Disc 1
- Why Do Fools Fall in Love - Frankie Lymon - Jimmy Merchant - Herman Santiago - Lymon
- I Wonder Why - Maxwell Anderson - Dion & The Belmonts - Ricardo Weeks
- Come Go with Me - Del Vikings - Clarence E. Quick
- In the Still of the Night - Five Satins - Fred Parris
- Since I Don't Have You - James Beaumont - Wally Lester - Lenny Martin - Joseph Rock - Skyliners - Jackie Taylor - Joe VerScharen - Janet Vogel - Lennie Martin
- Sincerely - Alan Freed - Harvey Fuqua - Moonglows
- The Great Pretender - Platters - Buck Ram
- Trickle, Trickle - Clarence Bassett - Videos
- 16 Candles - Crests - Luther Dixon - Allyson R. Khent
- Earth Angel - Jesse Belvin - Gaynel Hodge - Penguins - Curtis "Fitz" Williams
- When You Dance - Andrew Jones - Turbans
- Goodnight, Sweetheart, Goodnight - Calvin Carter - James Hudson - Spaniels
- Speedoo - Cadillacs - Esther Navarro - Powell
- Get a Job - Earl Beal - Raymond Edwards - William Horton - Richard Lewis - Silhouettes
- Island of Love - William Sheppard - Sheppards
- For Your Precious Love - Arthur Brooks - Richard Brooks - Jerry Butler - Impressions - Butler
- Little Star - Elegants - Vito Picone - Arthur Venosa
- So Fine - Fiestas - Johnny Otis
Disc 2
- A Teenager in Love - Dion & The Belmonts - Doc Pomus - Mort Shuman
- There's a Moon Out Tonight - Capris - Al Gentile - Joe Luccisano - Al Striano
- Remember Then - Earls - Tony Powers - Beverly "Ruby" Ross - Stan Vincent
- Daddy's Home - William Miller - Shep & the Limelites - James Sheppard
- I Only Have Eyes for You - Al Dubin - Flamingos - Harry Warren
- At My Front Door - Ewart Abner - El Dorados
- My True Story - Phil Belmonte - Jive Five - Eugene Pitt - Joe Rene - Oscar Waltzer
- Hushabye - Mystics - Doc Pomus - Mort Shuman
- Little Darlin' - Diamonds - Maurice Williams
- Rama Lama Ding Dong - Edsels
- You Belong to Me - Duprees - Pee Wee King - Chilton Price - Redd Stewart
- Unchained Melody - Alex North - Vito & the Salutations - Hy Zaret
- I Do - Marvelows - Melvin Mason - Frank Paden - Johnny Paden - Jesse Smith - Willie Stephenson
- Step By Step - Crests - Ollie Jones
- Blue Moon - Lorenz Hart - Marcels - Richard Rodgers
- Denise - Neil Levenson - Randy & the Rainbows
- Over the Mountain, Cross the Sea - Rex Garvin - Garvin - Johnnie & Joe
- Duke of Earl - Gene Chandler - Eugene Dixon - Bernice Williams
- Those Oldies But Goodies (Remind Me of You) - Nick Curinga - Little Caesar & the Romans - Paul Leo Politi - Romans