A Good Book for Middle Schoolers
In 1967, during the Vietnam war, Holling Hoodhood lives in Long Island, New York. Holling is the only Presbyterian in his grade in school. On Wednesdays, when the rest of his classmates go to either Hebrew school at Temple Beth-El or to Catechism at Saint Albert's, he has to stay at school with his seventh grade teacher, Mrs. Baker. When Mrs. Baker finds out, Holling is sure that she hates him. At first, he keeps getting more and more proof of his theory, for example, for the first few weeks she makes him wash the chalkboard and clap the erasers every week. Then Wednesdays start getting a little better. Even though Mrs. Baker assigns him Shakespeare plays to read, which aren't as bad as he had previously thought, Holling starts to like Mrs. Baker. Holling and Mrs. Baker begin to do things other than learn and read Shakespeare. Mrs. Baker teaches Holling how to run better and even takes him to a Yankee's game! Holling Hoodhood ends up having a good year after all.
One thing that I thought was cool about this book was that it had a lot of Shakespeare in it. Another characteristic that I liked was that every chapter had a new problem and solution in it, which kept the book interesting. I also liked how the author included a Vietnam refugee as one of the characters because it was relevant to the time period. There were also some negative aspects of the novel. One of these is the fact that you have to wait to find the setting. You don't find out they are on Long Island until a ways into the book. Another negative is that the author didn't give some characters full descriptions, for example Mr. Kowalski, Holling's friend's father. A final negative aspect is that the author didn't directly describe the importance of the time period, that the Vietnam war was going on.
In this book, the author uses first person point of view. In my opinion, this is easier to read than third person because the third person skips from character to character and first person stays with the main character. Also, the author's writing style is casual seeing that the book is narrated by a seventh grader. An example of this is when he said, "It's all in the delivery anyway. So I practiced in my bedroom, thinking of my sister." The author also uses somewhat simple words because, again, it is narrated by a seventh grader. An example of this is when he said, "stuff like that".
I would definitely recommend this book to all other middle schoolers. One reason is that the main character is in seventh grade, also. Another reason is that there are probably a lot of middle schoolers who feel that their teachers hate their guts. A third and final reason to recommend this book is the fact that the book is easy to read because the author didn't use many very long or hard words in it. Some similar novels are "Game" by Walter Dean Myers, "Baseball Great" by Tim Green, and "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone" by J.K. Rowling. These books all include students who are having trouble with adults or teachers that they think are mean.
5 out of 6 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.