As good mods,
the Jam always had a healthy respect for
R&B and
soul -- even the first album featured the revved-up
Northern soul of
"Non-Stop Dancing." With
The Gift, however,
Paul Weller seems to have become completely absorbed in it, and more specifically, in
Stax-style
soul with more than a hint of psychedelia a la
"Psychedelic Shack." An uneven album marked by overindulgences like the instrumental
"Circus" and unnecessarily long songs,
The Gift still has no shortage of terrific songs, like the simply sublime
"Ghost," "Town Called Malice" (the hit), and the
funk workout of
"Precious." Weller can obviously do "soulful" -- his voice has never sounded better -- but unfortunately,
The Gift, with its excesses and marginal tracks, doesn't show his talents in the proper light. Points for ambition, but ultimately, this is their least consistent effort since
This Is the Modern World. ~ Chris Woodstra
