The New York Times Book Review - Sarah Harrison Smith
…Sophie and her parents bring a little too much intensity to everything they do. But that manic energy makes what could be just a sweet story into something far more fun.
Debut author Miller takes the idea of playing with one’s food to another level in this sensitive but funny story about a girl’s affection for a squash. When Sophie selects a butternut squash at the farmer’s market, her parents assume they will be having it for dinner. Sophie, however, quashes that plan by adopting the vegetable as her new best friend and naming her Bernice (“It was just the right size to hold in her arms.... Just the right size to love”). Despite gentle prodding to relinquish Bernice before she rots, Sophie brings her deteriorating pal to the library and somersaults with her in the yard. Miller’s easygoing storytelling taps into the familiar scenario of children making fierce attachments to favorite objects; Sophie is passionate without being bratty, her parents are pragmatic but not harsh, and Sophie eventually makes new friends, including Bernice’s offspring. Wilsdorf’s (Five Funny Bunnies) winsome ink-and-watercolor scenes adeptly capture both Sophie’s many moods (“Don’t listen, Bernice!” she scowls when her mother suggests baking the squash with marshmallows) and her unruly pigtails. Ages 3–7. Author’s agent: Ammi-Joan Paquette, Erin Murphy Literary Agency. (Aug.)
From the Publisher
Starred Review, Booklist, August 1, 2013:
"In a perfect blend of story and art, the humorous watercolor-and-ink illustrations are bursting with color and energy on every page... This is a paean to love and friendship, which can come in all species, shapes, and sizes."
Starred Review, School Library Journal, July 2013:
"With lessons on life, love, and vegetable gardening, this tale will be cherished by children, and their parents will be happy to read it to them often."
Starred Review, Publishers Weekly, May 27, 2013:
"Sensitive but funny... Miller’s easygoing storytelling taps into the familiar scenario of children making fierce attachments to favorite objects."
Starred Review, Kirkus Reviews, June 1, 2013:
"This season-spanning turn with high-spirited Sophie offers endearing lessons about nurture and regeneration."
Children's Literature - Vicki Foote
Sophie is a little girl who picks out a squash at a farmers' market and likes it so well that it becomes her best friend. She decides to name the squash Bernice and takes it with her everywhere. She puts Bernice to bed each night in a crib next to her bed. Her mother suggests that they bake the squash because the squash will soon get mushy. Her dad tries to get her interested in dolls or trucks. Sophie insists that Bernice will last forever. Winter comes and the squash becomes softer, so Sophie asks a farmer what a squash needs in order to be healthy. He tells her that it needs fresh air, clean dirt, and a little love. Sophie makes a bed in the soil and tucks Bernice in for the night. It snows during the night and in the morning, Sophie finds that the squash is covered with snow. Her parents give her a new friend, a fish in a bowl, and eventually she begins to like the fish. In the spring, Sophie finds that the squash has sprouted and soon grows two tiny squash. Sophie is happy that now she has two new friends to love. The illustrations are interesting and fun. Young children will identify with Sophie's attachment. This odd and whimsical story about friendship should appeal to young children. Reviewer: Vicki Foote
Miller's debut, in which a little girl affectionately adopts a butternut squash, is a winner. After her parents buy that squash for dinner at the farmers market, Sophie commandeers it, giving it a face with markers. It proves just the right size to hold, bounce on her knee and love. "I call her Bernice," Sophie says. "I'll call for a pizza," says her mother. Throughout the fall, Sophie coddles her veggie, attending library storytimes, visiting other squash at the farmers market and practicing somersaults near the garden. Her parents do their gentle best to suggest alternatives for the moldering squash, from a trip to the toy store to a donation to the food pantry. Sophie will have none of it. "Bernice will last forever." When even Sophie notices changes in Bernice, she asks a farmer what keeps a squash healthy. Her unique interpretation of his advice ("Fresh air. Good, clean dirt. A little love") yields, next spring and summer, delightful twin surprises. Wilsdorf's amusing ink-and-watercolor illustrations alternate between full-bleed spreads and spots. From her bouncy braids to her red shoes, Sophie's vibrant, determined nature shines forth charmingly. This season-spanning turn with high-spirited Sophie offers endearing lessons about nurture and regeneration. (Picture book. 3-8)
Children's Literature - Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz
Sophie picks out a squash at the market, but not for supper. It's "just the right size to love." She calls it Bernice, gives it a face, wraps it in a blanket, and rocks it to sleep. She takes Bernice everywhere with her, from the library to the garden. When her mother suggests that they had better bake Bernice before she gets mushy, Sophie is horrified. She won't part with Bernice; she's sure she will last "forever." But when winter nears, Bernice gets soft and spotted. So in her favorite place, Sophie makes her a bed of soil, tucks Bernice in, and kisses her goodnight. When the snow falls, Sophie's father brings her a new pet, a fish. Gradually she grows to appreciate him. But then, in the spring, Bernice presents her with a wonderful surprise. Transparent watercolors and a strong black ink and China ink outline set the stage on the jacket/cover where a slightly cartoon-y Sophie and Bernice play together under an autumn tree. All the double-page scenes and vignettes display this loving relationship. Wilsdorf has covered the end pages with a score of Sophies playing with Bernices in many joyous ways. The heart-warming tale is bittersweet. Reviewer: Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz
School Library Journal
K-Gr 2—"Good friends are hard to find," says Sophie to her best buddy, Bernice. This must be so, because Bernice is a farmers' market squash. The fruit is supposed to be for supper, but all bets are off when Sophie gives it a face and a name. The two friends are inseparable, visiting the library and other squash at the market, practicing somersaults on the hill…and every night Sophie gives Bernice a baby bottle and tucks her into a cradle. ("Well, we did hope she'd love vegetables," Sophie's mother observes.) Countless stories exist about girls' exploits with their dolls or stuffed animals. Few, if any, feature healthy produce. But the tale of Sophie and Bernice is charming and even suspenseful as the title character reluctantly realizes that her squash will not last forever. Miller's sweet and lively story is perfectly matched by Wilsdorf's expert ink and watercolor illustrations. With lessons on life, love, and vegetable gardening, this tale will be cherished by children, and their parents will be happy to read it to them often.—Susan Weitz, formerly at Spencer-Van Etten School District, Spencer, NY