Read an Excerpt
The Wheel of Progress
“Demagoguery and democracy are brothers in etymology and spirit . . . for the German ear the word democracy awakens memories of complete chaos after the First [World] War.” —Magnus Freiherr Von Braun
When Wernher von Braun was about ten years old, his tall, elegant mother, Emmy Freifrau (Baroness) von Braun, asked him what he would like to do with his life. “I want to help turn the wheel of progress” was his answer, a response that sounded odd and surprising to her, coming out of the mouth of a small boy. An unusually abstract statement, it prefigured a lifetime of fascination with science and technology.
Equally surprising, it came from the mouth of a true son of the Junkers—the noble caste that had once dominated the Prussian civil service, officer corps, and landowning elite. Engineering and science were not careers that Junker sons often chose, even in the 1920s. It seemed to reflect some inner compulsion of Wernher’s, but it also reflected the tenor of the times—a time of dramatic technological and political change. He had been born in 1912, in a traditional prewar world; his massively built, mustachioed father, Magnus Freiherr von Braun, had been a rapidly ascending civil servant in the empire of Kaiser Wilhelm II, while his intellectually gifted mother was the orphaned daughter of an estate owner. Less than ten years later his father would be forced out of the civil service in the political turmoil of the new Weimar Republic. The family moved to the modern world city of Berlin. Yet as much of a maverick and a Berliner as Wernher von Braun would turn out to be, his Prussian Junker upbringing influenced his values, his abilities, and his choices—more so, in fact, than his father would later be willing to credit.
Of his parents’ two families, the von Brauns and the von Quistorps, the former was of much older aristocratic stock. Magnus von Braun, who inherited from his father the hobby of genealogical research, eventually traced the male line back to 1285, although in all probability an ancestor had battled the Mongols at Liegnitz in 1241. The von Brauns arose from the soil of Silesia, a verdant and rolling province on both sides of the Oder River, east of the Czech heartland of Bohemia and Moravia. In 1573 the Holy Roman emperor elevated two of them to the rank of Reichsfreiherr (imperial baron) for their military accomplishments.
Magnus von Braun came, however, from an even more distant outpost of Germandom, East Prussia—a province that would disappear from the map in 1945, when Stalin divided it between the Soviet Union and Poland. In 1738 one descendant of the family, Gotthard Freiherr von Braun, entered Prussian service as a lieutenant in the garrison of the province’s capital city of Königsberg (now Kaliningrad, Russia). There he married the daughter of a wealthy local burgher. His fifth child, Sigismund, also a Prussian officer, purchased the estate of Neucken, about fifty kilometers southwest of the city, in 1803 and erected a new house—Magnus von Braun’s ancestral home. One of the family’s close acquaintances in Königsberg had been the philosopher Immanuel Kant; the silver sugar spoon he gave to Sigismund as a wedding present was a holy object in the glass cabinet of the mansion, along with a golden snuffbox from Czar Alexander I of Russia. But in February 1807, not long after the house was finished, Napoleon fought the bloody and inconclusive Battle of Preussisch Eylau against the czar’s army around Neucken. Napoleon’s troops killed or stole all the farm animals, wrecked the estate buildings, and plundered the house, although valuables like Kant’s spoon were successfully carried away or hidden. It took the family years to recuperate economically from the damage—but the starvation and death inflicted on the estate’s enserfed peasantry were much worse.
On the seventy-first anniversary of the battle, 7 February 1878, a boy, Magnus Alexander Maximilian, was born at Neucken. His father was Lieutenant Colonel Maximilian Freiherr von Braun, who had inherited the estate in part because no fewer than three of his brothers, as Prussian officers, were killed in the 1866 war against Austria-Hungary. Military values and a fervent loyalty to the Hohenzollern kings of Prussia—who, after 1871, became emperors of the new, Prussian-dominated Germany—were the heart of the values taught on the estate. Magnus was the youngest of five; his brothers Friedrich (Fritz) and Siegfried both became army officers. While Fritz had to terminate his career to take over Neucken shortly before World War I because of the failing health of their father, Siegfried served all through the war, ending as colonel of the Third Guards Regiment. He was forced into other employment only because of the military’s drastic downsizing as a result of the Versailles Treaty.
Acceptable career choices for sons of the Prussian nobility were limited. Every able-bodied male was expected to at least serve a stint in the army before returning to estate agriculture, if there was a prospect of an inheritance—which in the nineteenth century was usually limited by primogeniture to the eldest son. Of course, a young man also had the possibility of marrying into an estate or, less often, accumulating enough wealth to buy one. As Prussia’s bureaucracy expanded from the eighteenth century on, however, the higher civil service and diplomatic corps opened up as employment possibilities for younger sons. Unlike the British aristocracy, all children of the Prussian aristocracy, male and female, inherited the father’s title, with the result that there were a lot of barons, countesses, and the like who usually lived well as a result of the privileges afforded them but had no landed property.
Daughters in this very patriarchal society inevitably faced even more limited choices. Outside of marriage, about the only prospects they had were to remain with the family as a maiden aunt and sister, or to become a nurse or administrator in a church-based hospital or charity institution. As the Junkers (outside of parts of Silesia) were aggressively Lutheran, the option of taking holy orders was unavailable. Magnus von Braun’s oldest sibling, Magdalene (born 1865), remained at Neucken her whole life, whereas Adele eventually became the head of a children’s sanatorium on the Baltic coast of East Prussia. Neither ever married.
Old age often puts a nostalgic glow on one’s memories of childhood. Magnus von Braun’s memoirs, completed in American exile in the late 1940s and early 1950s, are no exception in that regard. He described Neucken as a patriarchal utopia: “the whole estate thought of itself as a large family. . . . Neighborly love . . . was natural and inevitable and at the same time Christian in nature. Patriarchal life on the land bound the people together into a tight community of fate.” The housing of Neucken’s laborers was, he conceded, “still primitive in my earliest youth,” but nonetheless it was better than the conditions he later witnessed in eastern Europe—not to mention those of blacks and Mexicans in Texas and Alabama. (Prussia had abolished serfdom in the early decades of the century, not necessarily to the benefit of the peasants, who often lost their land.) Raised in a stable, hierarchical, rural society in which dissent was rare, Magnus von Braun never saw any need to question a state of affairs in which the Junkers ran local government as their private preserve and most villages were wholly owned appendages of the estates. Indeed, his memoir forthrightly states his reactionary, monarchist, elitist politics—there had always been, and would always be, rulers and ruled; equality was unnatural. In the 1960s he told one of his grandsons, “This democracy thing is just a passing fad.”
Educated by a tutor at Neucken until the age of ten, he was then sent to Königsberg to receive the traditional elite education of the humanistic Gymnasium, with a heavy emphasis on languages—in the upper grades, a lot of Latin and Greek. He apparently showed some talent; after graduating on Easter 1896, he made his way to the old, venerable University of Göttingen in north-central Germany to study law, the mandatory path into the civil service. With his baronial title and with a healthy stipend from his father, Magnus was able to join an elite dueling fraternity, the Corps Saxonia, “which was made up almost exclusively of landed nobles.” In the old fraternity tradition, he did not study very hard but rather demonstrated his manliness by drinking and dueling. Graduating in spring 1899, he took his civil service entry exams in Königsberg and then did his one-year military service as an officer in the old Prussian royal city of Potsdam, outside Berlin. Again, his connections were the best: he entered the Hohenzollerns’ elite infantry regiment, the First Foot Guards. Kaiser Wilhelm II’s sons served in this regiment, and Magnus’s eldest brother, Fritz, was a captain in the Guards’ Rifle Battalion, which was responsible for the army’s first experiments with machine guns. Apparently the young Magnus made such a good impression that, when he finished his service in the fall of 1900, the officers of the regiment made him a reserve lieutenant. The rank and uniform, like the elite fraternity membership, were of great value in Imperial German society.
Returning to the civil service track, he then served the long, unpaid apprenticeship that led to the second exam and a permanent and paying position—a system designed to allow only the propertied access to the higher ranks. After serving in various places in eastern and western Prussia, he passed the assessor’s exam in 1905, although not with flying colors. But he showed initiative, a talent for dealing with people, and the imagination to grapple with the new industrialized world far outside the realm of the Junkers. The Junkers’ anticapitalism is often exaggerated, but their view of the world was often circumscribed by their narrow self-interest as big landowners and as members of a ruling elite. Magnus von Braun spent a year and a half as deputy to the county commissioner (Landrat) in the Ruhr city of Essen, which was dominated by the Krupps, the armaments and steel barons. Then he arranged a six-month leave to study trade and city administration in London in 1907, working at a voluntary position in the office of a German bank in the world center of finance and trade. This experience catapulted him into higher circles upon his return home. A chance conversation in Berlin resulted in his diversion from the traditional civil service justice track into the Prussian Trade Ministry, where he served as an adjutant to the minister, Clemens Delbrück. In late 1909 he met Emmy von Quistorp at a reception at the minister’s house and was immediately smitten. Only seven or eight months later, on 12 July 1910, they married at her family’s estate, Crenzow, in western Pomerania, near the small cities of Anklam and Greifswald—and only twenty kilometers from what would later become the Baltic coast rocket center of their second child, Wernher.
The von Quistorps came from the same Junker landowning class as the von Brauns, but their roots in the nobility and the military were not nearly as deep. As burghers, without the noble von, they rose to prominence in the old Hanseatic city of Rostock as theologians, university professors, and merchants. In 1765 Dr. Bernhard Friedrich Quistorp came to Greifswald as a theology professor and Protestant pastor and became “general superintendent” of the last northern German territory ruled by Sweden. (It became Prussian in 1815.) His son, Johann Gottfried, earned a doctorate too, and as an entrée into the landed class, he bought an estate twenty-five kilometers away on the flat, open coastal plain near the estuary of the Peene River. In 1782 he became the first von Quistorp when the Hapsburg emperor ennobled him in Vienna. A grandson bought the nearby estate of Crenzow and Zarrenthin in 1819–20, giving up the first, and the next heir, named August (grandfather of Emmy), acquired the estate of Bauer and Wehrland, five kilometers away, in 1867 because favorable grain prices had allowed the family fortunes to flourish. With August von Quistorp’s death in 1877, the first son, Wernher (born 1856), inherited Crenzow, and the second, Ulrich, received Bauer and Wehrland, setting up two neighboring branches of the von Quistorps. Both estates would become important in Wernher von Braun’s life.
Wernher von Quistorp was more than successful in following the prescribed course of the Prussian nobility: he attended university, served in the cavalry, and married Marie von Below, possessor of a famous Prussian aristocratic name and sister to two well-known diplomats. As a West Pomeranian estate holder, Wernher von Quistorp took a leading role in the agricultural credit cooperatives that served as banks for landowners, and he was appointed to the Prussian House of Lords. Yet he clearly had inherited the Quistorps’ intellectual tradition. He pursued his education through to a law doctorate, but his true passion was ornithology, in which he became an important amateur scientist. According to his son-in-law Magnus von Braun, his collection of bird eggs “was one of the largest and most valuable in Germany. His correspondence with many ornithologists secured him superior knowledge in this area.”
He passed along his passion for natural history to his oldest child, Emmy Melitta Cécile, who was born on 3 November 1886 in Crenzow. After tutoring, she went to elite finishing schools in Berlin and London for two years. But a family tragedy forced her to return home: the premature death of her mother in Palermo, Sicily, in early 1903, presumably as a result of tuberculosis. The now sixteen-year-old Emmy became secretary for the estate and joined in her father’s ornithological research.
She knew every bird in the forest by its song or individual calls. She knew all the birds and also plants by their Latin names—and never forgot them. She was an expert in the area of mushrooms; thus the sciences of nature and the forest were for her always sources of a pure and great joy. Astronomy was an especially beloved subject.
So says her future husband. But her father also died too young, in 1908 at the age of fifty-two, and he was buried in Crenzow’s park alongside his wife; the two graves can still be found there today. The second child, Hans, inherited the estate. Emmy also had a younger sister, Irmengard, who married a Count Schlieffen, another famous Prussian name, and a younger brother, Alexander, who took a doctorate of laws and became a banker. When Emmy von Quistorp was put on the Berlin marriage market during the social season of 1909–10, she had a quick and happy result. Through all the successes, troubles, and trials that would ensue, her union with Magnus von Braun would prove to be strong and loving.