George MacDonald's Weighed and Wanting (also known in some editions as Thomas Wingfold, Curate) is a rich and philosophically intricate novel that grapples with questions of faith, moral integrity, spiritual rebirth, and the tension between outward religiosity and inward truth. First published in 1882, the novel exemplifies MacDonald's characteristic fusion of narrative with theological and metaphysical exploration, marking it as both a literary artifact of Victorian religious concern and a spiritual treatise cloaked in the form of fiction.
At the heart of Weighed and Wanting lies the journey of the eponymous curate Thomas Wingfold, a man whose spiritual complacency and conventional religiosity are shattered when a skeptical blacksmith named Polwarth confronts him with the intellectual and moral demands of genuine belief. The novel opens with Wingfold functioning as a mechanical clergyman—dutiful in his performance, yet hollow in conviction. It is through this initial condition that MacDonald exposes the spiritual malaise of Victorian institutional religion, emphasizing how easily faith becomes a performative and socially reinforced structure, rather than a lived and interrogated reality.
The theological catalyst of the narrative is Wingfold's existential crisis upon realizing that he does not truly believe what he preaches. His ensuing turmoil is not mere doubt, but a call to radical honesty. In classic MacDonald fashion, spiritual progress is inextricably tied to moral authenticity. MacDonald does not advocate for simple doctrinal assent or emotional conversion; rather, he insists on the integration of the intellect, conscience, and will in the search for truth. Wingfold's inner transformation is painstaking and often painful, a journey that mirrors the Socratic dictum that "the unexamined life is not worth living."
Supporting characters serve as foils and exemplars in this pilgrimage toward authenticity. The diminutive and physically deformed but spiritually profound Polwarth is one of MacDonald's most memorable creations—a figure of immense moral insight and humility, whose very presence challenges the ableist and classist assumptions of Victorian society. Polwarth functions as a kind of spiritual guide, a lay mystic whose personal suffering has not embittered him but rather deepened his spiritual understanding. His dialogues with Wingfold constitute some of the most theologically dense and moving passages in the novel, offering a theology not of easy answers but of lived, sacrificial love.
Another key figure is Helen Lingard, a woman whose own secret sin and the fear of moral exposure provide a parallel narrative of spiritual awakening. Her relationship with Leopold, who harbors a devastating secret and suffers under a tremendous burden of guilt, adds a dramatic and almost Gothic dimension to the plot. In these subplots, MacDonald explores the themes of confession, forgiveness, and redemption—not as instantaneous events, but as gradual processes marked by fear, resistance, and grace.
Indeed, the title Weighed and Wanting—a reference to the biblical account of Belshazzar's feast in the Book of Daniel, where divine judgment is pronounced upon a life found deficient—resonates throughout the text. Every principal character faces a moment of spiritual weighing: a reckoning in which they must confront the disparity between their public selves and their inward lives. In this, MacDonald reveals his conviction that true religion is not a matter of outward conformity, but of inward truthfulness—a position deeply resonant with the teachings of Jesus, especially in his denunciations of Pharisaical hypocrisy.
Stylistically, MacDonald's prose oscillates between didactic exposition and lyrical evocation. His narrative voice is imbued with a sense of pastoral care—firm yet compassionate, philosophical yet intimate. Unlike many Victorian novelists who rely heavily on social realism, MacDonald is not afraid to allow his characters to speak in theological abstraction or philosophical digression, sometimes at the expense of narrative momentum. For modern readers, this can be a challenge; yet for those attuned to the rhythms of 19th-century religious literature, such moments are profoundly rewarding.
The novel also serves as a critique of Enlightenment rationalism and scientific positivism, which MacDonald does not reject outright but seeks to integrate within a broader framework of spiritual understanding. Through Wingfold's intellectual struggles, MacDonald articulates a form of faith that welcomes questions and wrestles with doubt, rather than repressing or fearing them. This stands in contrast to both the dogmatism of the religious establishment and the cynicism of atheistic skepticism. Weighed and Wanting is a vision of Christianity that is deeply incarnational and ethically demanding. Faith, in MacDonald's rendering, is not merely belief in doctrines, but a surrender to the reality of divine love.
1100591354
At the heart of Weighed and Wanting lies the journey of the eponymous curate Thomas Wingfold, a man whose spiritual complacency and conventional religiosity are shattered when a skeptical blacksmith named Polwarth confronts him with the intellectual and moral demands of genuine belief. The novel opens with Wingfold functioning as a mechanical clergyman—dutiful in his performance, yet hollow in conviction. It is through this initial condition that MacDonald exposes the spiritual malaise of Victorian institutional religion, emphasizing how easily faith becomes a performative and socially reinforced structure, rather than a lived and interrogated reality.
The theological catalyst of the narrative is Wingfold's existential crisis upon realizing that he does not truly believe what he preaches. His ensuing turmoil is not mere doubt, but a call to radical honesty. In classic MacDonald fashion, spiritual progress is inextricably tied to moral authenticity. MacDonald does not advocate for simple doctrinal assent or emotional conversion; rather, he insists on the integration of the intellect, conscience, and will in the search for truth. Wingfold's inner transformation is painstaking and often painful, a journey that mirrors the Socratic dictum that "the unexamined life is not worth living."
Supporting characters serve as foils and exemplars in this pilgrimage toward authenticity. The diminutive and physically deformed but spiritually profound Polwarth is one of MacDonald's most memorable creations—a figure of immense moral insight and humility, whose very presence challenges the ableist and classist assumptions of Victorian society. Polwarth functions as a kind of spiritual guide, a lay mystic whose personal suffering has not embittered him but rather deepened his spiritual understanding. His dialogues with Wingfold constitute some of the most theologically dense and moving passages in the novel, offering a theology not of easy answers but of lived, sacrificial love.
Another key figure is Helen Lingard, a woman whose own secret sin and the fear of moral exposure provide a parallel narrative of spiritual awakening. Her relationship with Leopold, who harbors a devastating secret and suffers under a tremendous burden of guilt, adds a dramatic and almost Gothic dimension to the plot. In these subplots, MacDonald explores the themes of confession, forgiveness, and redemption—not as instantaneous events, but as gradual processes marked by fear, resistance, and grace.
Indeed, the title Weighed and Wanting—a reference to the biblical account of Belshazzar's feast in the Book of Daniel, where divine judgment is pronounced upon a life found deficient—resonates throughout the text. Every principal character faces a moment of spiritual weighing: a reckoning in which they must confront the disparity between their public selves and their inward lives. In this, MacDonald reveals his conviction that true religion is not a matter of outward conformity, but of inward truthfulness—a position deeply resonant with the teachings of Jesus, especially in his denunciations of Pharisaical hypocrisy.
Stylistically, MacDonald's prose oscillates between didactic exposition and lyrical evocation. His narrative voice is imbued with a sense of pastoral care—firm yet compassionate, philosophical yet intimate. Unlike many Victorian novelists who rely heavily on social realism, MacDonald is not afraid to allow his characters to speak in theological abstraction or philosophical digression, sometimes at the expense of narrative momentum. For modern readers, this can be a challenge; yet for those attuned to the rhythms of 19th-century religious literature, such moments are profoundly rewarding.
The novel also serves as a critique of Enlightenment rationalism and scientific positivism, which MacDonald does not reject outright but seeks to integrate within a broader framework of spiritual understanding. Through Wingfold's intellectual struggles, MacDonald articulates a form of faith that welcomes questions and wrestles with doubt, rather than repressing or fearing them. This stands in contrast to both the dogmatism of the religious establishment and the cynicism of atheistic skepticism. Weighed and Wanting is a vision of Christianity that is deeply incarnational and ethically demanding. Faith, in MacDonald's rendering, is not merely belief in doctrines, but a surrender to the reality of divine love.
Weighed and Wanting
George MacDonald's Weighed and Wanting (also known in some editions as Thomas Wingfold, Curate) is a rich and philosophically intricate novel that grapples with questions of faith, moral integrity, spiritual rebirth, and the tension between outward religiosity and inward truth. First published in 1882, the novel exemplifies MacDonald's characteristic fusion of narrative with theological and metaphysical exploration, marking it as both a literary artifact of Victorian religious concern and a spiritual treatise cloaked in the form of fiction.
At the heart of Weighed and Wanting lies the journey of the eponymous curate Thomas Wingfold, a man whose spiritual complacency and conventional religiosity are shattered when a skeptical blacksmith named Polwarth confronts him with the intellectual and moral demands of genuine belief. The novel opens with Wingfold functioning as a mechanical clergyman—dutiful in his performance, yet hollow in conviction. It is through this initial condition that MacDonald exposes the spiritual malaise of Victorian institutional religion, emphasizing how easily faith becomes a performative and socially reinforced structure, rather than a lived and interrogated reality.
The theological catalyst of the narrative is Wingfold's existential crisis upon realizing that he does not truly believe what he preaches. His ensuing turmoil is not mere doubt, but a call to radical honesty. In classic MacDonald fashion, spiritual progress is inextricably tied to moral authenticity. MacDonald does not advocate for simple doctrinal assent or emotional conversion; rather, he insists on the integration of the intellect, conscience, and will in the search for truth. Wingfold's inner transformation is painstaking and often painful, a journey that mirrors the Socratic dictum that "the unexamined life is not worth living."
Supporting characters serve as foils and exemplars in this pilgrimage toward authenticity. The diminutive and physically deformed but spiritually profound Polwarth is one of MacDonald's most memorable creations—a figure of immense moral insight and humility, whose very presence challenges the ableist and classist assumptions of Victorian society. Polwarth functions as a kind of spiritual guide, a lay mystic whose personal suffering has not embittered him but rather deepened his spiritual understanding. His dialogues with Wingfold constitute some of the most theologically dense and moving passages in the novel, offering a theology not of easy answers but of lived, sacrificial love.
Another key figure is Helen Lingard, a woman whose own secret sin and the fear of moral exposure provide a parallel narrative of spiritual awakening. Her relationship with Leopold, who harbors a devastating secret and suffers under a tremendous burden of guilt, adds a dramatic and almost Gothic dimension to the plot. In these subplots, MacDonald explores the themes of confession, forgiveness, and redemption—not as instantaneous events, but as gradual processes marked by fear, resistance, and grace.
Indeed, the title Weighed and Wanting—a reference to the biblical account of Belshazzar's feast in the Book of Daniel, where divine judgment is pronounced upon a life found deficient—resonates throughout the text. Every principal character faces a moment of spiritual weighing: a reckoning in which they must confront the disparity between their public selves and their inward lives. In this, MacDonald reveals his conviction that true religion is not a matter of outward conformity, but of inward truthfulness—a position deeply resonant with the teachings of Jesus, especially in his denunciations of Pharisaical hypocrisy.
Stylistically, MacDonald's prose oscillates between didactic exposition and lyrical evocation. His narrative voice is imbued with a sense of pastoral care—firm yet compassionate, philosophical yet intimate. Unlike many Victorian novelists who rely heavily on social realism, MacDonald is not afraid to allow his characters to speak in theological abstraction or philosophical digression, sometimes at the expense of narrative momentum. For modern readers, this can be a challenge; yet for those attuned to the rhythms of 19th-century religious literature, such moments are profoundly rewarding.
The novel also serves as a critique of Enlightenment rationalism and scientific positivism, which MacDonald does not reject outright but seeks to integrate within a broader framework of spiritual understanding. Through Wingfold's intellectual struggles, MacDonald articulates a form of faith that welcomes questions and wrestles with doubt, rather than repressing or fearing them. This stands in contrast to both the dogmatism of the religious establishment and the cynicism of atheistic skepticism. Weighed and Wanting is a vision of Christianity that is deeply incarnational and ethically demanding. Faith, in MacDonald's rendering, is not merely belief in doctrines, but a surrender to the reality of divine love.
At the heart of Weighed and Wanting lies the journey of the eponymous curate Thomas Wingfold, a man whose spiritual complacency and conventional religiosity are shattered when a skeptical blacksmith named Polwarth confronts him with the intellectual and moral demands of genuine belief. The novel opens with Wingfold functioning as a mechanical clergyman—dutiful in his performance, yet hollow in conviction. It is through this initial condition that MacDonald exposes the spiritual malaise of Victorian institutional religion, emphasizing how easily faith becomes a performative and socially reinforced structure, rather than a lived and interrogated reality.
The theological catalyst of the narrative is Wingfold's existential crisis upon realizing that he does not truly believe what he preaches. His ensuing turmoil is not mere doubt, but a call to radical honesty. In classic MacDonald fashion, spiritual progress is inextricably tied to moral authenticity. MacDonald does not advocate for simple doctrinal assent or emotional conversion; rather, he insists on the integration of the intellect, conscience, and will in the search for truth. Wingfold's inner transformation is painstaking and often painful, a journey that mirrors the Socratic dictum that "the unexamined life is not worth living."
Supporting characters serve as foils and exemplars in this pilgrimage toward authenticity. The diminutive and physically deformed but spiritually profound Polwarth is one of MacDonald's most memorable creations—a figure of immense moral insight and humility, whose very presence challenges the ableist and classist assumptions of Victorian society. Polwarth functions as a kind of spiritual guide, a lay mystic whose personal suffering has not embittered him but rather deepened his spiritual understanding. His dialogues with Wingfold constitute some of the most theologically dense and moving passages in the novel, offering a theology not of easy answers but of lived, sacrificial love.
Another key figure is Helen Lingard, a woman whose own secret sin and the fear of moral exposure provide a parallel narrative of spiritual awakening. Her relationship with Leopold, who harbors a devastating secret and suffers under a tremendous burden of guilt, adds a dramatic and almost Gothic dimension to the plot. In these subplots, MacDonald explores the themes of confession, forgiveness, and redemption—not as instantaneous events, but as gradual processes marked by fear, resistance, and grace.
Indeed, the title Weighed and Wanting—a reference to the biblical account of Belshazzar's feast in the Book of Daniel, where divine judgment is pronounced upon a life found deficient—resonates throughout the text. Every principal character faces a moment of spiritual weighing: a reckoning in which they must confront the disparity between their public selves and their inward lives. In this, MacDonald reveals his conviction that true religion is not a matter of outward conformity, but of inward truthfulness—a position deeply resonant with the teachings of Jesus, especially in his denunciations of Pharisaical hypocrisy.
Stylistically, MacDonald's prose oscillates between didactic exposition and lyrical evocation. His narrative voice is imbued with a sense of pastoral care—firm yet compassionate, philosophical yet intimate. Unlike many Victorian novelists who rely heavily on social realism, MacDonald is not afraid to allow his characters to speak in theological abstraction or philosophical digression, sometimes at the expense of narrative momentum. For modern readers, this can be a challenge; yet for those attuned to the rhythms of 19th-century religious literature, such moments are profoundly rewarding.
The novel also serves as a critique of Enlightenment rationalism and scientific positivism, which MacDonald does not reject outright but seeks to integrate within a broader framework of spiritual understanding. Through Wingfold's intellectual struggles, MacDonald articulates a form of faith that welcomes questions and wrestles with doubt, rather than repressing or fearing them. This stands in contrast to both the dogmatism of the religious establishment and the cynicism of atheistic skepticism. Weighed and Wanting is a vision of Christianity that is deeply incarnational and ethically demanding. Faith, in MacDonald's rendering, is not merely belief in doctrines, but a surrender to the reality of divine love.
4.99
In Stock
5
1
Weighed and Wanting
Weighed and Wanting
Related collections and offers
4.99
In Stock
Product Details
| BN ID: | 2940184733562 |
|---|---|
| Publisher: | George MacDonald |
| Publication date: | 05/06/2025 |
| Sold by: | Barnes & Noble |
| Format: | eBook |
| File size: | 746 KB |
About the Author
From the B&N Reads Blog