Joanna Rudge Long
Wabi Sabi's quest and the splendid pictures will please younger children (though probably not as young as the publisher’s recommended range of 3 to 6). The rest of us will be better prepared to appreciate the subtle interconnections among dialogue, poetry and collages fashioned from "time-worn human-made as well as natural materials." Even this medium is a metaphor for the gentle philosophy explored here. The art is rich in leaf greens and glowing reds; in the textures of hair, straw, crazed paint or rough paper. Young captures moments of transcendent beautya frog visible through moon-struck water (crumpled, iridescent paper)and his art incorporates traditional haiku references (a pale moon, symbol of autumn).
The New York Times
Children's Literature - Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz
Three texts go side by side in this stunningly designed and illustrated volume. In one tale Wabi Sabi, a cat living in Kyoto, learns that her name has a meaning that is "hard to explain." Wabi Sabi first asks her cat friend Snowball what it means. "It's a kind of beauty," she notes. Rascal the dog claims it is "too hard to explain to someone like you." A bird sends Wabi Sabi on a journey. The cat proceeds through the busy city to the woods. There she meets a monkey who tries to explain, telling her, "Listen. Watch. Feel." "Simple things are beautiful." Seeing herself in her bowl of tea, Wabi Sabi seems to begin to understand. On her way home, she stops by the Silver Palace, enjoying its simple beauty, composing three poems. At home she seems to comprehend the feeling and her name at last. Along with her story, appropriate haiku and haibun appear in English on the pages, as do others in Japanese characters, translated at the end. The collage illustrations, each distinctly unique on its double page, are bound to open vertically, perhaps relating to the way scroll paintings are hung, and what a variety of materials are employed! Some are purloined from nature; others, where a specific color or texture is called for to create the desired effect, are manufactured. Seeking out and discovering the inventive relationships between the images and the subtle texts is a delight. Note that the portrait of Wabi Sabi staring at us with wide eyes on the paper jacket is very different from the cover beneath, and do not pass by the end pages. There are notes on the history of the concept of wabi sabi and on haiku and haibun, in addition to the translation of those Japanese poems in the text. This bookis a tour de force, with meanings to be discovered on many levels. Reviewer: Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz
School Library Journal
This ambitious picture book tells the story of a cat living in Kyoto with her master. Curious to discover her name's meaning, Wabi Sabi travels across Japan, seeking advice and explanation from a variety of sources. In an introductory note, readers learn that the name comes from a concept centered on finding beauty through simplicity. As the feline discovers that she is ordinary yet wonderful, she comes to understand the meaning of her name. It is a complex idea, and the cat's journey is an effective way of presenting it to elementary school readers. The book reads from top to bottom, like a scroll, and contains a haiku and line of Japanese verse on each spread. Young's beautiful collages have an almost 3-D effect and perfectly complement the spiritual, lyrical text. While the story of Wabi Sabi's journey will hold some appeal for younger children, this is a book to be savored and contemplated and will be most appreciated by children old enough to grasp its subtle meaning. Translations are provided for the Japanese text as well as notes on haiku and the history of wabi sabi to place the whole lovely package in context.-Kara Schaff Dean, Walpole Public Library, MA
The Japanese concept of wabi sabi, or the art of finding "beauty and harmony in what is simple," is explored textually and visually in this story of a Japanese cat named Wabi Sabi who wonders what her name means when a visitor asks her mistress. "That's hard to explain," her mistress replies, initiating Wabi Sabi's quest to find a definition. Her feline pal Snowball tells Wabi Sabi her name refers to "a kind of beauty," while Rascal the dog hints it has something to do with the ordinary and simple. A confused Wabi Sabi journeys to the woods of Mount Hiei where the wise old monkey Kosho ceremoniously makes tea in an old wooden bowl to illustrate wabi sabi. Surrounded by nature, Wabi Sabi eventually understands that "simple things are beautiful" and returns home enlightened. Reibstein's plain yet poetic text, which deftly incorporates original and traditional Japanese haiku, works harmoniously with Young's deceptively simple, vertically oriented collages of natural and manmade materials to create their own wabi sabi. Simply beautiful. (notes, translations of Japanese haiku) (Picture book. 6-10)