Set in 1931 Berlin, Cantrell's scrupulously researched debut tolls a somber dirge for Weimar Germany in its last days. In the Hall of the Unnamed Dead, Hannah Vogel, a 32-year-old crime reporter for the Berliner Tageblatt, recognizes a photograph of a naked corpse on a riverbank as that of her beloved brother, Ernst, an unabashedly gay transvestite cabaret singer. In her search for Ernst's killer, Hannah uncovers his sexual connections reach from newly recruited young Nazis to the highest levels of the Nazi party. Hannah and Anton, a five-year-old waif who claims Ernst was his father, along with her tender lover, Boris, tread an ominous tightrope as Cantrell unveils the best and the worst of the German character, setting the humanity of decent Germans, Jews and gentiles alike, against the Nazis' raw savagery and mindless militarism. This unforgettable novel, which can be as painful to read as the history it foreshadows, builds to an appropriately bittersweet ending. (May)Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
A Trace of Smoke (Hannah Vogel Series #1)by Rebecca Cantrell
Even though hardened crime reporter Hannah Vogel knows all too well how tough it is to survive in 1931 Berlin, she is devastated when she sees a photograph of her brother's body posted in the Hall of the Unnamed Dead. Ernst, a cross-dressing lounge singer at a seedy nightclub, had many secrets, a never-ending list of lovers, and plenty of opportunities to get into
Even though hardened crime reporter Hannah Vogel knows all too well how tough it is to survive in 1931 Berlin, she is devastated when she sees a photograph of her brother's body posted in the Hall of the Unnamed Dead. Ernst, a cross-dressing lounge singer at a seedy nightclub, had many secrets, a never-ending list of lovers, and plenty of opportunities to get into trouble.
Hannah delves into the city's dark underbelly to flush out his murderer, but the late night arrival of a five-year-old orphan on her doorstep complicates matters. The endearing Anton claims that Hannah is his mother… and that her dead brother Ernst is his father.
As her investigations into Ernst's murder and Anton's parentage uncover political intrigue and sex scandals in the top ranks of the rising Nazi party, Hannah fears not only for her own life, but for that of a small boy who has come to call her "mother."
Cantrell's debut offers up a grittily realistic portrayal of 1930s Berlin as the Nazis come to power. While covering her usual crime beat, newspaper reporter Hannah Vogel unexpectedly spots a photo of her brother Ernst in the Alexanderplatz Police Station on a wall displaying pictures of the unclaimed dead. Ernst had been living a high-profile life as a gay man, performing in a cabaret and exposing himself to danger by associating with known Nazis. Though barely getting by in a time when money and resources are scarce, Hannah risks it all by launching a solo investigation to find her brother's murderer. She is unable to confide in even her closest friends lest they be targeted by corrupt police or Nazis. Keeping the suspense high, Cantrell does an excellent job of projecting the fear of the time through her characters. Sure to appeal to fans of Alan Furst and other noir historical thrillers; strongly recommended.
“Bold narrator and chilling historical setting...an unusually vivid context, [lets] Hannah report on the decadence of her world without losing her life –or her mind.”—The New York Times Book Review
“A gritty realistic portrayal of 1930s Berlin…keeping the suspense high, Cantrell does an excellent job of projecting the fear of the time through her characters. Strongly recommended.”—Library Journal (starred)
“[A] haunting debut novel….evocative, compassionate, and compelling.”—Kirkus Reviews (starred)
“Cantrell nails both the ‘life is a cabaret’ atmosphere and the desperation floating inside the champagne bubbles… a promising debut.”--Booklist
“Set in 1931 Berlin, Cantrell’s scrupulously researched debut tolls a somber dirge for Weimar Germany in its last days…this unforgettable novel, which can be as painful to read as the history it foreshadows, builds to an appropriately bittersweet ending.”--Publishers Weekly (starred review)
“A compelling and human story that captures brilliantly the atmosphere of Berlin during the rise of the Nazis.”—Anne Perry, New York Times bestselling author of We Shall Not Sleep
"Evocative and hauntingly crafted, Rebecca Cantrell's debut mystery A Trace of Smoke is a treasure of suspense, romance, and murder. Her ability to spin history into a visceral reality is done with the artistry of a master storyteller. Truly a stunning start to a long career."--James Rollins, New York Times bestseller of The Judas Strain
"Make room on your bookshelf for a talented new novelist named Rebecca Cantrell. In A Trace of Smoke, she delivers a historical mystery that works on every level. It's a riveting page-turner. It's an insightful study of a young woman in peril. It's a unerringly accurate vision of a society slipping steadily toward madness. And it's written with a sense of clarity, pace, and attention to detail that tells you this author is going to be writing terrific stories for a long time. So don't miss her debut."--William Martin, New York Times bestselling author of Back Bay and The Lost Constitution
“Step into the fun house world of 1931 Berlin where no one and nothing is what it seems…. A Trace of Smoke is compulsive reading with all the juiciness of the tawdry world of Cabaret but told with keen insight to the historical criminality taking place.”--Sara Colleton, executive producer of Dexter and The Painted Veil
"Moving through the Berlin of 1931, with the monstrosity of the next decade stirring beneath the streets, Rebecca Cantrell's characters illustrate the very human desire to cling to innocence and joy, to do right no matter the cost, to shelter light amidst growing darkness. Both personal and historical, A Trace of Smoke clings to the mind."--Laurie R. King, New York Times bestselling author of The Game
Read an Excerpt
Echoes of my footfalls faded into the damp air of the Hall of the Unnamed Dead as I paused to stare at the framed photograph of a man. He was laid out against a riverbank, dark slime wrapped around his sculpted arms and legs. Even through the paleness and rigidity of death, his face was beautiful. A small, dark mole graced the left side of his cleft chin. His dark eyebrows arched across his forehead like bird wings, and his long hair, dark now with water, streamed out behind him.
Watery morning light from high windows illuminated the neat grid of black-and-white photographs lining the walls of the Alexanderplatz police station. One hundred frames displayed the faces and postures of Berlin’s most recent unclaimed dead. Every Monday the police changed out the oldest photographs to make room for the latest editions of those who carried no identification, as was too often the case in Berlin since the Great War.
My eyes darted to the words under the photograph that had called to me. Fished from the water by a sightseeing boat the morning of Saturday, May 30, 1931—the day before yesterday. Apparent cause of death: stab wound to the heart. Under distinguishing characteristics they listed a heart-shaped tattoo on his lower back that said "Father." No identification present.
I needed none. I knew the face as well as my own, or my sister Ursula’s, with our square jaws and cleft chins. I wore my dark blond hair cut short into a bob, but he wore his long, like our mother, like any woman of a certain age, although he was neither a woman nor of a certain age. He was my baby brother, Ernst.
My fingers touched the cool glass that covered the image, aching to touch the young man himself. I had not seen him naked since I’d bathed him as a child. I pulled my peacock- green silk scarf from my neck to cover him, realizing instantly how crazy that was. Instead, I clenched the scarf in my hand. A gift from him.
I knew standard procedure dictated that the body be buried within three days. It might already be in an unmarked grave, wrapped in a coarse linen shroud. After Ernst left home and started earning his own money, he swore that only silk and cashmere would touch his body. I flattened my palm on the glass. The picture could not be real.
"Hannah!" called a booming voice. Without turning, I recognized the baritone of Fritz Waldheim, a policeman at Alexanderplatz. A voice that had never before frightened me. "Here for the reports?"
I drew my hand back from the photograph and cleared my throat. "Of course," I called. My damp skirt brushed my calves as I trudged down the hall to his office in the Criminal Investigations Department, struggling to bring my emotions under control. Feel nothing now, I told myself. You can feel it later, but not until after you leave the police station.
Fritz held the door open, and I nodded my thanks. He was the kindly husband of my oldest friend, and I feared that he would recognize the photograph too, if he studied it closely. He must not suspect that Ernst was dead. My identity papers, and Ernst’s, were on a ship to America with my friend Sarah and her son Tobias.
Sarah, a prominent Zionist troublemaker, was forbidden to travel by order of the German government. We’d loaned them our identity papers so they could masquerade as Hannah and Ernst Vogel, a German brother and sister on vacation. Their ship would dock soon, and our papers would be returned, but until that happened no one could notice anything that Hannah and Ernst Vogel did in Berlin without placing their lives in danger. Even though Ernst had acted distant with me for the past six months, he had agreed to the plan.
"Still raining, I see." Fritz pointed to my dripping umbrella. I’d forgotten I still held it. He closed the office door.
"Washes the dog shit off the sidewalks." I forced a laugh that tore my lungs. The weather remained our favorite joke, Fritz and mine. We jested about that and his Alsatian dog, Caramel. "How are Bettina and the children?" I tried to always keep it light with him. To make him enjoy handing me the police reports so much it did not cross his mind that he did not need to do it.
"Are you crying?" he asked, concern in his gray eyes. No getting past Fritz, the experienced detective.
"A cold." I wiped my wet face with my wet hand. I hated to lie to him, but Fritz ran everything by the book. He would neither understand, nor forgive, passing off my papers, even to save Sarah. "A cold and the rain."
He took a clean, white handkerchief out of his uniform pocket and handed it to me. It smelled of starch from Bettina’s wifely care. "Thank you," I said, wiping my cheeks. "Anything interesting?"
Like every Monday, I had come to the police station to sift through the weekend’s crime reports in search of a story for the Berliner Tageblatt, looking for a tale of horror to titillate our readers. Mondays were the best times for fresh reports. People got up to more trouble on weekends, and at the full moon. Ernst’s photograph flashed through my head. He too, had got up to more trouble on the weekend. I swallowed my grief and handed Fritz his handkerchief.
Fritz shook his head. "We found a few floaters last weekend." He walked behind the wooden counter that separated his work area from the public area. "Mostly vagrants, I think. Probably a few from a new power struggle between criminal rings, but we’ll not prove it."
I held my face stiff, using the polite smile I’d mastered as a child. I was grateful for the beatings, slappings, and pinchings I’d received from my parents. They had taught me to hold this face no matter what my real thoughts and feelings. Ernst had mocked me for it. Everything he thought or felt showed on his face the instant it entered his head. And now he was dead. I gulped, once more fighting for control. Fritz furrowed his brow. He suspected something was wrong, in spite of my best efforts.
"Anything worth my time?" I said to Fritz, because that is what I would have said on any other day.
"A group of Nazis beat a Communist almost to death, but that’s not news."
"Not news," I said. "But newsworthy, even though the Tageblatt will not run it. Someone should care what the Nazis are doing."
"We care," Fritz said. "But the courts let them go faster than we can arrest them."
He turned and walked to a large oak file cabinet. As he sorted through folders I took a few steadying breaths.
"Here we go." He pulled out a stack of papers.
I leaned against the counter and tried to look composed.
Fritz passed me the incident reports with his short, blunt fingers. "Not much, I’m afraid."
"Hey!" called a high- pitched male voice behind Fritz. "You must not give her those reports." A small man with erect military bearing rushed over to us and snatched the papers from my hand. "Who are you?"
Fritz looked worried. "She’s Hannah Vogel, with the Berliner Tageblatt."
"You have identification?" He stared at me with dark crow’s eyes. His thick black hair was perfectly in order, his suit meticulously pressed.
"Of course," I said. My identification rested in Sarah’s purse on a boat in the middle of the ocean. I rummaged through my satchel for show, grief replaced again by fear.
"I’ve known her since she was seventeen years old," Fritz said.
The man ignored him and snapped his fingers at me. "Papers, please."
"They must be here somewhere." My knees threatened to collapse.
I took things out of my satchel: a green notebook, a clean handkerchief, a jade- colored fountain pen that Ernst bought for me after he left home.
"What do you do at the Tageblatt?" His tone sounded accusatory. He leaned closer to me. I yearned to back away, but forced myself to remain still, like someone with nothing to hide.
"Crime reporter," I answered, looking up. "Under the name of Peter Weill."
"The Peter Weill?" His tone shifted. He was a fan.
"For the past several years," I said. "I have worked closely with the police all that time."
I pulled my press pass out of my satchel and handed it to him, then flipped open my sketchbook to a courtroom sketch published in the paper a week ago.
His face creased in a smile. "I remember that picture. Your line work is quite accomplished." He returned my press pass, and I tucked it into my satchel.
"Thank you," I said. "It’s so rare that anyone notices. You have a discerning eye."
Fritz suppressed a smile when the man stood up even straighter and held out his hand.
I wiped my palm on my skirt before shaking his hand. "Good to meet you."
"The plea sure is mine." He rocked back on the heels of his highly polished shoes. "Your articles have astute insight into the criminal mind. And the measures we must take in order to protect good German people from the wrong elements."
"I try to do a good, fair job by getting my information from the source." I glanced at the reports in his hand.
He bowed and handed them to me. "So many reporters these days speak only to victims. Or criminals."
"They are important sources as well." I took the reports with a hand that trembled only slightly. "One must be thorough."
"You have such insight into the male mind. You and your husband must be very close."
"She’s never been married," Fritz said. The corners of his mouth twitched with a suppressed smile.
"Might you autograph an article for me?" Kommissar Lang clasped his hands behind his back and leaned forward. "Do you have an article in today’s paper?"
I had not yet read today’s paper. "I am not certain."
"Yesterday’s," Fritz said. "Front page."
"I will procure a copy." Kommissar Lang hastened out of the room. Fritz returned to his desk without saying a word. His shoulders twitched with laughter, but he kept a serious face. It cost me, but I gave him the expected warning smile.
When I glanced down at the reports, I saw gibberish. Lines of black type ran along the paper, but my mind could not turn them into words. My hand shook as I pretended to take notes, but I hoped Fritz could not see that from his desk. I willed myself to think of nothing but numbers and stared at the second hand of my watch, silently counting each tick. When three minutes elapsed, I put the unread reports down on the counter. "You are correct, Fritz," I said. "Not much there."
I would find no report of a sensational murder or string of robberies for Peter Weill’s byline today. And the murder I most wanted to research I could not ask a single question about. No attention dared fall on Ernst or me. If Sarah and her son were still underway, they might be arrested. Because of her political activism, she had been denied immigration to the United States three times. But it was becoming harder for even apolitical Jews to leave Germany. If the National Socialists, the Nazis, were to gain the majority in the Reichstag, I shuddered to think what would happen. Anti- Semitic scapegoating ran deep everywhere in Europe. As disgusting as I found it, I had to admit that Hitler was far too clever at using it for his political ends. Things would get worse before they got better.
I turned and marched back down the hall, willing myself not to glance at the photograph. If I did not look, perhaps it would not be true.
"Fraulein Vogel," called Kommissar Lang. I heard him sprinting after me.
Something was amiss. Would he demand to see my papers again, papers I still did not have? I envisioned bolting through the front door of the police station, but instead I turned to him, ready to concoct a story of lost papers.
"You forgot my autograph," he panted.
"I do apologize." Relief flooded over me. "It slipped my mind. I am so late for the Becker trial."
Kommissar Lang nodded. "The rapist who targeted schoolgirls in the park?"
"That one." Any other day I would have asked him about his involvement in the case, but today I needed to get away before I broke down.
He thrust the paper at me.
"I apologize in advance if there’s anything inaccurate. My editor has a leaden touch."
He handed me a pen. "Come to my office and sign it." He gestured back down the hallway, past the photograph of Ernst. If I followed him, I knew that he would regale me with tales of his arrests and later be offended that I did not write each one for the Tageblatt. I had been through that with countless police officers, and afterward they were never much use as sources.
I placed his newspaper against the wall and signed it. "I must be at the court house early. It is best to watch the accused come in and sit down. One learns so much."
He nodded. "One can determine a great deal from watching someone walk."
I handed him back the newspaper and walked out the front door, trying not to let the wobble in my knees betray me.
Outside, a gust of wind tried to rip the umbrella out of my hands, but I held on, cursing and half- crying as I stumbled across cobblestones to the subway. I pushed my way down concrete stairs, against the crush of people going to work. They chattered and laughed together, gleeful in the mundane details of their lives. I wanted only to go home and be alone.
Pictures of Ernst flashed by in my head. The most painful images were from his childhood. He’d been a wonderful child and, later, a great friend. I leaned against the wall of the subway station, face turned toward the tile, and sobbed, safely alone in the crowd. When I could stand and walk again, I did.
Once aboard the train I collapsed on the wooden seat and drew a deep breath. I ran my fingers over the oak slats of the bench. The wood was blond, like Ernst’s hair. Across from me, their faces hidden behind twin newspapers, sat two men in black fedoras. One man read the Berliner Tageblatt, the other the Völkische Beobachter, that Nazirag.
Excerpted from A Trace of Smoke by Rebecca Cantrell.
Copyright © 2009 by Rebecca Cantrell.
Published in May 2009 by Tom Doherty Associates, LLC.
All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright laws and reproduction is strictly prohibited. Permission to reproduce the material in any manner or medium must be secured from the Publisher.
Meet the Author
Rebecca Cantrell majored in German, Creative Writing, and History at the Freie Universitaet of Berlin and Carnegie Mellon University. She currently lives in Hawaii with her husband and son. A Trace of Smoke is her first novel.
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >
In 1931 thirty two years old crime reporter for the Berliner Tageblatt Hannah Vogel visits Berlin's Hall of the Unnamed Dead. There on the wall is the picture of an unknown naked corpse whom she recognizes. The victim is her beloved gay brother Ernst, who could not harm a fly; he had no papers because he gave them to their Jewish friends to escape dangerous Germany for New York. Outraged that someone would torture and kill her effeminate kind sibling, she knows she must remain silent re his identity or her "lost papers until their friends reach America. Still Hannah investigates using Ernst's sexual proclivity and his performing at the underground El Dorado cabaret as the starting points With the help of her dedicated lover and a young urchin claiming to be her nephew, Hannah makes her inquiries including the claim of the street kid that her obviously gay brother sired a child. This is a powerful historical tale that looks deep inside the souls of the groups that make up the Weimer Republic at a time when Hitler is just starting to rise in power. The story line contrasts caring people from various religions vs. the brutal angry assaults of the Nazis. Not an easy read with no sugar coating, A TRACE OF SMOKE will have readers pondering whether this could happen in modern day America. Harriet Klausner
This story manages to fit neatly into four genre categories and does it amazingly well! While reading, my imagination portrayed the story in black and white form with dashes of color, mostly red, which is significant to the gay character. This is not due to a lack of development, but rather should be taken as a compliment to the author's talent to imprint emotions into the scene without directly stating or over dramatizing. I felt a connection to each character and grew to care about them all, even the 'bad' guys because their humanity coupled with history sparked a touch of sympathy. The lead character is an inspirational female, not for her overtly heroic antics, but for her ability to cope and face challenging situations. Thematically, the story builds on many levels, and for me the most convincing is the sense of bravery. Every character at some point and to some degree shows bravery and compassion, which makes this a moving and deeply human historical tale worth exploring. I don't want to give anything away, but the ending was a bit too easy of an escape especially given the power of the foe the lead character faces. However, I am eager to read A Night of Long Knives (sequel,#2) to see where it picks up. Perhaps my questions or reservations will be answered. Please take into consideration I'm really picking to find one small flaw. I almost hate to mention it because the book was craftily constructed and I do not wish to tarnish this jewel!
The wild despair that characterized Berlin in the early thirties has been the subject of many books and films, possibly because the setting is ripe with possibilities for drama and intrigue. "The Damned" and "Cabaret" both explored this world, and Rebecca Cantrell's debut novel feels as if it may someday be considered one of the significant works of this genre. The story follows the dangerous misadventures of Hannah Vogel, the author of a "true crime" column (under an assumed male identity) for a Berlin newspaper. When Hannah's brother, a cabaret personality, is found murdered, there is little interest and not many clues. But the boy may not have been as insignificant as it first appears, and the investigation soon leads to some very important and frighteningly dangerous people. Cantrell's style is elegant and fluid: Hannah is a sympathetic heroine, and her observations about those she encounters give the book a gentle heart, even when it concerns itself with the sordid side of Berlin's underground. Accurate period detail seems to be an essential ingredient in the success of such historical thrillers. Cantrell has clearly done extensive research, and the smoky clubs, squalid apartments, and intimidating government chambers are vividly realized. But some readers may be even more delighted by the passages that describe the love of writing, the passion for communicating on paper, and the almost addictive need Hannah has for telling her story as she lives it: "A Trace of Smoke" is a writer's book, as much about the words as it is about the events that lead to a suspenseful and satisfying conclusion. We've all read and seen stories about the horrors of the Nazi movement, but this book wisely tells that vast story through two characters--Hannah and an abandoned boy she informally adopts--and provides both a sense of the epic and an intimate look at the devastation wrought by monsters who murder adults and use children as pawns.
This is an interesting tale, pleasantly told although the writing is nothing special- lots of simple sentences given by a narrator apparently not well-educated. The gay men in the story are either Nazis or cross-dressers, but lovers all. The young man, Indian warrior as he is, is probably the most interesting character in the book. I can't decide if I want to read the sequel or leave well enough alone. As it is, Phillip Kerr's Bernie Gunther novels, set in Berlin in the same era, satisfy my need to know of this time and are much better written. But this one definitely has heart.
Rebecca Cantrell transports the reader to Berlin in 1931. The city is filled with unrest and political upheaval as the Nazis exert their power. Here we meet Hannah Vogel, a reporter with the Berliner Tageblatt. She is a woman of strength, conviction and courage, but the murder of her brother, Ernest, changes her destiny. Afraid yet determined she searches to find his killer and have her revenge. The path is long and has many obstacles but Hannah will not give up. The story is so well written that I felt I was there with Hannah looking for answers. Rebecca's characters are so well defined that the jump off the page. If you enjoy a story filled with mystery and suspense, read A Trace of Smoke. I received a copy of this book from the author.
This book stunned me. I am not usually one to read mysteries, I usually find them slow and predictable. However this book was neither. I have A.D.H.D. so its hard for me to be able to start a book, get into it and then continue it to the end if it doesn't hold my attention. I started to read this book and was unable to stop till real life called me away. Even then a week later I couldn't help but find the book still held my attention enough that in my first free time I had again, I just had to finish. Now I cant wait to read the next book in the series "A night of long knives". I found that I could see myself alot in the main character Hannah. In fact I found her inspiring. Without giving any spoilers to the book itself I will say I can relate to Hannah in so many ways like, scraping by with very little food to survive but always trying to show a stronger side of myself to others, while hiding my true emotions as to not draw attention. I found her very determined and resourceful and strong willed even in her weaker moments. The characters all had very different personalities which kept you on your toes as to what each one will do in different situations as she hunts down her brothers killer all while her life is turned upside down into a roller coaster ride of mystery. I also have to admit I have never read a book even remotely like A trace of smoke. But I loved it and even learned some things along the way. I suggest this book to anyone who likes mystery books or is still looking for one that will surprise them and catch their interest. And now I am going to start the next book in the series because I cant wait to see what kind of adventure Hannah will have next :)
I found this book by accident while shopping at a garage sale. I picked it up,read the back cover and laid it down and looked at other things. Before leaving the garage sale I went back and picked the book up again and bought it. It's not something I would probably normally read just based on the back cover. I did read it and I loved it! It was one of the best books I had read in a very long time. It's set in Nazi Germany and blends fiction with real past history. I loved Hannah and her story and actually didn't want the book to end. Imagine how happy I was to find out there were three more Hannah Vogel books waiting for me to read!!! I've read all of them now and hope her story continues. You will love this book too!!
I just started reading Rebecca Cantrell and am hooked on this series. She really brings WWII Germany to life, and makes you understand better the life they had to lead back then. She does a great job of building the characters along with some action. I will be definitely reading the rest in this series.