Entertaining (Book Twirps review)
In the land of Quill, any child who shows any type of artistic talent is considered a threat to the government. To be artistic shows a tendency to be a free-thinker, which, in turn, could cause a problem for the government. At the age of thirteen all children are categorized as wanted, necessary or unwanted. Thirteen-year-old Alex has known for months that when the time comes, he will be listed as unwanted and be sentenced to death. His twin brother, Aaron, however, is selected as a wanted and will be sent to university to study and eventually serve on the cities government. When Alex and the other unwanteds are shipped off to the death farm, they are surprised to find that something special awaits them. A secret, magical land called Artime is hidden behind the gates of Quill, hidden by magic. No one in the land of Quill knows about Artime, and the government assumes the children have all been put to death when in fact they are being trained in the arts, allowed to think freely and learning to use magic.
Though Alex is ecstatic to have found a place where he can be himself, he can't help but miss his twin brother, and wonders if somehow he can bring Aaron to join him in Artime. What Alex doesn't realize is that Aaron is happy with his new position and strives to one day become the ruler of Quill. When the existence of Artime is threatened, the members must fight to keep their beloved freedom, and much to Alex's disappointment, this fight will pit him against his twin brother.
This book is marketed as a cross between Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. While I'm sure this is great for marketing, and will entice curious readers, I'm afraid these readers may be disappointed. While Ms. McCann's book is enjoyable and certainly has its merits, it is neither of the before mentioned books. The only similarity it has to The Hunger Games is the dystopian setting of Quill. While the magical land of Artime, and the magic the children learn in school could be compared to the magic of the Harry Potter series, McCann's world is not nearly as immersive. I read this book expecting something more because of the blurb on the cover. Don't get me wrong, there is a lot to be enjoyed within the pages of The Unwanteds. McCann's Artime is rife with potential. The talking blackboards, the transportation tubes and the "artsy" magic the children learn are all enjoyable. I think I may have enjoyed it more had I not had such high expectations. I also felt the book was rushed. There is a lot happening in the book, and I would have liked more in the way of the magic lessons, and I would have liked the mystery to have been a little deeper. I felt a lot of this was glazed over to reach the battle at the end. All in all the book is enjoyable, and it will definitely appeal to the targeted audience provided they are not die-hard Harry Potter fans.
(Review based on an advanced reviewer's copy courtesy of the publisher via Simon & Schuster's GalleyGrab)
2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.