The Making of Song Dynasty History: Sources and Narratives, 960-1279 CE

by Charles Hartman

Overview

In this ambitious work of political and intellectual history, Charles Hartman surveys the major sources that survive as vestiges of the official dynastic historiography of the Chinese Song dynasty (960–1279). Analyzing the narratives that emerge from these sources as products of Song political discourse, Hartman offers a thorough introduction to the texts and the political circumstances surrounding their compilation. Distilling from these sources a 'grand allegory of Song history', he argues that the narratives embedded within reflect tension between a Confucian model of political institutionalism and the Song court's preference for a non-sectarian, technocratic model. Fundamentally rethinking the corpus of texts that have formed the basis of our understanding of the Song and of imperial China more broadly, this far-reaching account of historiographical process and knowledge production illuminates the relationship between official history writing and political struggle in China.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781108834834
Publisher:	Cambridge University Press
Publication date:	10/08/2020
Pages:	400
Product dimensions:	9.25(w) x 6.30(h) x 0.98(d)

About the Author

Charles Hartman is Professor of Chinese Studies in the Department of East Asian Studies at the University at Albany, State University of New York.

Table of Contents

Introduction: Toward a dynamic historiography of the Song dynasty; Part I. Sources: 1. The Song State Compendium; 1.1 Introduction; 1.2 The origins and distinctiveness of the Song dynasty huiyao; 1.3 The first and second collections; 1.4 A hundred year hiatus; 1.5 Resumption under Emperor Xiaozong; 1.6 New paradigms; 1.7 The Reconstructed Draft; 1.8 Understanding the Recovered Draft; 1.9 Conclusion; 2. Li Tao and the Long Draft; 2.1 Introduction; 2.2 The historian from Sichuan; 2.3 The origins of the Long Draft; 2.4 The reign of Emperor Xiaozong and the politics of the Long Draft; 2.5 Method and message in the Long Draft; 2.6 The fate of a masterpiece; 2.7 Conclusion; 3. Li Xinchuan and the Chronological Record; 3.1 Introduction; 3.2 The life of Li Xinchuan; 3.3 Corrections of Errors in Old Accounts; 3.4 The Chronological Record; 3.4.1 Facts and sources; 3.4.2 Constructing narratives; 3.4.3 Creating a political discourse; 3.5 The Diverse Notes; 3.6 The Record of the Way and its Fate; 3.7 Conclusion; 4. The daoxue historians; 4.1 Zhu Xi; 4.2 Chen Jun; 4.3 Lü Zhong's Lectures on Song History; 4.4 Daoxue historiography; 5. The Song History; 5.1 Introduction: a flawed history?; 5.2 The project and the committee; 5.3 Structure and meaning; 5.3.1 The imperial eulogies; 5.3.2. The prefaces and evaluations; 5.3.3 Cyclical structure and meaning in the Song History; 5.4 Politics and message; Part II. Narratives: 6. Political precedents and the origins of historical narrative; 6.1 The power of precedent; 6.2 The policies of the ancestors; 6.3 Precedents in Southern Song; 7. Song history as grand allegory: an introduction; 8. An empire of benevolence; 8.1 Yuanyou origins; 8.2 Luo Congyan's Record of Revering Yao; 8.3 New history for a new regime; 8.4 Hu Anguo's 'Plans for the Restoration' and the return of Qin Gui; 8.5 Zhao Ding, Fan Chong, and the Yuanyou legacy; 9. From soldier to sage: deifying the prime ancestor; 9.1 Fighting over Chen Bridge; 9.2 A banquet for the generals; 9.2.1 The Song military problem; 9.2.2 The restoration context; 9.2.3 Sima Guang again; 10. The lineage of evil: benevolence undermined; 11. The rhythms of Song history; Bibliography; Index.

Editorial Reviews

‘The Making of Song Dynasty History is a masterwork of history and historiography. Meticulously researched, closely argued, and studded with sparkling gems on the workings of Song institutions and the lives of historical figures, Hartman's grand narrative reveals in exquisite detail how contemporaneous historical and political developments shaped the writing of Song history. This is a book that every Song historian will want – and need – to read.' Beverly Bossler, University of California, Davis

‘A truly monumental achievement with potential to transform the entire field: the product of meticulous sinological scholarship, persuasive empirical arguments, and staggering intellectual ambition. Performing an archaeological dig through the textual strata of Song historiography, Professor Hartman painstakingly documents their formation, alteration, and manipulation under intense political and ideological pressures.' Ari Daniel Levine, University of Georgia

‘This is a book of crucial importance to anyone who does Song history or who has an interest in how historiography and political culture are entwined. It is a magisterial work of institutional history and textual archaeology that everyone who uses Song sources will need to keep by their side.' Paul Jakov Smith, Haverford College, Pennsylvania

‘… The Making of Song Dynasty History is an indispensable book.’ Christian de Pee, Journal of Chinese History

From the Publisher