- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Marge Piercy
Margaret Atwood is a large and remarkable writer. Her concerns are nowhere petty.—(Marge Piercy)
Want a NOOK? Explore Now
Part detective novel, part psychological thriller, Surfacing is the story of a talented woman artist who goes in search of her missing father on a remote island in northern Quebec. Setting out with her lover and another young couple, she soon finds herself captivated by the isolated setting, where a marriage begins to fall apart, violence and death lurk just beneath the surface, and sex becomes a catalyst for conflict and dangerous choices. Surfacing is a work permeated with an aura of suspense, complex with layered meanings, and written in brilliant, diamond-sharp prose. Here is a rich mine of ideas from an extraordinary writer about contemporary life and nature, families and marriage, and about women fragmented...and becoming whole.
From the Trade Paperback edition.
1. Throughout the novel, we never learn the name of our narrator. Why might Atwood choose anonymity for her heroine?
2. This novel is replete with dis- and re-appearances: fathers vanish, babies are lost, marriages erode, long-banished memories return, pregancies occur. Discuss the implications of disappearing and reappearing.
3. Our narrator frequently refers to herself as an "accomplice": to the killing of the fish, to the accruing of "random samples" for the film. Over the course of the novel, she not only ceases her collusion but also becomes an active saboteur. What catalyzes this shift?
4. Early in the novel, the narrator attempts to draw clear battle lines: men versus women, the city versus the country, the Americans versus Canadians. In time, however, many of these opposing camps blur together: supposed Americans are revealed to be Canadians, Anna shifts her allegiance and sides with the men. What is the result of these new alliances?
5. The narrator must literally dive into the lake in order to dredge the swamp of her memory and recover her buried past. Throughout the novel, the lake serves as both a literal and symbolic centerpiece. Discuss its role and importance.
6. What can we see from the novel's discussion of "truth" or "lies?"
7. What clues in the novel suggest that the narrator is struggling to supress memories of an abortion?
8. What role does the discovery of her father's drawings play in her ability, as a daughter and as a fellow artist, to understand his life better?
9. Each of the two couples employ different strategies for wounding and communicating with oneanother. Do relationship strategies differ more on gender lines or from couple to couple? What are the distinctive strategies employed by each couple/person?
10. Does the heroine remain a reliable narrator throughout? Do her perceptions ever deviate from reality? At what point, if ever, do you discount her version of reality?
11. Does your opinion of Joe alter as the novel progresses?
12. Our heroine describes her habitual process of observing, memorizing, and copying emotions she has seen in others in lieu of having actual feeling herself. Discuss.
13. What is the role of animals in the novel? The role of technology?
14. In describing childhood games of hide and seek in the forest, the narrator recalls her fear "that what would come out when you called would be someone else". When she later escapes into the forest, she does in fact emerge transformed. What happens on her odyssey?
15. Consider this final manifesto: "This above all, to refuse to be a victim . . . I have to recant, give up the old belief that I am powerless." Does a shift in self-perception have the power to reverse one's destiny? What factors determine who is and is not a victim? What gives her the power to break free?
Discussion questions provided courtesy of Anchor Books, a division of Random House, Inc., New York. All rights reserved.
1. Throughout the novel, we never learn the name of our narrator. Why might Atwood choose anonymity for her heroine?
2. This novel is replete with dis- and re-appearances: fathers vanish, babies are lost, marriages erode, long-banished memories return, pregancies occur. Discuss the implications of disappearing and reappearing.
3. Our narrator frequently refers to herself as an "accomplice": to the killing of the fish, to the accruing of "random samples" for the film. Over the course of the novel, she not only ceases her collusion but also becomes an active saboteur. What catalyzes this shift?
4. Early in the novel, the narrator attempts to draw clear battle lines: men versus women, the city versus the country, the Americans versus Canadians. In time, however, many of these opposing camps blur together: supposed Americans are revealed to be Canadians, Anna shifts her allegiance and sides with the men. What is the result of these new alliances?
5. The narrator must literally dive into the lake in order to dredge the swamp of her memory and recover her buried past. Throughout the novel, the lake serves as both a literal and symbolic centerpiece. Discuss its role and importance.
6. What can we see from the novel's discussion of "truth" or "lies?"
7. What clues in the novel suggest that the narrator is struggling to supress memories of an abortion?
8. What role does the discovery of her father's drawings play in her ability, as a daughter and as a fellow artist, to understand his life better?
9. Each of the two couples employ different strategies for wounding and communicating with one another. Do relationship strategies differ more on gender lines or from couple to couple? What are the distinctive strategies employed by each couple/person?
10. Does the heroine remain a reliable narrator throughout? Do her perceptions ever deviate from reality? At what point, if ever, do you discount her version of reality?
11. Does your opinion of Joe alter as the novel progresses?
12. Our heroine describes her habitual process of observing, memorizing, and copying emotions she has seen in others in lieu of having actual feeling herself. Discuss.
13. What is the role of animals in the novel? The role of technology?
14. In describing childhood games of hide and seek in the forest, the narrator recalls her fear "that what would come out when you called would be someone else". When she later escapes into the forest, she does in fact emerge transformed. What happens on her odyssey?
15. Consider this final manifesto: "This above all, to refuse to be a victim . . . I have to recant, give up the old belief that I am powerless." Does a shift in self-perception have the power to reverse one's destiny? What factors determine who is and is not a victim? What gives her the power to break free?
Anonymous
Posted March 11, 2003
I must confess, I bought Surfacing because it was the shortest of Margaret Atwood's novels and I had only a few days before my deadline. But after reading The Blind Assassin, I was excited to be picking up another Margaret Atwood book. Surfacing has quite a different feel, however, and meanders for the first 160 (of 200) pages. As the book winds down, you wonder if the main character is mentally sane, or, in fact, if Margaret Atwood is. The book twists and turns, puzzles the reader, but ultimately all comes together for a satisfying (but fairly tragic) ending.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Feminist and post colonial theories share common qualities since they have consistently held the position of the ¿other¿ in society, making the protagonist¿s plight a mere microcosm of the reality of what exists. The nameless protagonist is exploited in various ways by society as well as her married lover; paralleling the exploitation of Canada and other post-colonial societies by other dominant cultures. Atwood highlights the damage caused to those exploited and colonized as she shows the loss of identity experienced by the individual whose history: 'I must be more careful of my memories, I have to be sure they're my own and not the memories of other people telling me what I felt, how I acted, what I said'; language and culture have been dominated. <BR/><BR/>Feminist and post-colonial theories have also always been concerned with the language, both the native language of the colonized land as well as the language forced on the individuals as speech is part of the basis for identity. They can also be used subversively to thwart patriarchal powers. When the protagonist emerges from the lake liberated, she no longer feels the need to use the language of the `conquerors¿ and instead retreats into animal grunts. Her culture is perpetually threatened by the `enemies¿, The Americans; and also her own countrymen as the condition of degeneracy as well as what is considered `normal¿ by the enemies have been internalized and Canadians themselves have become the very thing they loathe.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted May 21, 2003
My first Atwood book was Alias Grace, and I loved it so much I wanted to read more by this author. Surfacing was very different, I was gently lulled along by lovely descriptions to a violent and unexpected end. Satisfying and disturbing both!
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.am not going to say much about this novel at the moment... I can't decide what to say beyond the fact that it is powerful, thought provoking but sometimes slightly man-hating... I suggest reading it strenuously, but be warned that it is a very subtle novel filled with symbolism rather than concrete things.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted July 11, 2005
I have now read all of Margaret Atwood's novels except for one and I'm drawn into her characters each time. I think she has a remarkable way of setting a believable stage that captivates the audience and then slowly starts to shape it into something entirely different. I can relate to it so easily that by the end, I'm afraid of what I'm relating to. Only after I put the book down and start to think about it in my every day life am I able to say, 'that's not healthy'. Surfacing is a prime example of Atwood's ability to do that to a reader. Go for it!!
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted December 29, 2009
No text was provided for this review.
Anonymous
Posted January 10, 2010
No text was provided for this review.
Anonymous
Posted April 13, 2010
No text was provided for this review.
Anonymous
Posted December 13, 2010
No text was provided for this review.
Anonymous
Posted January 19, 2010
No text was provided for this review.
Overview
Part detective novel, part psychological thriller, Surfacing is the story of a talented woman artist who goes in search of her missing father on a remote island in northern Quebec. Setting out with her lover and another young couple, she soon finds herself captivated by the isolated setting, where a marriage begins to fall apart, violence and death lurk just beneath the surface, and sex becomes a catalyst for conflict and dangerous choices. Surfacing is a work permeated with an aura of ...