Highly Disappointing!
i have now read all 6 in this series since Fathers Day weekend (when His Majesty's Dragon was the book for Free Friday).
the other 5 books were either great, or very good.
this one SUCKED!!! i was nearly so bored and disgusted with this that i almost stopped reading it altogether...
SPOILERS:
ok, so Laurence and Temeraire get sent to "New South Wales" (soon to be Australia). the highly annoying Dragon, Iskeria, decides to come along.
the main plot seems to be the 3 dragon eggs that they are suppose to start a new Covert with down there. unfortunatly, Rankin is re-introduced, as are a few new characters you don't even get to know, including Cpt Bligh (Mutiny on the Bounty fame).
one egg hatches, Cpt Riley gets that dragonet, and he's still a jerk (but not to the dragon, oddly enough). but the dragon is just as annoying and pompous as Iskeria... why Temeraire doesn't just slap the taste out of their mouths throughout the story, i have no idea.
then, 1 of the eggs is stolen while they're out searching for a pass through the mountains! they spend damn near the rest of the freaking book talking about the stupid color of the rocks, the brush, the streams, the water, the.... you get the idea. nearly 150+ pages of NOTHINGNESS!!! it is 280 pages long, and on page 240, SOMETHING worthwhile finally happens!!! then it's over almost immediately, and it wasn't that compelling anyway.
really, did i need to know about every nook and cranny wherever they landed in the outback? no, i didn't. complete waste of time about every time they were trying to find the trail of the theives. did we need to have our time wasted with these lizard like "binyips" or whatever they were called, too?
the writing style seemed to change again. first books were all from Laurence's point of view, then one (or two) from Temeraire's. this one, seemed written from an outsiders view...
the ending, just doesn't make any sense at all. sure, it leaves you hanging, like "what will they do next?" and that's after you feel that Laurence and Tem are about to "break up"... and why didn't Tem beat the stuffing out of Iskeria for taking him down in the Ocean?
just a very frustrating and disappointing book compared to the first 5, WHICH I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
so many little sub-sub-plots that don't matter to the overall story and only seem to be there to take up space (or for the next book to take shape), just like the too descriptive story-telling about every color of rock and tree that doesn't matter. it went on and on and on, and nobody cares!!!
this book could have been 75-100 pages total, written in the same style as the first 5, and been a very good book.
if there's a 7th in the series, i sincerely hope the "test readers" have the nuts to give better feedback than what they did on this one. they should be fired to have allowed the author to continue with this little, and undramatic, substance to be put together and called a book.
sorry, but I'm not happy at all with this one, and loved the other 5, could wait to read the 6th... took my "nook" with me on family vacation just so i could read this book.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.