another rude metallic thud sent a flock of geese flying high over a mausoleum down by Cypress Pond. He watched the birds disappear from his line of vision a second before he expected them to, another sign of the natural order being disturbed.
He took a left at the first granite angel and followed the sound of the machinery up Hemlock Avenue, passing the tree-shaded urn gardens, catafalques, and overground sarcophaguses, the society matrons not far from the stevedores, the nuns near the baseball stars, the Indian Princesses beside the Hat Check Kings, the Natural Causes next to the Sudden Demises.
Would it make the job any easier if they could all talk for an hour? Or would the sheer cacophony just be overwhelming? What happened? What do you mean, that's it? Tony did it! 911 is a joke. But I wanted so much more! He shielded his eyes from a gust of flying specks. Would you even be able to hear one soft high girlish voice saying, "Excuse me, but I don't belong here."
He lumbered on past a Civil War memorial, a bruiser-weight white guy in a three-quarter length leather coat, with boxing glove shoulders, an Etruscan chest, and more or less the gut he deserved at forty-nine. His hairline had retreated up to the grassy hinterlands, revealing a pair of dark rapscallion's eyebrows over a debauched cherub's face. Women still liked him, though, because he could listen attentively without interrupting to talk about the Giants and because he seemed like a man who could take broken things and give them back fixed without a lot of pissing and moaning about how hard it had been.
Maybe not quite twenty years, he decided. The ground had no give to it when they first buried her. There was frost on the headstones, icicles on the crypts, and the trees' branches were broken blood vessels against a white sky. Maybe after Thanksgiving.
A sharp breeze shivered the red maples and sent a wash of dead leaves past his ankles. He felt something catch in his pant cuff and reached down to find a fifty dollar bill stuck there. He picked it up and examined it, seeing it was not just fake but half-burnt. Another gust of wind carried the odd mingled scents of roast duck and smoldering incense. His eyes searched for an explanation, over the stone crosses and up the hill, before they found a Chinese family in black gathered on a rise, traditional candles and flowers arrayed around a casket covered in netting.
"Hey, Francis X, que pasa?" A voice called out from behind him. "Wake up. We've been waving to you for like two minutes."
He turned and saw a half-dozen people gathered around an open grave, staring at him like a groom who'd shown up drunk at his own wedding. His eyes adjusted as he recognized most of them as either being from D.A.'s office or the Medical Examiner's office. Behind them, the backhoe kept working, digging up a grave by the headstone, Allison Wallis, 1955-1983. A steel claw reaching into a shallow hole and emerging with a mouthful of dirt. It pivoted and disgorged its load out on to the plywood boards laid out to protect the grass, the smell of topsoil hitting wood setting off a writhing of worms in his gut.
"Hey, hey, Scottie, word up." Francis put on a game face as he went over to greet the video tech, who'd set up his camera tripod over the trench.
"Not the same old same old, eh, Francis?" said Scott Ferguson, a big bluff guy with a walrus moustache from the Visual Evidence Unit who was always handing out business cards, trying to get weekend work filming weddings, bar mitzvahs and christenings. "Usually when you put 'em down, they stay down." v
Normally he only ran into Scottie at crime scenes, when there was literally still blood on the walls. "So whassup?" said Scottie. "I tried to ask Paul, but he said this is your clambake."
"Did he now?"
Francis looked across the grave where Paul Raedo, his erstwhile friend, the prosecutor, was having an animated discussion with a lady from the ME's office, pointing his way every few seconds, trying to reassign the blame no doubt. Four members of the gravediggers' union stood by in their green uniforms, leaning on picks and shovels, waiting to do the more exacting work of digging around the coffin.
"Well, he told me one thing," Scottie admitted. "He said it's the fucking weirdest case he ever heard of."
"Don't believe the hype."
"Well, I don't know what the hell else you'd call it. Girl's dead twenty years and her blood shows up on another body last week."
"Sounds like fucking Paul told you plenty." Francis glared.
The backhoe grunted and rocked on its stabilizers as little brown plumes wafted from the gouge, drizzling dust on the people nearby. Francis took some small measure of satisfaction in seeing Paul cough and try to brush the grit off his lapels.
"So what's up with that?" asked Scottie. "You got the wrong girl buried?"
"That's what her mother thinks," said Francis, remembering how he'd stood on this very spot with Eillen Wallis, a hand on her arm to keep her from jumping in after her daughter. "I'm trying to keep an open mind."
"And what about the guy you locked up for it? Paul said he was in the can twenty years."
"He's not the happiest horse in the race, but what are you gonna do? I still got one eye on him. Everybody did something."
The machine kept digging. Each chooff of metal going into soil another little dig to his solar plexus, another reminder that something had gone wrong on his watch. The doctor brings you into the world, the undertaker signs you out, and if something goes wrong in between, the police are supposed to step up. He might have had his lapses, but if you needed someone to get you from crime scene to the grave, he always figured he was the man for the job. Not necessarily to comfort the bereaved the way a priest or a funeral director would - just to keep the game honest. But now he felt like he'd let down his people. He was supposed to be their representative, their servant, their envoy; a politician for the Dead. Who else was going to make sure their needs got met? Who else was going to twist arms, make phone calls, knock on doors, and filibuster on their behalf? Who else was supposed to speak up and fight like they were his core constituents?
"So do I smell a lawsuit in the wind or is somebody burning incense?" Scottie sniffed.
"Chinese funeral up the hill."
Francis pointed with his half-singed dollar to where a bell was softly chiming, joss sticks were fuming and a monk in saffron robes was leading the family in chanting.
"They pay people to come or something?"
"Nah." Francis folded the bill up and stuck it in his breast pocket. "It's hell money."
"Hell money. Spending cash for the afterlife. You let the dead go hungry, they might come back and haunt you."
"Maybe you ought to toss it in there instead." The tech nodded as one of the gravediggers looked down into the pit and gave a thumbs up. "Somebody's getting an attitude."
"Might be a little late for that already," said Francis,
Slowly the steel claw retracted and the men climbed into the hole with their picks and shovels, ready to start separating the casket from the dirt.