The Top Jobby Elizabeth Cody Kimmel, Robert Neubecker
Every kid loves to go with his or her parents to work. But how cool it would be if your dad was responsible for changing the lightbulbs at the top of the Empire State Building! Readers will be amazed by the details this book provides about one of the most recognizable buildings in the world and will relate to one girl's pride when she brags to her classmates about
Every kid loves to go with his or her parents to work. But how cool it would be if your dad was responsible for changing the lightbulbs at the top of the Empire State Building! Readers will be amazed by the details this book provides about one of the most recognizable buildings in the world and will relate to one girl's pride when she brags to her classmates about her dad's very high position.
It looks like the nameless narrator will have to take a backseat to the other kids on Career Day; their parents are astronomers, NASCAR drivers and jewelers, while her dad changes lightbulbs. But as the girl launches into her spiel, a different sort of lightbulb goes off as it dawns on the class that her father's job is pretty special after all: he's in charge of the beacon atop the antenna of the Empire State Building. Kimmel's (Lily B. on the Brink of Paris) speaks with authority because, as she explains, she actually accompanied Dad on his task the previous weekend. Kimmel has amassed a host of details, which she skillfully spins for her audience. The bulb is "about the size of our beagle's head but 620 watts brighter" and Dad better not drop it, because when he's at the very top, it's "one thousand four hundred fifty-three feet and eight and nine-sixteenths inches to the sidewalk." (The narrator brings a catcher's glove to the hatch below the antennae, just in case.) Neubecker equally deftly builds the story's visual momentum, alternating spot illustrations with full-page pictures (a vertiginous, bird's-eye view shows Dad at work); in a vertical spread, the re-lit landmark virtually glows. As he proved in Wow! City!, Neubecker's signature style can conjure up metropolitan magic; his ink outlines and punchy colors instantly convey why New York is a helluva town. Ages 4-up. (July)Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information
On career day, several children tell exciting, glamorous stories about their parents' jobs as racecar driver, jeweler, and UFO hunter. Then, the book's narrator announces that her dad changes lightbulbs. When a boy laughs at this seemingly boring career and the teacher attempts to move on to a different subject, the girl continues to speak. She explains that she recently accompanied her father on a bus, a train, and a subway when he changed the bulb at the top of the Empire State Building. The harrowing details of this adventure amaze her teacher and classmates as the child proves that initial assumptions can be very wrong. While the story is positive in theme, its telling leaves something to be desired. The young narrator provides excessively detailed, sophisticated data, and her voice ranges from childish to overly technical. Neubecker's clear, bright illustrations effectively convey action and emotion, but it's unlikely that children will sit through the narrator's somewhat lengthy explanations.
Amanda MossCopyright 2006 Reed Business Information.
- Penguin Young Readers Group
- Publication date:
- Edition description:
- Product dimensions:
- 7.80(w) x 10.80(h) x 0.20(d)
- Age Range:
- 3 - 5 Years
What People are saying about this
Meet the Author
Elizabeth Cody Kimmel lives in New York's Hudson Valley.
Robert Neubecker lives in Park City, Utah.
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >