Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date.

For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now.

Wellspring of Chaos (Recluce Series #12)

Wellspring of Chaos (Recluce Series #12)

4.8 13
by L. E. Modesitt Jr.

See All Formats & Editions

"An intriguing fantasy in a fascinating world." —Robert Jordan, New York Times bestselling author of The Wheel of Time® series

Kharl is the best cooper in Brysta, one of the major cities in Nordla, and his life has been as ordered and dependable as his barrels. His trouble begins when he saves a neighbor's daughter from


"An intriguing fantasy in a fascinating world." —Robert Jordan, New York Times bestselling author of The Wheel of Time® series

Kharl is the best cooper in Brysta, one of the major cities in Nordla, and his life has been as ordered and dependable as his barrels. His trouble begins when he saves a neighbor's daughter from the violent advances of two upper-class men. Then he rescues an actual rape victim he finds unconscious in an alley, a blackstaffer a young expatriate mage from Recluce, and that makes his wife very uneasy. The culprit in both cases turns out to have been Egen, the cruel and corrupt son of the local ruler. When the blackstaffer is mysteriously murdered in Kharl's cooperage, Kharl is jailed, tried, and flogged, and in a shocking turnaround released and his consort executed for the murder, which she did not commit. Egen again. Kharl ends up on the run, with just a handful of coins and a few clothes, but he also takes the slain woman's black staff and her book,The Basis of Order, which explains the principles of its power. The diligent cooper is about to learn a new, very different skill.

L.E. Modesitt, Jr.'s bestselling fantasy novels set in the magical world of Recluce are among the most popular in contemporary fantasy. Each novel tells an independent story that nevertheless reverberates though all the other books in the series, to deepen and enhance the reading experience. Rich in detail, the Saga of Recluce is a feast of wondrous marvels.

Saga of Recluce

#1 The Magic of Recluce / #2 The Towers of Sunset / #3 The Magic Engineer / #4 The Order War / #5 The Death of Chaos / #6 Fall of Angels / #7 The Chaos Balance / #8 The White Order / #9 Colors of Chaos / #10 Magi’i of Cyador / #11 Scion of Cyador / #12 Wellspring of Chaos / #13 Ordermaster / #14 Natural Order Mage / #15 Mage-Guard of Hamor / #16 Arms-Commander / #17 Cyador’s Heirs / #18 Heritage of Cyador /#19 The Mongrel Mage (forthcoming)

Story Collection: Recluce Tales

Other Series by L.E. Modesitt, Jr.
The Imager Portfolio
The Corean Chronicles
The Spellsong Cycle
The Ghost Books
The Ecolitan Matter

Editorial Reviews

From the Publisher

“Strong supporting characters, vivid settings and creative approach to mythos and magic enhance this richly detailed story. New readers should feel comfortable in Modesitt's world, where chaos and order reign in delicate balance, while series fans will welcome this return to familiar ground. As usual, Modesitt handles his world-building and characterization with ease. While knowledge of the previous books in the series will enhance the reading experience, it's not a requirement to enjoying this stand-alone tale. This newest entry in the Saga of Recluce is a gift for fans and new readers alike.” —Romantic Times Bookclub on Wellspring of Chaos (a "Top Pick")

“The prolific Modesitt's 12th Recluce fantasy, his first since 2001's Scion of Cyador, delights from start to finish. . . . .In a genre saturated with callow youngsters who grow into heroes, Modesitt effortlessly builds an epic adventure around an ordinary, middle-aged man. This marks a welcome new chapter in the Recluce saga, with the ending all but promising a sequel.” —Publishers Weekly on Wellspring of Chaos

“Modesitt's excellent new story has thought-provoking underpinnings that will snare newcomers as well as old Recluce hands.” —Booklist on Wellspring of Chaos

Publishers Weekly
The prolific Modesitt's 12th Recluce fantasy, his first since 2001's Scion of Cyador, delights from start to finish. In the city of Brysta on the island of Nordla, Kharl, a cooper, has a prosperous business and a loving, if not perfect, family. He's also a man who can't help doing right, no matter the cost to himself. He soon pays a heavy price for twice offending the local lord's dastardly son by his good deeds: first, he rescues a neighbor's daughter from two upper-class louts trying to rape her; second, he saves the life of Jenevra, a Recluce blackstaffer (or mage), after she's attacked and left in the street to die. When someone later cuts Jenevra's throat, Kharl is arrested for the crime, but at the trial he can only watch as the local lord arranges to have the cooper's wife hanged for a murder neither of them committed. Hounded from the only home he's known, Kharl ends up on the run with only a few coins to his name-and Jenevra's staff and book. Kharl's slow transformation from family man to lonely wanderer, from solid citizen to wanted outlaw, from simple right-thinking craftsman to fledgling order-master and wizard, makes for a relentless and absorbing story. In a genre saturated with callow youngsters who grow into heroes, Modesitt effortlessly builds an epic adventure around an ordinary, middle-aged man. This marks a welcome new chapter in the Recluce saga, with the ending all but promising a sequel. (Apr. 26) FYI: Modesitt's last novel was The Ethos Effect (Forecasts, Oct. 6). Copyright 2004 Reed Business Information.
Modesitt slightly alters his approach in this newest installment in the story of Recluce. Instead of a youngster coming to understand his world as a by-product of maturity, protagonist Kharl is a middle-aged barrel-maker, a family man who supports his wife and children by working in his cooperage. He is a fair man who tries to do his best on each barrel, and he seeks to deal honorably with all. But Kharl's sense of justice puts him at odds with his ruler's jaded younger son, and soon Kharl is accused of arson and flogged, his wife is hanged for murder, his business is confiscated, and his sons run away. Kharl must try to rebuild his life and his shattered mind, first by finding a job as a ship's carpenter and second by trying to comprehend how such injustice can occur without scandalizing society. Modesitt approaches his traditional underlying look at the uses and misuses of power through Kharl's examination of his world's functioning. Kharl's resolve to oppose injustice—and how he goes about it—will capture the reader's interest and hold it throughout. Kharl's journey around Recluce while he recreates his lost life becomes a "Pilgrim's Progress" as he withstands temptations to settle down to a quiet life that might not endure in order to put down the chaos (generated by the misuse of power) disrupting the lands he visits. Kharl's struggle to combat injustice obviously is just beginning. This volume is an essential purchase for those high school libraries where the series is popular and is a recommended purchase for those where Modesitt is not yet known. VOYA Codes 5Q 4P S A/YA (Hard to imagine it being any better written; Broad general YA appeal; Senior High, defined as grades10 to 12; Adult-marketed book recommended for Young Adults). 2004, Tor, 448p., Ages 15 to Adult.
—Marsha Valance
This will hook new readers even if they don't have prior knowledge of the series. Middle-aged Kharl, the best cooper (barrel maker) in Brysta, stops two men from molesting his neighbor's daughter, not knowing that one is the son of a local official. Thus begin his trials and tribulations. He is charged with murder; found not guilty but whipped and taxed out of his shop, and ends up on the streets of Brysta trying to evade the local officials. His consort is found guilty of the murder and hanged; his sons abandon him; his neighbor is assassinated. Kharl eventually signs on as a ship's carpenter, and when he tries to return a black staff left by a woman from Recluse he is told it belongs to him now. He reads The Basis of Order (also left behind) and begins to develop his own latent powers of order to combat the chaos around him. Not only an engrossing story, this is also a morality tale about the roles order and chaos play in life and the importance of all the choices we make. YAs used to dewy-faced young protagonists may be surprised at the draw of middle-aged Kharl. Solid characters, great action, and deep thought all in one. (Book 12 in the Saga of Recluse Series). KLIATT Codes: JSA—Recommended for junior and senior high school students, advanced students, and adults. 2004, Tor, 448p. map., Ages 12 to adult.
—Sherry Hoy

Product Details

Tom Doherty Associates
Publication date:
Recluce Series , #12
Edition description:
First Edition
Product dimensions:
4.16(w) x 6.72(h) x 1.27(d)
Age Range:
14 - 18 Years

Related Subjects

Read an Excerpt


Kharl stood at the front window of his shop, looking westward for a moment at the wedge of twilight sky visible between the slate roofs of the buildings on the far side of the narrow Crafters' Lane. A single lamp was visible through the middle window of Gharan's quarters, above the weaver's shop. Next door, at Hamyl's, both the lower floor and the rooms above were dark. That wasn't surprising, Kharl told himself, since Hamyl's consort had taken the children to her parents' holding to help with the early-midsummer gathering. That had left the potter free to indulge himself at the Tankard, and the lane peaceful, since Kharl's neighbor, the scrivener Tyrbel, was a widower and kept a quiet establishment.

Lowering his eyes, the cooper glanced at the five barrels in his display, all tight cooperage from the best white oak, ranging from the hogshead to the standard barrel and down to the quarter barrel and the fine-finished fifth barrel with the brass spigot, used by anyone who wanted to store and dispense expensive liquids, mostly spirits. Then he barred the front door and closed the shutters behind the lead-glassed panes that his grandsire had installed before Kharl had been born. At that time, glass windows had been considered particularly foolish for a cooper, unlike a goldsmith or an artisan—or even a weaver or a potter—who had to display work to attract buyers. Times had changed, and most shops along the lane had come to display their wares behind windows.

"A barrel's a barrel. So's a hogshead. People buy barrels because they need barrels." Kharl smiled as he recalled the acerbic words of his grandmother, who had never let his grandsire forget what she regarded as the foolishness of the glass.

Foolishness? Kharl didn't think so. He still got orders from passersby who otherwise hadn't thought about barrels. Not many, never more than one an eightday, and sometimes only a few a season. Over time, though, the windows had paid for themselves.

He picked up the lamp and walked toward the rear of the shop, past the high racks that held the billets he would form into staves. Most of the billets were oak, white for the tight cooperage and red for slack. There were also some billets of tight-grained black oak, and a few of chestnut. He passed the workbench and the tool rack, with every tool in place. On the left side of the rear wall was the small forge where he sized and shaped the hoops for tight cooperage. Beside the forge on the brick flooring was the fire pot and, beside it, the steaming ring. The faintest smell of ashes and charcoal drifted toward Kharl from the banked coals of the forge.

Just short of the rear wall, and the door to the loading dock, the cooper stopped and looked at the fifteen white oak barrels waiting there. Each was identical to the next, with the iron bands, set just so, and the smooth finish, with a medium toasting on the inside. Korlan was supposed to pick them up in the morning—pick them up and pay the balance due. The vintner had taken the first fifteen barrels an eightday earlier. Kharl only hoped that the vintner did not come up with some excuse, as he had the summer before, waiting almost two eightdays before showing up, but, then, that was the problem in dealing with someone who lived more than ten kays to the south of Brysta.

Kharl half smiled, then nodded, and turned, the carry-lamp in hand, to head up the stairs.

"…silvers and coppers are not for me,

but a pretty girl whose charms are free…"

He frowned. Had he heard singing in the alley? The Tankard was four doors toward the harbor, but seldom did roisterers come wandering down the alley, even early in the evening. Kharl cocked his head.

"…for when there's no lamps to see,

any woman's as fair as fair can be…"

"No…let go of me!"

The woman's voice—no, it was a girl's voice—was familiar, but Kharl could not place it. He moved to the far side of the loading dock and swept up the cudgel in his left hand, then, leaving the lamp behind, eased the door open.

"Let me go!"

"…mean you no harm, little woman." A raucous laugh followed. "We'll even pay you for what you give others for free…"

"Let go! Let…mmmpphhh…" The girl's words were choked off.

Kharl closed the door behind him so that he would not be silhouetted by the light from the lamp. He glanced toward the Tankard, but saw no one. He looked back to the north. There, less than a rod away, perhaps less than ten cubits, in the fading light and the dimness of the alley, were three figures that Kharl could barely make out. Two men held the girl, a thin figure with dark ringlets over a green summer blouse. The hair and the blouse belonged to Sanyle, the youngest of Tyrbel's daughters.

One of the men had Sanyle's arms cruelly twisted behind her, and the other had his hand on her shoulder, pulling the summer blouse down. Both men were laughing.

Kharl took three quick steps, then two more, bringing the cudgel up.

The nearer man, the one who had started to rip away Sanyle's blouse, turned. A blade hissed from the scabbard at his belt.

Kharl took another step and struck the blade and the man's hand with the cudgel before the man had finished turning toward the cooper. The shortsword dropped on the cobblestones of the alley with a muffled clank.

"Ah…swine-slime…misbegotten…" The youth jumped back, cradling his hand. The dark blue velvet of his tunic was almost lost in the dimness.

The second man let go of Sanyle, and his right hand darted toward the hilt of his blade.

"Don't…" growled the cooper. "'Less you want a broken arm. Just let her go, and back away and head back where you came from. Have fun with your own or those you pay."

As soon as the man had released her, Sanyle slipped away into the shadows. There was a glint on the heavy brass key she held, and then the rear door of the structure beside the cooperage opened, and quickly shut.

"You can't do this." The taller young man, who was still half a head shorter than the cooper, kept his hand on the hilt of his blade, but did not draw it. "You don't know who you're talking to…"

"Doesn't matter," growled the cooper. "Don't force girls barely old enough to know the difference 'tween boys and men."

"They're all the same."

Kharl raised the cudgel slightly. "Back off, little man, 'less you never want to use that arm again."

The shorter youth scooped up the fallen blade with his left hand and backed away. After a moment, the taller one followed.

Kharl stood watching until the two were out of sight, and until the alley was quiet once more. Then he turned and reentered the cooperage, wondering from what merchants' houses had come the overdressed and spoiled youths. With a snort, he set down the heavy cudgel and barred the door.

After reclaiming the lamp, he started up the steps to the quarters above the cooperage. His boots thumped heavily on the wood, and the fourth step creaked, as it had for years.

Charee stood just inside the door at the top of the stairs. Shoulder-length black hair was bound back from her face, making it seem even narrower than it was. Her green eyes were cool. "Your supper's cold. Thought you were coming up sooner."

"I was. Heard something out back. Wanted to make sure that it wasn't someone trying to break in. Just a pair of youngsters thought they were men, drinking too much for ones so young." Kharl had no intention of saying more about the would-be bravos. For all her virtues, Charee lacked one—that of circumspection. The young men could scarcely have picked out one crafter in gray from another, not unless Charee told the entire lane. Because she well might have, while suggesting that Kharl was being foolish, Kharl saw little point in calling attention to the incident. Sanyle would doubtless tell her widower father, but the scrivener was more than taciturn, as were his children.

"Won't you ever leave well enough alone, Kharl? Leave the roisterers alone. Or if you must, call them to the attention of Lord West's Watch. That's what he draws his tariffs for. You've got a consort and sons that need you…"

"My hard-won coins, leastwise." Kharl shut the door to the stairs and the shop below and walked toward the washroom on the right side of the landing.

"Let's not be starting that again."

Kharl forced a smile. "I won't, dearest. I need to wash up." The pitcher on the wash table was full, and the basin empty and clean, with a worn but clean gray towel and a narrow bar of fat soap laid out on the left side. He closed the washroom door and began to wash, enjoying the faint rose scent that came from the petals in the soap. It took time to get the sawdust off his face and hands and arms, and out of his dark beard, short-cropped as it was.

When Kharl stepped into the main room, it was still warm from the day, but the harbor breeze blowing through the open windows offered a welcoming coolness, even if it did bear the scents of salt and fish and caused the two wall lamps to flicker.

The cooper walked toward the round table where Arthal and Warrl waited, their eyes following him, but not exactly looking at him.

"Did you finish your lessons?" Kharl's eyes fixed on Warrl, his younger son, by three years.

"Yes, ser. I did." After a moment, the younger boy asked, "How much longer will I have to go to Master Fonwyl?"

"Until he says you can read and write well enough to pass the craft-master's tests." Kharl seated himself.

"I don't see why," interrupted Arthal. "It's not as though we'll ever have the golds to post the bond for mastercrafter."

"Maybe so, and maybe not," replied Kharl. "But if you get the chance, I don't want you looking back and complaining that I didn't prepare you. Reading and writing aren't something you can pick up easy-like when you're older."

"But what use is it if you're not a mastercrafter or a merchant or a lord? You scarce have a chance to read a broadsheet—"

"But I can, and once or twice it's saved me good coins. Enough." Kharl managed not to snap. "Let's enjoy supper."

As if she had been waiting for them to stop, Charee lifted the heavy cast-iron stewpot off the stove and carried it to the table. There, she set it on the well-browned trivet in the center of the oval oak table that had been one of the first pieces of actual furniture that Kharl had made after he had taken over the cooperage.

His consort set the large basket of afternoon-baked bread on the table and seated herself at the opposite end of the oval table from Kharl. Kharl began to ladle the stew into the chipped brown crockery bowls that had come from Charee's mother.

"Smells good," offered Kharl.

"It does," added Warrl.

"More summer squash and potatoes than meat," murmured Arthal.

"It's tasty, and it's hot, and you didn't have to spend the day cooking it," Kharl pointed out. "If you'd rather not eat, you can leave the table right now."

"No, Da…I'm sorry, Ma." Arthal's voice was barely apologetic.

Kharl didn't feel like calling his older son on his borderline rudeness, not after a long day finishing the last of the barrels for Korlan, especially when he knew that Arthal would just make some other comment.

"What was going on outside, Da?" asked Warrl.

"Just some young fellows who'd had too much at the Tankard. Had more ale than sense, and didn't know it."

"Will the Watch catch them?"

"They settled down," Kharl said, after taking a mouthful of the stew, still warm and peppery, despite Charee's comments about it getting cold. "Good stew." He broke off a chunk of the crusty bread, then dipped it into the stew before chewing off the dipped end. "Good bread."

"They'd better settle down," offered Arthal. "Lord West likes Brysta peaceful."

"The justicers worry more about thieves and killers," Kharl said, taking a swallow of the warm ale, really only about half a mug for each of them, but that had been all that was left in the quarter barrel in the cellar, and he couldn't afford any more—not until Korlan paid him for the wine barrels.

"Cossal said they hung three brigands in the Justicers' Hall on twoday," added Warrl. "He was there."

"They hung three men. That's true. They might even have been guilty." Kharl had his doubts that everyone hanged was as guilty as charged.

"Does it matter, if one brigand is strung up for something he didn't do?" asked Charee. "Anyone they catch has done more than enough anyway. Weren't for Lord West, we'd have thieves overrunning Brysta, like in his sire's time."

"That was a different time," Kharl said. "Fairven had fallen. The more powerful steam engines had exploded. Many trading ventures had failed. People were starving, and white wizards were everywhere."

"Better the whites than those blackstaffers from Recluce," Charee sniffed. "Them and their fine clothes, and their noses in the air. Think they know everything. Father Jorum says that we're all equal in the eyes of the Sovereign."

Kharl wasn't about to get into debating the opinions of the priest of the one-god believers. "I can't see as they harm anyone, but it's better that they stay in Recluce." He took another chunk of bread and wiped out his empty bowl with it. "Good dinner, dearest."

"How would we know? The lords won't touch 'em, not unless they're caught doing something right awful. Merayni, she listened to one of 'em, last winter's end it was, and he was telling terrible tales. Terrible tales."

"What kind of tales?" asked Kharl, in spite of himself. He had his doubts about Charee's older sister Merayni, although Merayni was certainly good-hearted, and she and her consort were more than successful with the pearapple and peach orchard that Dowsyl had inherited from his father. He paused. "Didn't know blackstaffers got so far south as Peachill or Eolya."

"They get everywhere, Merayni was saying, and the tales he told! Terrible, she said. About how a body can't even walk across some hills in Candar without turnin' black and shriveling up and dyin' right there on the spot."

"That may be," Kharl replied. "That's Candar, and not Nordla. Lord West is lucky to have one or two wizards that he can count on. Rather have him with wizards than some of the other Lords of the Quadrant."

"This young blackstaffer, he said that the lord's wizards weren't proper mages. 'A course, Father Jorum says all wizardry is evil."

"I wouldn't know if they're proper wizards." Kharl tilted his mug to get the last drop of ale. "I'm a cooper, not a wizard or a lord. That's their business. Mine's barrels. Solid barrels."

"Terrible stuff, magery." Charee sniffed again. "As bad as thieves and brigands, if you ask me."

"I'm sure there are good mages and bad ones. There are good lords and bad ones, good coopers and bad ones."

"No such thing as a good mage, if you ask me. Lord West can have them all. Be better if he hung 'em."

"That's what lords are for. Deal with raiders, and invaders, and brigands, and mages. Rather be a cooper."

Warrl yawned. So did Arthal.

"You two can take the bowls to the wash table," Charee said.

"Wish we had a sister, like Aubret does," mumbled Warrl. "Do all the dishes."

"You don't have a sister," Charee said. "Two of you are enough."

"…always say that…" murmured Arthal.

"Did you say something?" asked Kharl.

"No, ser."

"I didn't think so." Kharl pushed back his chair and walked to the window, letting the cool evening air flow around him. He hoped that Korlan would pick up the barrels in the morning.

Copyright © 2004 by L. E. Modesitt, Jr.

Meet the Author

L. E. Modesitt, Jr., is the bestselling author of the fantasy series The Saga of Recluce, Corean Chronicles, and the Imager Portfolio. His science fiction includes Adiamante, the Ecolitan novels, the Forever Hero Trilogy, and Archform: Beauty. Besides a writer, Modesitt has been a U.S. Navy pilot, a director of research for a political campaign, legislative assistant and staff director for a U.S. Congressman, Director of Legislation and Congressional Relations for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, a consultant on environmental, regulatory, and communications issues, and a college lecturer. He lives in Cedar City, Utah.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Post to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews

Wellspring of Chaos (Recluce Series #12) 4.8 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 13 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Zay:*gets hit out of nowhere* ???:ehehehe...*hits him again* zay:wait...it cant be...am i...fighting me?! Zay2:thats right! You shouldve just stayed put instead of being the hero!*punches zay* zay:*flies backwards then turns god mode* die!!!*punches him* zay2:hmph. Idiot!!!*takes the hit and zay gets hurt* zay:i forgot...im fighting me...rrrrrgggg...im a failiure! I shouldve listened!! Zay2:thats right...get consumed by doubt...little one! Zay:*feels as if hed been stabbed with onehundred blades*no...this...cant be...*falls to the ground* am i going to die..? Looking back my life is a failiure...unable to protect my friend...i cant even help link...this...no! I cant give up! Fleetway,my student is always jolly! And what student inherits his way from someone other than his teacher!!!!*charges up his energy and they fight for 12 hours straight* zay:this is it!!!*raises his arms and says RAITH REAPER:SEVEN SOULS OF PEACE!!!*the reapers attack zay2 and he dies zay falls down on res thirty six*
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I've much enjoyed the previous books in this series, but all have tended to begin with a boy or very young man. This breaks that tradition and starts with an older man in the prime of life. It deals with issues affecting a family man and one who has seen much of life. It takes some interesting twists and turns and brings you to a conclusion that you will enjoy. I've just started the sequel to this book; it's starting out fast and also promises to be a good one. Hope you enjoy it too.
Guest More than 1 year ago
In the city of Brysta in the realm of Nordla, Kharl is contented with his work as a highly regarded cooper, loves his wife and two sons. When Kharl hears a cry he comes to the rescue of a neighbor¿s daughter who is being attacked by two men. He finds out that one of the attackers is nobleman Captain Egen of the City Guard. Egen considers Kharl an enemy so when a young woman is murdered, the captain arranges for Kharl to be arrested for the crime.............................. Testimony proves that Kharl couldn¿t have murdered anyone but his wife is convicted of the crime and he has to helplessly watch her execution. His sons flee because they know Egen is waiting to kill them. Kharl leaves the country and begins to realize that he has the powers of a mage. He learns how to harness that power which comes in handy when battling pirates or being involved in a civil war........................ WELLSPRING OF CHAOS takes place in the Recluse universe but that country is hardly involved in the storyline so this is a book that can be read by people who haven¿t perused the other novels of L.E. Modesitt, Jr. (though they come highly recommended).. The protagonist is a hero in the true sense of the word because he does what is right no matter the personal cost and does not seek revenge for the crimes against him. Kharl grows into his powers slowly as an outgrowth of his profession so the audience believes that his mage power is real. The author once again writes a fantasy novel that is simply superb.................................. Harriet Klausner