It reminded me of why I became a Star Wars fan in the first place.
My only complaint was that it was too short. Too much like a novella, not a real novel. It would have been perfect as a 4 installment serial in some SW magazine As a full fledged hard cover novel, it was a little light. But Iâ¿¿m glad I bought it. I liked seeing Mara just beginning her tenure as the Emperorâ¿¿s Hand. Her powers are so amazing when augmented by the Emperor. One can really see now why she was so lost and embittered in HttE after his death. I wish there had been good, pro-Mara authors in the post VotF era. We might have seen Luke gently bring her back to nearly that level. We do see some of that in Survivor. I liked seeing Han slowly coming around to being a real part of the Rebellion. Itâ¿¿s such a leap from the end of ANH to the beginning of ESB. I liked seeing Leia struggling with the transition from Princess and Senator to Rebel leader. Something we never got to see in the movies, any of the movies. I liked seeing Luke, still in contact with Ben, coming into his own as a fledgling Jedi. Zahn does a nice job of filling the gap between the farm boy getting a medal at Yavin IV and the almost Jedi following the Force to Dagobah. But what I really liked was the way Zahn, as usual, showed the readers another view of the SWU. The movies and many of the books portray the Empire as SO evil that one wonders why the citizenry hadnâ¿¿t revolted years ago, why the rebellion wasnâ¿¿t welcomed with open arms. But here, as in HttE, we see another side of the Empire. Order and Stability. Granted at the cost of diversity and individual freedom. And as we all know from real life, many, many people are willing to make that trade-off. I liked the Stormtroopers. It was a bit of a stretch at first to have them deserting, but when one remembers that they were all volunteers, not clones or conscripts (and not chemically indoctrinated like the troopers taken up by the Eye of Palpatine), it becomes more plausible. That accepted, then the reader has to deal with the plausibility of their escape and continued freedom. If we are to believe Imperial propaganda, Stormtroopers NEVER desert. (Any one who believes without question what any restrictive government tells them is beyond hope, so I wonâ¿¿t get into explaining why we, as the readers, should ignore this non-desertion folderol). This idea of total loyalty plays right into the Troopersâ¿¿ continued success. No one, even when the evidence is right before their eyes, is going to think a group of Stormtroopers is anything but an officially sanctioned operation. Part of their success is due to the ineptness of Adm. Ozzel (whose stupidity will cost him his life in ESB) and the secretiveness of the ISB. Partly itâ¿¿s luck (but thatâ¿¿s an acceptable literary contrivance if itâ¿¿s not overdone). But a good part of the Troopersâ¿¿ success is staying true to their mission: defend the citizens of the Empire. Allegiance isnâ¿¿t Zahnâ¿¿s best SW book, but thatâ¿¿s like saying that the Last Supper is not Da Vinciâ¿¿s best work or that American Graffiti isn't Lucas's best movie
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.