- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Baskin writes an unsettling novel that shows the impact of guilt and childhood trauma.
Baskin limns her protagonist with quick, clear strokes...an affecting portrait of the extent of the aftershocks from a family tragedy.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books
Posted May 9, 2013
Im the kind of girl who LOVES sad stories but not when they are so...pointless. The main character had a lot of emotional issues that were gripping but the way she delt with them was not only self-destructive and stupid but also very intentional. She let people walk all over her.
The whole plot was slow, underdeveloped, and again pointlss. This book did nothing for me. The ending wasnt satisfying or even sad enough to make me feel anything other than disgust. The author paints us a dreary picture of life and although that can make for a great story, in this case it just wasted my time.
There were several frustrating moments when i wanted to smack a few characters and no one in the book, not even the book its self had any redeeming qualities. It wasnt a witty, emotional, scary, exciting,.romantic, sweet, heart pounding, adventerous, depressing, or even heartbreaking story. It was nothing. It was bland and boring and shockingly empty of a STORY.
The whole book is basically Maggie has a crappy life and only makes it crappier for herself on purpose. She doesnt even ,earn a good life lesson to make it seem like her 'journey' was worth while. I feel sorry for her because she clearly hates herself and doesnt see her own worth but honeatly this is the emptiest book ive ever read. Even books i think are bad and stupid have more in them then this book.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted September 2, 2013
Reviewed by Avery, age 9
Maggie is a great swimmer and on the high school swim team and loves swimming even though her little sister Leah drowned 10 years ago. Maggie has a secret gift, but not a good one. People tend to want to tell Maggie their deepest darkest secrets and once they realize they have spilled their guts, they get mad and embarrassed and it causes her to have a hard time making and keeping friends. It also makes her make poor choices, as she has a difficult time with peer pressure and how it affects her after the fact.
“You always tell on me. And I always get in trouble.”
This book shows us that being a kid is very difficult; we are often faced with situations we can’t control, like losing people we love, and doing stupid stuff, like caving to peer pressure and bullying, can make a big difference in how we see ourselves and how others see us. Growing up isn’t easy and this story shows us how important it is to have at least one person you can rely on and talk to to help through all the tough times that pop up. If you’re okay talking about teen sexuality, this is a great book for even tweens. I liked it a lot and I know you will too.
*This book was provided in exchange for an honest review*
*You can view the original review at Musing with Crayolakym and San Francisco & Sacramento City Book Review
Posted March 19, 2013
Surfacing is a quick read, but I liked it. I liked the premise of her almost magical ability that draws the truth from people and I love the themes of grief and blame that ultimately give way to forgiveness, so I knew that I needed to read this one.
Maggie was an enjoyable character and I saw a lot of character growth in her. I think a part of this is that the story is told partly in flashbacks, which is on the line of middle grade and young adult contemporary. It deals with some pretty hard core issues, but it is never gratuitously graphic, although there are scenes I wouldn't want a sixth grader to read, so I don't know. In parts (I did get a bit confused of the time line) she is only in 6th grade, but at some point she is a sophomore, because that is what the back of the book says... I am not sure where this transition is... This didn't take away from enjoying Maggie, although her voice is younger in some parts, which leads me to think middle grade.
I really liked her best friend Julie. It was a quick form relationship as young kids, and she stuck by her and learned her nuances but loved her anyways. But she isn't just a cookie cutter, she has a personality and she questions and tries to get quieter Maggie to talk to her instead of just abandoning her like others seem to do because they end up telling her things they don't want to be out in the open.
I labeled this as contemporary because I was never quite sure about her ability. I know that some people are just easy to talk to and tell secrets to. So I think that the almost magical is key word.
The ending was more open ended and sad that I would like, but I think it fits the themes of the book.
Bottom Line: This is a sweet but dark story with a likable protagonist
Posted March 12, 2013
I Also Recommend:
Surfacing is a deeply moving novel that young adults will truly appreciate. Nora Raleigh Baskin strikes the perfect balance between the struggles of a teen and her grieving family and the typical teen experience. Maggie believes she has the ability to draw people to her just to have them reveal their most personal secrets. Her only solace lies in swimming, her one true friend Julie, and her obsessive crush on captain of the wrestling team, Matthew.
With a solemn opening in the voice of Maggie's older sister Leah, readers are drawn into the heart of the story. Baskin gets to the point quickly, pushing readers through meaningful connections between Leah's drowning and how Maggie and her family deal with the long ago tragedy. Leah's interjections into the plot are reminiscences of their childhood and sometimes present observations, as if she's an invisible fly on the wall. A clever and interesting addition to the story, Leah will help draw readers' perception of Maggie.
As Maggie struggles with grief and guilt over the event that further tore her family apart she begins to follow a destructive path. She's very naive in this regard, as if she recognizes that she's headed on a wrong course, but lets her low self-worth mean that it's all okay. Sometimes it's hard for even the reader to figure Maggie out, she shuts us out just as effectively as she shuts out her friends. Ultimately, though, her story shows its heartbreaking reality.
Baskin's soft writing style takes the edge off any extreme emotions, but carries them into the hearts of readers. Surfacing will strike chords in readers young and old!
*Book provided via publisher in exchange for an honest review*
0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.