Carmen González Martínez, University of Murcia, Anales de Historia Contemporanea (review of Spanish language edition)
"This revised edition is the best and most readable account of the Spanish Republican Army in any language, fully informed and admirably objective. A unique institutional history."
Stanley G. Payne, Hilldale-Jaume Vicens Vives Professor of History Emeritus, University of Wisconsin-Madison
"This is a thorough and painstaking account of the Republican Army from its pre-Civil War origins to its defeat in 1939, based on years of research in archives, and correspondence and interviews with protagonists. It mobilises a wealth of evidence from primary sources to the latest secondary literature. Its analysis is scrupulously balanced, lucid, and dispassionate."
Sebastian Balfour, Professor Emeritus, Department of Government, London School of Economics and Political Science
"How refreshing [to] find a book that is intensely researched in the primary sources, scrupulously fair in its analysis, and of genuine utility in understanding this complex struggle … Incisive yet wide-ranging, this book offers a wealth of information and insights … Indispensable for modern European collections … Essential. All levels/libraries."
G. P. Cox, Choice
"An outstanding account of the Ejercito popolar republicana … Professor Alpert gives us a comprehensive, sympathetic, but by no means uncritical look at a surprisingly effective 'improvised' army … an essential read for anyone interested in the Spanish Civil War or the improvisation of military armies."
Albert Nofi, Strategy Page (strategypage.com)