Disc 1
- Resthaterian
- Camille
- Love in Its Proper Place
- Poppin'
- Kitchen Jazz
- Clair (Phylicia)
- The Huxtable Kids
- Outstretched Hands (Gloria)
- Look at This
- A House Full of Love
Disc 2
- Strawberry Moon
- The Look of Love
- Shivaree Ride
- Caught a Touch of Your Love
- Maddie's Blues
- I Will Be Here for You
- Monte Carlo Nights
- Keep in Touch
- Summer Nights
Disc 3
- Blues for D.P.
- Just Enough
- French Connection
- Something Borrowed, Something Blue
- Lullaby for Shana Bly
- Stolen Moments
- In a Sentimental Mood
- Stella by Starlight
Disc 4
- Jamaica
- Gramercy Park
- Sacred Kind of Love
- Brand New Age
- Fly Away
- Don't Take Your Love from Me
- Time Out of Mind
- Split Second (Act II, The Bar Scene)
- Nice-N-Easy
- Unspoken Love
- Protect the Dream
Disc 5
- Take Five (Take Another Five)
- Your Love
- Only for You [Siempre Para D'sera]
- Greene Street
- Next Exit
- I Miss Home
- Love Like This
- Summer Chill
- Till You Return to Me
- Get on Up
- Check Out Grover
Disc 6
- E Preciso Perdoar [One Must Forgive]
- When I Fall in Love
- I'm Glad There Is You
- Happenstance
- All My Tomorrows
- Nature Boy
- Please Send Me Someone to Love
- Overjoyed
- Flamingo
- For Heaven's Sake
- Estate ("Ess-Tah-Tay") (In Summer)
Disc 7
- Soulful Strut
- Can You Stop the Rain
- Play That Groove for Me
- Bordertown
- I Can Count the Times
- Village Groove
- Headman's Haunt
- Poacher Man
- Mystical Force
- Uptown
Disc 8
- Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas
- Breath of Heaven (Mary's Song)
- The Love in His Infant Eyes
- Away in a Manger
- I Wonder as I Wonder
- Christmas Time Is Here
- The Magi's Song/A Child Is Born
- Jesu (Joy of Man's Desiring)
- The Christmas Song
- The Christmas Waltz
- Christmas Day Chant
- Breath of Heaven (Mary's Song) [Instrumental Version]
Disc 9
- Je Crois Entendre Encore [I Still Hear Her Sweet Voice] [From The Pearlfishers]
- Pourquoi Me Reveiller? [Why Do You Wake Me?] [From Werther]
- Flower Duet [From Lakme]
- Amor Ti Vieta [Love Forbids] [From Fedora]
- O Mio Babbino Caro [Oh, My Sweet Papa] [From Gianni Schicci]
- Donna Non Vidi Mai [Never Seen a Woman Like That] [From Manon Lescaut]
- Ch'ella Mi Creda [Let Her Believe It] [From The Girl of the Golden West]
- My Man's Gone Now [From Porgy and Bess]
- O Soave Fanciulla [Oh, Sweet Little Lady] [From La Boheme]
- E Lucevan Le Stelle [The Stars Were Shining] [From Tosca]
- Au Fond Du Temple Saint [Deep Inside This Holy Place] [From The Pearlfishers]
- Vissi D'arte [I Lived for Art] [From Tosca]