Based on a true story!
Children's Literature - Lois Rubin GrossThe heroism of ordinary Danish citizens during World War II, in their commitment to saving roughly 7200 of the country’s Jewish citizens from the Nazis, has been well documented in both fact and fiction. This wonderful picture book is another entry in the impressive list of books that includes Lois Lowry’s award-winning Number the Stars. Anett and her parents are hiding a Jewish family in their basement. This means that Anett has learned to keep important secrets and go to the people in her village who are equally committed to the humanitarian effort. When Nazis come to the town, and to Anett’s very door, it becomes obvious that the family will have to be moved. However, finding the way to a rescue boat at the harbor is difficult on a moonless night. Anett comes up with a plan inspired by secrecy. She and her parents invite all their neighbors to whisper directions to the escaping family who, under cover of night, are able to escape. This is a sophisticated subject reduced to a graphic novel high interest and lower-level vocabulary. The illustrations, while not shown in panels, are clearly modeled on those in graphic novels and they are marvelous. With minimal color and line, Santomauro manages to convey the distress of the secret burdened child and her family. Neutral colors convey the dire feeling of the time, but the greys, browns, and blacks are punctuated with red, most effectively on the Nazi soldiers’ armbands. The conversation bubbles marking the path to the coast seem to literally point the way. This is a very successful mix of a popular style of art and an important story that will appeal to a wider range of young readers. Reviewer: Lois Rubin Gross; Ages 5 to 10.
The New York Times Book Review - Elizabeth WeinThe setting is a Danish fishing village, but one of the book's charms is how little context you need to understand it…[The Whispering Town] feels appropriate for reading to very young children as an introduction to the subject of the Holocaust.
Annet's family is part of the Danish resistance, hiding Jews in their cellar until the hidden refugees can escape by boat to Sweden. Unlike many stories set during the Nazi occupation, this one finds its protagonist, who narrates the story, an already accomplished insurgent: when her mother tells Annet, "There are new friends in the cellar," the girl knows whom to go to in the underground for additional food and even books for the young boy sheltering with his mother. These hushed requests inspire Annet to create a kind of whispering chain to guide the Jews to the harbor on a moonless night. Based on real events that unfolded in the Danish fishing town of Gilleleje, it's a story that feels urgent and refreshingly unsentimental. Elvgren (Josias, Hold the Book) never stops her reportorial storytelling for a speech about why these brave people are defying the Nazis—Annet just knows she has to act. Santomauro, who has a distinctly graphic novel sensibility, uses strong ink lines and a rich neutral palette (save for a few splashes of red) to convey a sense of secrecy, high stakes, and profound moral courage. Ages 7-11. Illustrator's agent: Advocate Art. (Feb.)
Residents of a small town in Nazi-occupied Denmark work together to provide a hidden Jewish mother and son safe passage to neutral Sweden. "New friends" are being harbored in Anett's dark basement for two nights. Though afraid, she allows their whispering voices to lead her down the stairs. Anett brings food from her mother's kitchen and books from the library until the boy and his mother can secretly board a fishing boat that will cross over to Sweden. Most of Anett's daily encounters with neighbors and shopkeepers show that the townsfolk support Anett's family in their dangerous effort. When the Nazis begin to search houses each night, the situation becomes even more perilous for Anett's family, and her father determines that they must be taken to the harbor despite the obscuring clouds. Without moonlight, the Jews are beckoned from door to door, guided only by whispering voices—"This way"—that indicate the route to safety. The direct simplicity of the story's telling serves well as an introduction for younger children to the Holocaust. Dark cartoon sketches reminiscent of Tomi Ungerer in opaque black, blues, grays and khaki green markers and word bubbles with the key words of direction paint the ominous atmosphere. This uncomplicated narrative of Danish resistance will facilitate teaching and discussion of a difficult yet necessary subject. (author's note) (Picture book. 5-8)
Write a Review
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >