Nine-year-old Helen is confused by the disappearance of her Jewish friend during the German occupation of Paris.
“Like Richter's Friedrich (1970) for older readers, this picture book dramatizes the Holocaust from the point of view of a gentile child who watches the mounting persecution of a Jewish friend. Translated from the French, the story is narrated by Helen, who remembers herself at nine years old in 1942 when the Nazis occupied northern France. Why does her best friend, Lydia, have to wear a yellow star? Why are people in hiding and using strange names? What is Lydia afraid of? Helen quarrels with her friend, and then Lydia is taken away, and Helen never sees her again. The book won the Graphics Prize at the 1994 Bologna Book Fair. The pastel pictures in sepia tones are understated, with an old-fashioned, almost childlike simplicity. In contrast to the quiet pictures of the children together inside the house, there's a climactic double-page street scene of a long column of people carrying suitcases and being marched away by the French police. Without being maudlin or sensational, the story brings the genocide home.” Hazel Rochman, Booklist
“This poignant account of childhood innocence destroyed by the Nazi occupation of France touches both heart and mind. A woman named Helen, remembering her ninth birthday, still regrets the angry comment she made that day to her Jewish friend Lydia -- who disappeared the next morning when the Nazis began rounding up the Jews and arresting them. The illustrations are minimal in detail yet emotionally evocative.” The Horn Book
- Walker & Company
- Publication date:
- Edition description:
- Sales rank:
- Product dimensions:
- 9.08(w) x 11.19(h) x 0.12(d)
- Age Range:
- 7 - 10 Years
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews
It was a very short book and I did not like the sad ending
I first read this book with my mother when I was 7 years old, and I have never forgotten it since then. It's an incredibly gripping story that deals with childhood friendship and guilt during the beginning of the Holocaust. It's not a book with a lighthearted, feel-good ending, but it is a book that needs to be read to your child over and over again (with YOU, the PARENT, present) so as to introduce the subject of the Holocaust to a child in its purest essence. This book needs to be read so as to keep the memory of the Holocaust alive, and to do this we simply must pass it on to our children. This is NOT a book that should be given to a child with the pretense of "Here you go, have fun!" Instead, this is a book to be read with your child so that discussion and understanding can grow from it. Ultimately, it is a book that I have read to my own children and have recommended time and time again to other parents. Please, read this book and read it WITH your child. You'll certainly be glad you did.