- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Charming and Pleasant Fantasy
Title: Thimble Down
Series: Chronicles of Dorro
Author: Pete Prown
My Rating: 3 Stars
Good Reads Rating: 3.93 Stars
Content Rating: 10+
Similar Books: The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien, The Wind in the Willows by Kenneth Grahame
Check it out: Good Reads | Amazon | Barnes and Noble
Good Reads Summary:
THIMBLE DOWN is a country village where death and malice lurk the quiet lanes. When the vile, drunken Bing Rumple acquires a gem-laden treasure, violence begins to follow him everywhere. Where did Bing find such a precious jewel, and worse, is someone willing to kill to possess it? In this fast-paced adventure, the village bookmaster, Mr. Dorro, and his young companions Wyll Underfoot and Cheeryup Tunbridge are in a desperate race to find the answer—before death comes to Thimble Down.
This was a puzzling book for me. As I read, I kept thinking “I should love this. I should absolutely love this”, and yet, for some reason, I didn’t. I liked it; it has a lot going for it. But it never quite reached AMAZING status.
First off, Thimble Down is extremely charming. It’s sort of like reading a mix of The Wind in the Willows and the first chapter of The Hobbit. This is why I was having trouble understanding why Thimble Down just wasn’t wowing me. I love both of those books, so therefore, I SHOULD feel the same way about Thimble Down. Perhaps it wasn’t zany enough (like poor Bilbo’s Unexpected Party), or it wasn’t whimsical enough (like Mole discovering life outside his underground home).
Our main hero, Dorro Winderiver is a bit of an amateur investigator, who enjoys afternoon tea a bit more than mysteries. While this sounds like the charming part, there were whole sections dedicated to Dorro’s eating habits. The slow pace of the book, especially at the beginning, was my biggest disappointment. Very little happened for a good while, and when something finally did happen, it didn’t happen to anyone I cared about. Even then, things continued to move slowly.
Slow pace aside, the writing style in Thimble Down is lovely. Charming character voices, clever humor, entertaining descriptions of the inhabitants of Thimble Down and the work they do there all kept me interested enough to keep reading. Certainly there is a mystery to be solved, but again, it was not one I cared too much about. Dorro isn’t much of a hero at all, in the fantasy sense of the word; he prefers his books and, of course, his food.
The cast of secondary characters is charming and humorous, bumbling about trying to solve a murder. Few are up to the task, but it is certainly entertaining to see them try.
I don’t recommend Thimble Down if you’re looking for an exciting, edge-of-your seat thrilling fantasy novel. If, however, you are looking for a pleasant read to accompany a rainy day and a cup of tea, Thimble Down is the book for you.
As reviewed by Jessica at Ramblings on Readings.
Posted February 23, 2014
Delightful and funny.
Did I enjoy this book: It wasn’t terrible. There was nothing exceptional about it; I’d liken it to the B-movie version of The Hobbit, but I fear that’s doing it a disservice. It wasn’t BAD. Despite the fact that Prown’s world is seriously similar to Middle Earth (halflings, elves and all), I didn’t mind as much as I thought I would (or should). Instead of being annoyed that Prown borrows Tolkein’s world, I sort of wondered if this was, perhaps, a Hobbity town across the ocean that Gandalf hadn’t quite discovered yet. …A middling Middle Earth, perhaps?
Mostly I think Thimble Down is delightful and funny, and you’ll likely enjoy it if you know why it is the dwarves agree to bring Bilbo along on their journey. Even if you don’t know about Bilbo, I’d wager a pint you’d be interested to hear his tale after reading Thimble Down.
Would I recommend it: Yeah, why not? If you’re a LOTR fan (and you can get past the ‘ZOMG this is like, exactly the same’ business), you’ll get a good chuckle out of it.
Will I read it again: Meh.
As reviewed by Melissa at Every Free Chance Book Reviews.
(I received a copy of this book for review purposes.)
Posted January 5, 2013
A rip-roaring adventure, kind of old-school like Redwall, Artemis Fowl or The Hobbit. Can't wait for the next in the series!Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.