Worse than MTV
I could write a long, erudite speech on how horrible this books is, and so can many others, but I just don't have the space.
SMeyer is not a very good writer. She uses words over and over, and in the wrong context. I swear to God, I can't tell you how many times I read "chagrin". She has poor grammar and sentence structure, and I'm just wondering where her editors were. It's only expected, though, when she did not have past writing career. She just woke up one day and thought she could write a book. It does not work like that. Her lack of experience shines through when every page there is a sentence describing how beautiful Edward is.
Her characters were flat and annoying. Half of them I forgot (and Bella did, too). Bella, the main character, is selfish, annoying, and clingy. She calls the people who try to become friends with her overly helpful, and is immediately attracted to the people who don't give a damn about her existence. Especially Edward. Edward is immediately the cool, mysterious love interest. And that's it. He has no personality whatsoever. He is pretty creepy, watching Bella when she sleeps and messing with her car so she can't see her friends. This is protective, it's emotionally abusive. Yes, Eddy is abusive. I was especially annoyed by Midnight Sun, and his view on his students. It's mostly the author's fault for believing the entire human race has the same, petty thoughts. But then Eddy comes in with his super sized ego and claims that all the humans are pathetic in their way of thinking. I know a lot of people have worries outside of boyfriends, homework, and the medial life within school grounds. SMeyer just wants to paint Bella in the picture that she is "different", when in actuality, she fits in quite nicely with the background.
Bella and Edward together have an unhealthy relationship. When Eddy left her, Bella was on the verge of committing suicide. She was depressed, even though a lot of people care about her and want to help her. She's ungrateful and stupid, especially when Jacob comes into play. He was an alright character to begin with, but then he became a borderline rapist. Edward, when he though his love had killed herself, wanted to be killed by the bad guys. Romeo and Juliet pulled it off better. The rest of the characters are inserts, and do nothing to the story.
Another thing, there is no plot. And don't say that Eddy and Bella's relationship is a plot. First of all, it is not. Second of all, they have no relationship. Eddy "loves" Bella because she smells good and Bella "loves" Eddy because he's hot (and there's not a page that doesn't tells us how attractive he is). There's only lust and obsession, and love never comes into play. Kisses and one-liners are not romance, either. Conversation, laughter, and love is. Saying "you are exactly my brand of heroine" is not a conversation, just a pick-up line. And when there is a plot, it is introduced 300 pages in and is definitely anti-climatic.
I could go on with the deus ex machina, character analysis, and other things that Twilight fans haven't taken into consideration, but I believe you've got the overall message. Twilight sucks. Period.
17 out of 31 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.