The Limits of Meaning: Case Studies in the Anthropology of Christianity

by Matthew Engelke (Editor), Matt Tomlinson (Editor)

Overview

Too often, anthropological accounts of ritual leave readers with the impression that everything goes smoothly, that rituals are "meaningful events." But what happens when rituals fail, or when they seem "meaningless"? Drawing on research in the anthropology of Christianity from around the globe, the authors in this volume suggest that in order to analyze meaning productively, we need to consider its limits. This collection is a welcome new addition to the anthropology of religion, offering fresh debates on a classic topic and drawing attention to meaning in a way that other volumes have for key terms like "culture" and "fieldwork.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780857457097
Publisher:	Berghahn Books
Publication date:	08/01/2006
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	252
File size:	377 KB

About the Author

Matthew Engelke is Professor of Religion and Director of the Institute for Religion, Culture, and Public Life at Columbia University. He has conducted research in Zimbabwe and published numerous articles in leading journals, focusing on Christian ritual, conversion, spirit possession, and textual authority. He is coeditor with Marshall Sahlins of Prickly Paradigm Press.

Matt Tomlinson is an assistant lecturer in Anthropology at Monash University. He has conducted research in Fiji on Christianity’s role in village and national politics, especially in relation to traditional chiefly systems and coups d’état. He has published in American Anthropologist, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, and Oceania.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements

Chapter 1. Meaning, Anthropology, Christianity
Matt Tomlinson and Matthew Engelke

Chapter 2. When Silence isn’t Golden: Charismatic Speech and the Limits of Literalism
Simon Coleman

Chapter 3. Clarity and Charisma: On the Uses of Ambiguity in Ritual Life
Matthew Engelke

Chapter 4. Rituals without Final Acts: Prayer and Success in World Vision Zimbabwe’s Humanitarian Work
Erica Bornstein

Chapter 5. Nationalism and Millenarianism in West Papua: Institutional Power, Interpretive Practice, and the Pursuit of Christian Truth
Danilyn Rutherford

Chapter 6. The Limits of Meaning in Fijian Methodist Sermons
Matt Tomlinson

Chapter 7. Converting Meanings and the Meanings of Conversion in Samoan Moral Economies
Ilana Gershon

Chapter 8. Dusty Signs and Roots of Faith: The Limits of Christian Meaning in Highland Bolivia
Andrew Orta

Chapter 9. Paranomics: On the Semiotics of Sacral Action
James D. Faubion

Afterword: On Limits, Ruptures, Meaning, and Meaninglessness
Joel Robbins

List of Contributors
Index

Editorial Reviews

"The originality of this work is reinforced by the diversity of each author's positioning and the richness of each contribution in terms of reflection and area. This volume constitutes a landmark for the ethnography of Christianity as well as for the interpretative method in anthropology."  ·  L'Homme

"...[the] introduction provides a stimulating meditation on the centrality of meaning in anthropological discussions of religion, in general, and ritual, in particular...The thematic concern with the ways people conceive of meaning and respond to threats or breakdowns provides an unusual degree of coherence. The value of the book is further enhanced by the rich detail and accessibility of most of the chapters."  ·  American Anthropologist

"...an engaging and exciting contribution to a growing literature of detailed and ethnographically rich analyses...This book will be important to scholars of Christianity and of religion generally,, as well as to regional specialists of the areas discussed, especially in the Pacific."  ·  Pacific Affairs

"Based on meticulous ethnographies, most of the contributions of this volume are of high quality and succeed in revealing the importance of a focus on the 'moments of failure'...The book's contributions are extremely relevant to the study of religion, but, while they claim to explore a singular 'Christianity', they concentrate on Protestant Christian groups."  ·  Critique of Anthropology

"The collection is of interest not only to those studying Christianity but also to a wider readership in Religious Studies. Furthermore, the well-chosen lens of meaning through which Christianity is approached in the articles renders the volume a coherent whole."  ·  Temenos. Nordic Journal of Comparative Religion

"Christian theology has given to the human sciences at large hermeneutics as an interpretive science of meaning. This remarkable collection of essays by anthropologists turns a keen hermeneutic sensibility on Christian discourse and practice itself, and in the process not only makes an important contribution to the ethnography of Christianity, but also offers a profound meditation on the theory of meaning."  ·  Thomas Csordas, University of California - San Diego

"The Limits of Meaning is by far the best instance I've seen of the fresh and powerful insights anthropologists are bringing to the study of Christianity. The fascinating ethnographic case studies, along with a fine Introduction by the editors and commentary by Joel Robbins, highlight the crucial importance of meaning for Christianity by focusing on points where it is most at risk or fails utterly. Extremely readable while advancing a sophisticated theoretical argument that links the deeper dynamics of Christianity with its local manifestations, this book challenges conventional understandings and opens new avenues of research. It deserves to be on the bookshelves of all serious students of contemporary world Christianity."  ·  John Barker, University of British Columbia

EBOOK COMMENTARY

“The originality of this work is reinforced by the diversity of each author’s positioning and the richness of each contribution in terms of reflection and area. This volume constitutes a landmark for the ethnography of Christianity as well as for the interpretative method in anthropology.”  ·  L'Homme

“…[the] introduction provides a stimulating meditation on the centrality of meaning in anthropological discussions of religion, in general, and ritual, in particular…The thematic concern with the ways people conceive of meaning and respond to threats or breakdowns provides an unusual degree of coherence. The value of the book is further enhanced by the rich detail and accessibility of most of the chapters.”  ·  American Anthropologist

”…an engaging and exciting contribution to a growing literature of detailed and ethnographically rich analyses…This book will be important to scholars of Christianity and of religion generally,, as well as to regional specialists of the areas discussed, especially in the Pacific.”  ·  Pacific Affairs

“Based on meticulous ethnographies, most of the contributions of this volume are of high quality and succeed in revealing the importance of a focus on the ‘moments of failure’…The book’s contributions are extremely relevant to the study of religion, but, while they claim to explore a singular ‘Christianity’, they concentrate on Protestant Christian groups.”  ·  Critique of Anthropology

“The collection is of interest not only to those studying Christianity but also to a wider readership in Religious Studies. Furthermore, the well-chosen lens of meaning through which Christianity is approached in the articles renders the volume a coherent whole.”  ·  Temenos. Nordic Journal of Comparative Religion

"Christian theology has given to the human sciences at large hermeneutics as an interpretive science of meaning. This remarkable collection of essays by anthropologists turns a keen hermeneutic sensibility on Christian discourse and practice itself, and in the process not only makes an important contribution to the ethnography of Christianity, but also offers a profound meditation on the theory of meaning."  ·  Thomas Csordas, University of California - San Diego

"The Limits of Meaning is by far the best instance I’ve seen of the fresh and powerful insights anthropologists are bringing to the study of Christianity. The fascinating ethnographic case studies, along with a fine Introduction by the editors and commentary by Joel Robbins, highlight the crucial importance of meaning for Christianity by focusing on points where it is most at risk or fails utterly. Extremely readable while advancing a sophisticated theoretical argument that links the deeper dynamics of Christianity with its local manifestations, this book challenges conventional understandings and opens new avenues of research. It deserves to be on the bookshelves of all serious students of contemporary world Christianity."  ·  John Barker, University of British Columbia

From the Publisher