Peter Stampfel dismisses this album's sequencing, which was changed without the band's consent before its 1965 release. (He resequenced it, adding two bonus tracks, for
the Rounders' excellent
One and Two reissue in 1999.) Indeed, the weird bifurcated structure, placing all of the traditionally styled fiddle tunes on side one and all of the more stylistically varied numbers on side two, rather misses the point. Like the musicians collected on
Harry Smith's
Anthology of American Folk Music,
the Holy Modal Rounders mixed
traditional folk music and the artifacts of their particular circumstances (in their case, life among the junkies and freaks in post-Beat, pre-hippie Greenwich Village) into a unique and idiosyncratic blend that could have only come from these two people at this particular time. Mixing up the revered traditional song
"Mole in the Ground" with the trippy
"Crowley Waltz" was the whole idea! That quibble aside, however, this collection of outside material along the lines of
the Stanley Brothers'
"Clinch Mountain Backstep" and
Blind Willie McTell's
"Statesboro Blues" with
traditional folk songs (there's only one original,
Steve Weber and
Michael Hurley's fragmentary
"Junko Partner") is nearly as successful as the duo's even weirder 1964 debut, showing that strangeness and mystery, along with raucous good humor, is at the heart of American
folk music. Still, the 1999 CD is the best way of hearing this music. ~ Stewart Mason
