Not worth your time or money
I recently saw David Horowitz giving a talk about his book, The Professors, at Duke University while watching C-SPAN. Most of his discussion of his own ideas were unorganized (just all over the place), incoherent, and illogical. His arguments, if you could even call them that, were full of logical fallacies. During his lecture he talked about the insistence for 'civil discourse,' but he himself was anything but civil, particularly when audience members challenged his ideas. Perhaps this stemmed from the fact that he seemed unable to intellectually or cogently defend his own feeble ideas. Horowitz, at best, showed himself as a man of hypocrisies. For example, he criticized some professors whom he labeled 'left-wing' for engaging in 'name-calling ' yet, he aggressively defended Anne Coulter's recent name-calling of Arabs and Muslims. I guess for Horowitz name-calling is ok depending on who's the target. Furthermore, he criticized some professors (a very small number in reality) who fail to publish academically, whether that be in the form of books or scholarly articles in peer-reviewed journals. Yet, readers will notice that Horowitz isn¿t really qualified to speak on this subject none of his books are published by serious academic publishers and he clearly isn¿t trying to reach out to a serious scholarly audience. And no wonder there is after all, nothing scholarly, intellectual, or carefully crafted in Horowitz¿s ideas. If you are looking for garbage, garbage you will get with Horowitz's writing. There are at least a few people on the 'right' who can articulate an argument, but Horowitz isn't one of them. Ranting and raving can never substitute for real intellectual discourse, the kind Horowitz himself claims is needed on the subject of 'radical' professors with political agendas. His lecture at Duke University was revealing in one respect: most of the students (young men and women) who addressed questions to him were far more articulate than himself and were far less prone to the type of emotional outbursts that Horowitz allowed himself to succumb to. Also, his so-called 'arguments' would have been far more convincing if he had demonstrated that he is really interested in examining the appropriateness of professors who advance their own political ideas in the classroom and not in simply eradicating dissent or unpopular ideas altogether. There are just as many ¿right-wing¿ radicals on university campuses in the United States as there are ¿left-wing¿ radicals, but all of Horowitz¿s anxiety seems centered around the latter rather than the former. Apparently, he has erroneously concluded that the radicals on the ¿left¿ are more dangerous than those on the ¿right,¿ though evidence abounds which would suggest otherwise. (One only has to look around at all the religious fanatics and neo-Nazis, who identify with the ¿right,¿ to realize this.) Not surprising, Horowitz also operates under several false premises. For example, he assumes that students today are being indoctrinated with radical ideas because their college classrooms are suffused with politics. In doing so, he argues that prior to the 1960s, classrooms were free of politics, but this simply wasn¿t the case. Politics were present even then, just a different type of politics with a different message and different agenda were at work at that time. Horowitz, with all his flawed thinking, conflates the need for discussing the issue of politics and activism in the classroom with an advocating of Orwellian type ¿Thought Police¿ to censor ideas he and his comrades don¿t like. Clearly, Horowitz isn¿t worried about ¿dangerous professors¿ but about how to terminate ideas that differ from his own. Readers will start to see the irony here. Universities, after all, are places where all kinds of ideas are opened up, not closed down. While it is hard to take Horowitz¿s hate-filled diatribes seriously, one has to be alarmed at his attacks on professors, e
0 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
Bestselling author David Horowitz reveals a shocking and perverse culture of academics who are poisoning the minds of today's college students. The Professors is a wake-up call to all those who assume that a college education is sans hatred of America and the American military and support for America's terrorist enemies.