What Matters Most

( 28 )

Overview

With every New York Times bestseller, Luanne Rice illuminates yet another of the secret wonders of the heart. Her unforgettable evocations of family, friendship, and loves lost and won in such novels as The Edge of Winter, Sandcastles, and Summer of Roses give voice to our most powerful emotions. Now she brings back two of her most beloved characters to tell of their journey across the sea to unravel the ...
See more details below
Paperback (Mass Market Paperback - Reprint)
$6.83
BN.com price
(Save 8%)$7.50 List Price
Other sellers (Paperback)
  • All (172) from $1.99   
  • New (5) from $2.65   
  • Used (167) from $1.99   
What Matters Most

Available on NOOK devices and apps  
  • NOOK Devices
  • NOOK HD/HD+ Tablet
  • NOOK
  • NOOK Color
  • NOOK Tablet
  • Tablet/Phone
  • NOOK for Windows 8 Tablet
  • NOOK for iOS
  • NOOK for Android
  • NOOK Kids for iPad
  • PC/Mac
  • NOOK for Windows 8
  • NOOK for PC
  • NOOK for Mac
  • NOOK Study
  • NOOK for Web

Want a NOOK? Explore Now

NOOK Book (eBook)
$6.99
BN.com price

Overview

With every New York Times bestseller, Luanne Rice illuminates yet another of the secret wonders of the heart. Her unforgettable evocations of family, friendship, and loves lost and won in such novels as The Edge of Winter, Sandcastles, and Summer of Roses give voice to our most powerful emotions. Now she brings back two of her most beloved characters to tell of their journey across the sea to unravel the mysteries of a shared past—and two undying love affairs.…

What Matters Most

Sister Bernadette Ignatius has returned to Ireland in the company of Tom Kelly to search for the past—and the son—they left behind. For it was here that these two long-ago lovers spent a season of magic before Bernadette’s calling led her to a vocation as Mother Superior at Star of the Sea Academy on the sea-tossed Connecticut shore. For Tom, Bernadette’s choice meant giving up his fortune and taking the job as caretaker at Star of the Sea, where he could be close to the woman he could no longer have but whom he never stopped loving. And while one miracle drew them apart, another is about to bring them together again.

For somewhere in Dublin a young man named Seamus Sullivan is also on a search, dreaming of being reunited with his own first love, the only “family” he’s ever known. They’d been inseparable growing up together at St. Augustine’s Children’s Home, until Kathleen Murphy’s parents claimed her and she vanished across the sea to America. Now, in a Newport mansion, that very girl, grown to womanhood, works as a maid and waits with a faith that defies all reason for the miracle that will bring back the only boy she’s ever loved.

That miracle is at hand—but like most miracles, it can come only after the darkest of nights and the deepest of heartbreaks. For life can be as precarious as a walk along a cliff, and its greatest rewards reached only by those who dare to risk everything…for what matters most.

From the Hardcover edition.

Read More Show Less

Editorial Reviews

From the Publisher
“A page-turner.”—Chicago Sun-Times

“Luanne Rice has a talent for navigating the emotions that range through familial bonds, from love and respect to anger.”—The Denver Post

“Rice has an elegant style, a sharp eye and a real warmth. In her hands families—and their values—seem worth cherishing.”—San Francisco Chronicle

From the Trade Paperback edition.

Publishers Weekly

True love never dies-but it may need the helping hand of the Virgin Mary and the luck o' the Irish to survive in Rice's latest, effectively a sequel to last year's Sandcastles. Sister Bernadette Ignatius (the former Bernie Sullivan), Mother Superior at the coastal Connecticut Star of the Sea Academy, travels to Dublin with Tom Kelly, the academy's ombudsman, seeking James, the son they gave up over 20 years ago. In a parallel narrative set up in a prologue, young James and Kathleen, raised together as orphans, are devastated when they are forced to separate when Kathleen is 13. While Bernie and Tom look for James (now calling himself Seamus), James searches for Kathleen, who pines for him in a Newport, R.I., mansion, where she is a cook and maid for an atrocious, wealthy family. Rice juices up the predictable plot line with miraculous visions, ghosts, convenient encounters and melodramatic twists of fate-yet the effects are still lukewarm, though there's guilt, redemption and three-hankie moments aplenty for those who stick it out to the end. (July)

Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information
Library Journal
Never mind that Bernadette Sullivan and Tom Kelly, first seen in last year's Sandcastles, are passionately in love. Bernadette has followed the call and withdrawn to a cloister. Then the two are compelled to seek out the son they gave up for adoption. Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
An emotionally exhaustive revisit with the two Irish-American families from Sandcastles (2006). This time around, Rice turns her attention to Sister Bernadette (Bernie) Sullivan and Thomas (Tom) Kelly. Long before Sister Bernie took her vows, she and Tom were young lovers (see Sandcastles for backstory). While on a romantic holiday to Ireland connecting with their roots, Bernie and Tom shared a single night of passion. Bernie became pregnant. Tom wanted to keep the baby, but Bernie struggled between her calling to the church and her love for Tom. Ultimately, the baby was given up for adoption. Now, 20-odd years later, Tom and Bernie decide to fly to Dublin to track down their son, Seamus, and introduce themselves as his parents. At the reunion, Seamus wants nothing to do with the family that abandoned him and left him in a crowded orphanage. To make matters more complicated, the disastrous meeting stirs up old passions between Tom and Bernie. Their romantic detente ends and their friendship is irrevocably altered. Tom makes a final effort to win over Seamus before flying back to America. Grudgingly, Seamus accepts Tom's help when Tom offers to use his influence to reunite Seamus with his lost love from the orphanage. With Tom's help, Seamus tracks down his love in America. At this point, the plot spins wildly out of control as the author tosses in one melodramatic, outlandish event after another. Though a few new characters are sprinkled in, it's impossible to care about them. Rice, usually good at bringing to life the Irish landscape, this time falls flat.
Read More Show Less

Product Details

  • ISBN-13: 9780553589702
  • Publisher: Random House Publishing Group
  • Publication date: 6/24/2008
  • Format: Mass Market Paperback
  • Edition description: Reprint
  • Pages: 496
  • Sales rank: 471,777
  • Product dimensions: 4.30 (w) x 6.82 (h) x 1.08 (d)

Meet the Author

Luanne Rice
Luanne Rice is the author of twenty-five novels, most recently Light of the Moon, What Matters Most, The Edge of Winter, Sandcastles, Summer of Roses, Summer’s Child, Silver Bells, and Beach Girls. She lives in New York City and Old Lyme, Connecticut.

From the Hardcover edition.

Biography

Luanne Rice is the New York Times- bestselling author who has inspired the devotion of readers everywhere with her moving novels of love and family. She has been hailed by critics for her unique gifts, which have been described as "a beautiful blend of love and humor, with a little magic thrown in."

Rice began her writing career in 1985 with her debut novel Angels All Over Town. Since then, she has gone on to pen a string of heartwarming bestsellers. Several of her books have been adapted for television, including Crazy in Love, Blue Moon, Follow the Stars Home, and Beach Girls.

Rice was born in New Britain, Connecticut, where her father sold typewriters and her mother, a writer and artist, taught English. Throughout her childhood, Rice spent winters in New Britain and summers by Long Island Sound in Old Lyme, where her mother would hold writing workshops for local children. Rice's talent emerged at a very young age, and her first short story was published in American Girl Magazinewhen she was 15.

Rice later attended Connecticut College, but dropped out when her father became very ill. At this point, she knew she wanted to be a writer. Instead of returning to college, Rice took on many odd jobs, including working as a cook and maid for an exalted Rhode Island family, as well as fishing on a scallop boat during winter storms. These life experiences not only cultivated the author's love and talent for writing, but shaped the common backdrops in her novels of family and relationships on the Eastern seaboard. A true storyteller with a unique ability to combine realism and romance, Rice continues to enthrall readers with her luminous stories of life's triumphs and challenges.

Good To Know

Some interesting outtakes from our interview with Luanne:

"I take guitar lessons."

  • "I was queen of the junior prom. Voted in, according to one high school friend I saw recently, as a joke because my date and I were so shy, everyone thought it would be hilarious to see us onstage with crowns on our heads. It was 1972, and the theme of the prom was Color My World. For some reason I told my guitar teacher that story, and he said Yeah, color my world with goat's blood."

  • "I shared a room with both sisters when we were little, and I felt sorry for kids who had their own rooms."

  • "To support myself while writing in the early days, I worked as a maid and cook in one of the mansions in Newport, Rhode Island. I'd learned to love to cook in high school, by taking French cooking from Sister Denise at the convent next door to the school. The family I worked for didn't like French cooking and preferred broiled meat, well done, and frozen vegetables. They were particular about the brand—they liked the kind with the enclosed sauce packet. My grandmother Mim, who'd always lived with us, had taken the ferry from Providence to Newport every weekend during her years working at the hosiery factory, so being in that city made me feel connected to her."

  • "I lived in Paris. The apartment was in the Eighth Arrondissement. Every morning I'd take my dog for a walk to buy the International Herald Tribune and have coffee at a café around the corner. Then I'd go upstairs to the top floor, where I'd converted one of the old servant's rooms into a writing room, and write. For breaks I'd walk along the Seine and study my French lesson. Days of museums, salons du thé, and wandering the city. Living in another country gave me a different perspective on the world. I'm glad I realized there's not just one way to see things.

    While living there, I found out my mother had a brain tumor. She came to Paris to stay with me and have chemotherapy at the American Hospital. She'd never been on a plane before that trip. In spite of her illness, she loved seeing Paris. I took her to London for a week, and as a teacher of English and a lover of Dickens, that was her high point.

    After she died, I returned to France and made a pilgrimage to the Camargue, in the South. It is a mystical landscape of marsh grass, wild bulls, and white horses. It is home to one of the largest nature sanctuaries in the world, and I saw countless species of birds. The town of Stes. Maries de la Mer is inspiring beyond words. Different cultures visit the mysterious Saint Sarah, and the presence of the faithful at the edge of the sea made me feel part of something huge and eternal. And all of it inspired my novel Light of the Moon."

  • "I dedicated a book to Bruce Springsteen. It's The Secret Hour, which at first glance isn't a novel you'd connect with him—the novel is about a woman whose sister might or might not have been taken by a serial killer. I wrote it during a time when I felt under siege, and I used those deeply personal feelings for my fiction. Bruce was touring and I was attending his shows with a good friend. The music and band and Bruce and my friend made me feel somehow accompanied and lightened as I went through that time and reached into those dark places.

    During that period I also wrote two linked books—Summer's Childand Summer of Roses. They deal with the harsh reality of domestic violence and follow The Secret Hour and The Perfect Summer When I look back at those books, that time of my life, I see myself as a brave person. Instead of hiding from painful truths, I tried to explore and bring them to the light through my fiction. During that period, I met amazing women and became involved with trying to help families affected by abuse—in particular, a group near my small town in Connecticut, and Deborah Epstein's domestic violence clinic at Georgetown University Law Center. I learned that emotional abuse leaves no overt outward scars, but wounds deeply, in ways that take a long time to heal. A counselor recommended The Verbally Abusive Relationshipby Patricia Evans. It is life-changing, and I have given it to many women over the years."

  • "I became a vegetarian. I decided that, having been affected by brutality, I wanted only gentleness and peace in my life. Having experienced fear, I knew I could never willingly inflict harm or fear on another creature. All is related. A friend reminds me of a great quote in the Zen tradition: "How you do anything is how you do everything."
  • Read More Show Less
      1. Date of Birth:
        September 25, 1955
      2. Place of Birth:
        New Britain, CT

    Read an Excerpt

    Chapter One

    Sister Bernadette Ignatius and Tom Kelly sat in the back seat of a black cab, driving from Dublin's airport through the city. She felt jet-lagged from their flight from Boston and all the weather delays, but full of anticipation about what she was about to find out. Although she hadn't been here in over twenty years, Dublin looked so familiar: the lovely Georgian townhouses with their fanlights and brightly painted doors, stone bridges arching over the River Liffey, the columned facades of imposing government buildings.

    "Well, look at that," Tom said, leaning across the seat to point at the cozy brick bar with hot pink petunias spilling from glossy black window boxes. "O'Malley's Pub. It's still here. Remember? Our own personal Tir na Nog. That's where . . ."

    "Some things never change," she said quickly, to stop his words. "I wonder if Mr. O'Malley is still behind the bar."

    "I wonder what he'd think to see Bernie Sullivan in a nun's habit."

    "With the convent right around the corner, I doubt he's shocked by the sight of a nun."

    "No," Tom said. "But then, you're not just any nun."

    "Tom Kelly," she said sternly. "We're either going to do this the hard way or the easy way. I'm voting for the easy way."

    "You're the boss, Sister Bernadette," he said. "You always have been."

    She nodded once, hard. He was right about that: she was his employer. Tom was the foreman and groundskeeper at Star of the Sea Academy in Black Hall, Connecticut, where Bernadette was Superior. He and his crew kept the lawns manicured, the gardens blooming, the vineyard producing, and the old stone walls and buildings from falling apart. He had quite a vested interest in the place; it had once been the mansion and grounds of his paternal great-grandfather, the well-known industrialist and philanthropist Francis X. Kelly.

    Bernadette slid a glance across the seat, saw Tom staring out the cab window. She tried to read his expression. She had known him forever, or at least most of their lives. They had met at Star of the Sea, at summer picnics when his family would invite hers down to the beach for the day. Francis X. Kelly had employed her great-grandfather, Cormac Sullivan, to build all the walls on the property. Their families had long histories, and so did Bernadette and Tom.

    Tom had thrown away his family riches to work the land. He was passionate about social causes and justice, caught up in the legacy of his ancestors' poverty, hunger, and fighting spirit. He had gone to private schools, then turned his back on a life of luxury and ease. He liked to keep his hands dirty and his feet planted solidly on the ground. Bernie loved him for it. She doubted she could have a better foreman and knew she could never have a better friend.

    He looked tired, she thought. This trip was possibly more challenging for him than it was for her, and that was saying something. She knew that he had very strong hopes, in terms of the outcome. And she knew, even before they really set forth on their quest, that he would be disappointed.

    "Here we are," the driver said in his bright Irish accent. "The Convent of Notre Dame des Victoires."

    "Guess which one of us is staying here," Tom asked him.

    "Very funny," Bernadette said as the driver chuckled.

    Although the driver started to help her with her bags, Tom took over. She saw him reach into the trunk, pull out her suitcase. She rarely used it, hardly ever leaving Star of the Sea, except for the occasional monastic conference or retreat. Since her family--her brother John, his wife, Honor, and their three daughters--lived on the Academy grounds, she usually spent her week's vacation right there at home.

    She had applied for a sabbatical last year, hoping to go to Florence to study her beloved Fra Angelico, but had never found the time to take it. The Academy always needed her--to run the school, make decisions in the convent, keep the vineyard operating.

    This trip to Dublin fell under the category of "personal time." As Superior, she had granted time away to Sisters with sick siblings or parents, funerals to attend, family emergencies. For her own leave of absence, she had made arrangements very quickly, left Sister Ursula in charge of everything, including the hectic start of the school year. None of her nuns had ever needed to deal with anything like what she herself was about to face, and the thought of it sent chills through her body.

    "Are you cold, Bernie?" Tom asked, seeing her shiver, standing on the curb.

    "No," she said. "I'm fine."

    "Coming down with something?"

    She shook her head, gazing past him at the convent's curtained windows. She thought she saw the fabric move and a shadow pass behind the glass.

    "Well, I'll be at the house," he said. "You have my number if you need me. If they don't have orange juice, or you need some aspirin or something, you know who to call."

    "I'm sure they'll have everything I need," she said dryly, slipping her hands into her sleeves.

    "And if they don't, you'll get it," he said. "You do know how to take care of things, I'll give you that." He squinted up at the convent, as if assessing the brickwork. "There's some crumbling mortar there, needs repointing," he said, pointing at the front steps. It was probably a very effective way to block out his memory of the last time he'd dropped her off at this address.

    "Not every convent can be lucky enough to have you on staff," she said.

    He gazed down at her, the squint not letting up one bit. She waited for a smile, but it didn't come. What did she expect? For him to thank her for the compliment? Not likely, not Tom Kelly. Under the circumstances, it probably sounded to him meager at best.

    "At least, most likely, they don't have a resident vandal," he said, giving her a quick, mischievous smile. "What was that message, carved in the stone?" He paused, seeming to think, even though she was sure he knew the words by heart. She felt the heat in her neck and face, and she shook her head. She never would have expected Tom to be so mean. "Tell me the words, Bernie. The ones that appeared first, early in the summer . . ."

    " 'I was sleeping, but my heart kept vigil,' " she murmured.

    He nodded. "That's right," he said, lifting her bag, carrying it up the sidewalk. "How could I forget?"

    "You didn't," she said coolly, unlatching the wrought-iron gate at the foot of the front steps.

    As they climbed the steps, she felt years falling away, almost as if she were coming to the convent for the first time, preparing to join the order. Her mouth was dry, and she was filled with a sense of trepidation, fear that she might be making the wrong choice.

    "You sure you want to do this?" Tom asked, the same question he'd put to her twenty-three years earlier.

    "The choice has already been made," Bernie said, echoing her own response.

    Just then the door opened, and a nun stood there smiling widely, gazing at Bernie with warm green-gold eyes. She was tall and thin, and looked exactly as Bernie remembered her, all those years ago, when they were novices together.

    "Sister Bernadette Ignatius!" the nun said in her Kerry brogue.

    "Sister Anne-Marie," Bernie said.

    Tom slid the bag into the front hall, standing back as the old friends embraced and Bernie wiped away tears.

    "Is that you, Tom Kelly?" Sister Anne-Marie asked, beaming.

    "It sure is," he said. "How're you doing, Annie?"

    "I'm fine," she said, throwing herself against him in a big hug. Bernie watched the affection in both their faces, and she fought to keep her own expression as blank as possible. She knew this wasn't going to be simple, and she had to maintain as much control as she could.

    "Okay, I'm off," Tom said. "You have my number, Sister Bernadette. I'll see you tomorrow morning. Take good care of her, Sister Anne-Marie."

    "You know I will," she said with mock sternness, locking arms with Bernie, and pulling her into the inner sanctum, closing the door behind her.

    Bernie's heart was pounding. She looked around the hall, saw the delicate marble statue of the Blessed Mother standing in the alcove. The aroma of good cooking wafted down the hall, and she also smelled hints of incense from the chapel just off the front hall. Memories were flooding back, making her feel almost faint. She heard the car door slam, and when she glanced past the curtain, she saw Tom watching out the car window as the driver pulled away.

    "Feels like it's happening all over again," she said in a low voice.

    "It's not, though," Sister Anne-Marie replied, standing just behind her.

    "I'm not sure why I came," Bernie said. "This story has already been written. Right down to 'The End.' "

    "A kinder way to look at it," Sister Anne-Marie said gently, her tone bringing hot tears to Bernie's eyes as she eased her around, taking her hand, "is that the story is just beginning. 'Once upon a time . . .' "

    Bernie opened her mouth to reply, but just then she heard heavy footsteps coming through the parlor--the room where she had seen the shadow behind the curtain. And she knew without turning around that this was the person she dreaded seeing more than anyone in this world.

    Merrion Square was one of Dublin's finest addresses, hands down, and it was there that Tom Kelly directed the driver to take him. The large Georgian square was surrounded by museums and brick townhouses with wrought-iron balconies, ivy growing up the brick, bright front doors crowned by segmented fanlight windows, and commanding brass door knockers. Prosperous Dubliners had lived here since John Ensor laid out the square in 1762; the Kellys had moved in a quarter-century later.

    Three townhouses along the north side formed Dublin's Kelly stronghold. They all had sea serpent door knockers--the same image engraved on Tom's gold crest ring, that of the legendary sea monster said to have risen from the deep to protect Tadhg Mor O'Kelly, Tom's fierce kinsman who fell "fighting like a wolf dog," defending Ireland against the Vikings in the Battle of Clontarf in 1014.

    Tom shook his head. One hour in Dublin and he was already lost in the ancient history of another millennium. Or, more to the point, another decade. Climbing the stairs of the middle house, the one with the bright red door, he felt exhausted by his journey. His knock was answered by a maid as Elizabeth Kelly, his cousin William's wife, came charging down the stairs.

    "Tommy, you've arrived already!" she exclaimed. "Billy'll be beside himself. Why didn't you tell us your flight so we could've sent a car?"

    "Liza, hello. I didn't want to put you to any trouble," he said, hugging her.

    "Your first visit here in twenty-three years, and you think we wouldn't want to welcome you in Kelly style?"

    "Oh, you know me," he said, smiling at her warmth, happy to see her again. "I like things simple."

    "That's right," she said. "I remember. No fancy airs about you, not like your cousins Billy and Sixtus and Niall and Chris and the rest of them. You've spared yourself hearing about the latest Mercedes, but not for long. Billy'll be home soon enough, and he'll show you his toys. Clara, take Tom's bag up to his room now."

    Tom gave the young maid a glance, shook his head to let her know he'd carry it himself. Liza either didn't notice or decided not to care.

    "Where's Bernie, now?" she asked.

    "She's staying with the Sisters."

    "No," Liza said, her face falling. "Even on a vacation, they force her to stay in the convent?"

    Tom nodded, not really having the heart to explain that Bernie didn't take vacations, and that in any case this was far from a vacation.

    "Darn it," Liza said. "I was counting on spoiling her the way she spoiled us the last time we visited Star of the Sea. I still dream of that bed, with its view over the vineyard to the Sound. And the fresh flowers she brought every day . . . She's certainly kept it a showplace; your great-grandfather would be so pleased with her."

    "Yes, he would," Tom said, although he wasn't sure of that at all.

    "Well, I must tell you," Liza said, her eyes sparkling, "when we heard the two of you were coming, we couldn't have been more pleased. All of us. Sixtus and Emer, Niall and Isobel, as well as Billy and myself. Emer, though . . . she was a little confused."

    "About what?" Tom asked.

    "Well, the part about you traveling together. She said nuns weren't allowed to go places with men, but we all assumed that since you've known each other so long, and you work for her and all, that would be the special exception to the rule. Which is why we thought Bernie would be staying here."

    "Ah," he said. He should have known that the family gossip mill would be churning. He shook his head, hoping the dim hall light would hide the flush he felt spreading up his neck.

    "Well, Emer had it wrong. That's all. Tommy, you must be dead on your feet. Clara, where'd you go?" She stared down at his bag, sitting in the middle of the floor, then looked around for the maid with no small degree of panic. But Tom put his hand on her wrist, stopped her.

    "It's okay, Liza," he said. "Let me get that. Is it the same guest room? On the second floor?"

    "Yes, Tom. The Blue Room, we still call it."

    He kissed her cheek, and started up the stairs before she could offer the lift. These narrow townhouses were tall and steep, with just two rooms on each floor. The flights were different than in the states. Here in Ireland, he had to remember that the first floor was called the ground floor, and the second floor was called the first floor, and the third floor was called the second, and so on. In any case, by the time he reached the third flight, his thighs burned from climbing so many stairs, and he relished the feeling. His body felt ready to explode with pent-up energy.

    When he passed the laundry room, he smiled to see a treadmill in there beside the ironing board. Tom and his cousins were at that age when they had to start taking care of the Kelly heart--especially with all the fine dining and drinking his cousins probably did. Living at the Academy, tending the grounds, gave Tom a constant workout.

    Closing the Blue Room's door behind him, he stood at the window, gazing out at the square. The Convent of Notre Dame des Victoires wasn't visible. It was blocks away, but Tom saw it in his mind's eye. He wondered what Bernie was doing, whether she had decided to confide in Sister Anne-Marie or not. He wondered whether she had encountered the Mother Superior yet, and if so, whether she had managed to keep her emotions in check.

    He closed his eyes, pressed his forehead against the cool glass windowpane. If he stood very still, he could block out Dublin and almost see the words scratched into the stone of the Blue Grotto back at home, on the Academy grounds. I was sleeping, but my heart kept vigil.

    He sighed, shaking his head.

    "Bernie," he said.

    And then, because he was worn out from his flight and everything else, he kicked off his shoes and lay down on top of the blue bedspread, and tried to sleep.

    From the Hardcover edition.

    Read More Show Less

    Introduction

    A celebration of love’s infinite power, What Matters Most weaves two tales of undying devotion, illuminating past and present, hope and reconciliation, as only acclaimed novelist Luanne Rice can. Completing the unforgettable story of Sister Bernadette Ignatius and Tom Kelly that began in the bestseller Sandcastles, Rice takes us to the enchanted Irish homeland of these singular characters. Long ago, young lovers Tom and Bernadette forged a timeless bond on Ireland’s shores. When Bernadette’s calling led her to a life of service at Star of the Sea Academy in Connecticut, she and Tom left behind their secret past–and their newborn child. Now, more than two decades later, they have embarked on a bittersweet journey to reclaim him. They never imagined that they could also give their tormented son a chance to find his childhood sweetheart. She was the only family he had ever known, and not even an ocean will keep them apart. Each of the characters on this mesmerizing journey will find themselves risking everything for what matters most.

    The questions and discussion topics that follow are intended to enhance your reading of Luanne Rice’s What Matters Most. We hope they will enrich your experience of this deeply moving novel.

    Read More Show Less

    Foreword

    1. Discuss the role of miracles in What Matters Most. Which miracles were mixed blessings? Which ones brought unconditional joy to those who experienced them? If you had witnessed Bernadette’s vision, how would you have interpreted the words she heard: “Love my son”?

    2. How are “family” and “home” defined in What Matters Most? Who forged the strongest family ties? What sort of home life existed for those who inhabited St. Augustine’s Children’s Home, compared to Star of the Sea and the Wells home in Newport?

    3. How did you feel about Sister Eleanor Marie after learning about her childhood? Are actions such as hers unforgivable?

    4. Tom experienced a lifetime of longing for Bernadette, becoming the caretaker at Star of the Sea so that he could be near her. Kathleen and Seamus’s love remained strong despite years of physical separation. What kept these lovers devoted to each other, regardless of the circumstances? Which is more powerful: devotion or fate?

    5. In your opinion, why did Kathleen sleep with Pierce? How did their trysts reflect the loneliness and despair that had defined so much of her life?

    6. Discuss the dynamics of the Wells household. Who are the most powerful family members? Do women or men dominate the decision making? What standards do the Wellses use to measure happiness and fulfillment?

    7. What does it mean to be a member of the Kelly family? How do Dublin’s monuments and the legend of the sea monster convey their special legacy? What do the stark differences between Seamus’s heritage and Kathleen’s tell us about the consequences ofknowing our genealogical roots?

    8. What is the effect of Honor and John’s story, and their family’s ability to experience redemption, in the midst of Bernadette’s ordeal?

    9. What was the result of the reunions featured in the novel? How do they compare to the reunion scenes anticipated and hoped for by the characters? With which figures from your past would you most want to be reunited?

    10. In chapter sixteen, Tom says he believes Bernadette is exempt from fully living in this world; her life as Mother Superior insulates her from real-life woes. What are the benefits and limitations of her life as a nun? How does she perceive this identity?

    11. What transformations have taken place in Seamus by the time he sees the ghost? Would the younger Seamus have been able to accept such an experience, or to even hear the ghost’s message?

    12. What had you predicted for Bernadette and Tom as they crossed paths with John and Honor in the closing scenes of Sandcastles? What aspects of Bernadette and Tom’s quest surprised you the most? In what way does What Matters Most underscore other aspects of yearning and healing in previous Luanne Rice novels you have read?

    Read More Show Less

    Reading Group Guide

    1. Discuss the role of miracles in What Matters Most. Which miracles were mixed blessings? Which ones brought unconditional joy to those who experienced them? If you had witnessed Bernadette’s vision, how would you have interpreted the words she heard: “Love my son”?

    2. How are “family” and “home” defined in What Matters Most? Who forged the strongest family ties? What sort of home life existed for those who inhabited St. Augustine’s Children’s Home, compared to Star of the Sea and the Wells home in Newport?

    3. How did you feel about Sister Eleanor Marie after learning about her childhood? Are actions such as hers unforgivable?

    4. Tom experienced a lifetime of longing for Bernadette, becoming the caretaker at Star of the Sea so that he could be near her. Kathleen and Seamus’s love remained strong despite years of physical separation. What kept these lovers devoted to each other, regardless of the circumstances? Which is more powerful: devotion or fate?

    5. In your opinion, why did Kathleen sleep with Pierce? How did their trysts reflect the loneliness and despair that had defined so much of her life?

    6. Discuss the dynamics of the Wells household. Who are the most powerful family members? Do women or men dominate the decision making? What standards do the Wellses use to measure happiness and fulfillment?

    7. What does it mean to be a member of the Kelly family? How do Dublin’s monuments and the legend of the sea monster convey their special legacy? What do the stark differences between Seamus’s heritage and Kathleen’s tell us about the consequences of knowing our genealogical roots?

    8. What is the effect of Honor and John’s story, and their family’s ability to experience redemption, in the midst of Bernadette’s ordeal?

    9. What was the result of the reunions featured in the novel? How do they compare to the reunion scenes anticipated and hoped for by the characters? With which figures from your past would you most want to be reunited?

    10. In chapter sixteen, Tom says he believes Bernadette is exempt from fully living in this world; her life as Mother Superior insulates her from real-life woes. What are the benefits and limitations of her life as a nun? How does she perceive this identity?

    11. What transformations have taken place in Seamus by the time he sees the ghost? Would the younger Seamus have been able to accept such an experience, or to even hear the ghost’s message?

    12. What had you predicted for Bernadette and Tom as they crossed paths with John and Honor in the closing scenes of Sandcastles? What aspects of Bernadette and Tom’s quest surprised you the most? In what way does What Matters Most underscore other aspects of yearning and healing in previous Luanne Rice novels you have read?

    Read More Show Less

    Customer Reviews

    Average Rating 4
    ( 28 )
    Rating Distribution

    5 Star

    (14)

    4 Star

    (8)

    3 Star

    (2)

    2 Star

    (3)

    1 Star

    (1)

    Your Rating:

    Your Name: Create a Pen Name or

    Barnes & Noble.com Review Rules

    Our reader reviews allow you to share your comments on titles you liked, or didn't, with others. By submitting an online review, you are representing to Barnes & Noble.com that all information contained in your review is original and accurate in all respects, and that the submission of such content by you and the posting of such content by Barnes & Noble.com does not and will not violate the rights of any third party. Please follow the rules below to help ensure that your review can be posted.

    Reviews by Our Customers Under the Age of 13

    We highly value and respect everyone's opinion concerning the titles we offer. However, we cannot allow persons under the age of 13 to have accounts at BN.com or to post customer reviews. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.

    What to exclude from your review:

    Please do not write about reviews, commentary, or information posted on the product page. If you see any errors in the information on the product page, please send us an email.

    Reviews should not contain any of the following:

    • - HTML tags, profanity, obscenities, vulgarities, or comments that defame anyone
    • - Time-sensitive information such as tour dates, signings, lectures, etc.
    • - Single-word reviews. Other people will read your review to discover why you liked or didn't like the title. Be descriptive.
    • - Comments focusing on the author or that may ruin the ending for others
    • - Phone numbers, addresses, URLs
    • - Pricing and availability information or alternative ordering information
    • - Advertisements or commercial solicitation

    Reminder:

    • - By submitting a review, you grant to Barnes & Noble.com and its sublicensees the royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable right and license to use the review in accordance with the Barnes & Noble.com Terms of Use.
    • - Barnes & Noble.com reserves the right not to post any review -- particularly those that do not follow the terms and conditions of these Rules. Barnes & Noble.com also reserves the right to remove any review at any time without notice.
    • - See Terms of Use for other conditions and disclaimers.
    Search for Products You'd Like to Recommend

    Recommend other products that relate to your review. Just search for them below and share!

    Create a Pen Name

    Your Pen Name is your unique identity on BN.com. It will appear on the reviews you write and other website activities. Your Pen Name cannot be edited, changed or deleted once submitted.

     
    Your Pen Name can be any combination of alphanumeric characters (plus - and _), and must be at least two characters long.

    Continue Anonymously
    See All Sort by: Showing 1 – 20 of 28 Customer Reviews
    • Posted December 9, 2008

      more from this reviewer

      a reviewer

      Over two decades Bernadette Ignatius and Tom Kelly were lovers. She became pregnant and gave birth to his son. However, Bernadette decided to join the church to become a nun. Unable to raise the lad by himself, Tom agreed to place the newborn in a Dublin orphanage. To be near her, he became the caretaker at the convent where she took her vows. --- Now twenty-three years later, Tom and Sister Bernie search for their offspring angry Seamus Sullivan, who loathes his biological parents for deserting him. When Tom learns that Seamus loves a former orphanage resident Kathleen, whose parents came for her a decade ago, he encourages him to go out and get her. However, to find love, Seamus must move past his hate to forgive his parents while Kathleen is across the ocean in Newport knowing the only boy she loves will one day come for her. --- WHAT MATTERS MOST is filled with memorable characters whose faith is tested as each of the prime four players struggle to do what they feel is right they each learn a Plato-like lesson that to have a miracle first one must suffer in their cases heartbreak. The story line is enhanced by visions and ghosts, but uses to many expedient scenarios that enable the prime cast to run into each other at critical times though some might insist serendipitously miracles are in their corner. Still the lead four protagonists make for a powerful inspirational tale as they learn WHAT MATTERS MOST in life. --- Harriet Klausner

      1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Posted November 23, 2009

      more from this reviewer

      I Also Recommend:

      A very powerful novel

      Such a powerful second installment from Luanne Rice's Sandcastles. It picks up where the book left off. Sister Bernadette Igantious and Thomas Kelly travel back to Ireland to find the son they placed for adoption 23 years ago. The son, whom they thought, had an amazingly wonderful life with an adoptive family. What they come to find is that their son grew up in a Children's Home and was never adopted, he sometimes lived on the street on his own and although he went through such pain, trials and tribulations, he still become such an amazing man. There in Ireland, the love that was always between Sister Bernadette and Tom were ignited and the gravity of what they did 23 years ago is now in front of them. They find love, forgiveness and family.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted September 5, 2008

      LUANNE RICE'S BEST BOOK YET

      I have read a lot of LuAnne Rice's books and loved them all except The Edge of Winter. This one, though, simply put, is THE BEST one I have read to date. I couldn't put it down. I didn't want it to end, and it stayed with me even after I had finished reading it. One of my all-time favorite books has been The Thorn Birds and this, though different, reminded me of it. I have passed the word on to my friends--it's a must read! I have to just break my habit of reading ahead. It does tend to ruin the climax of the book. Keep the tissues handy.

      0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted July 9, 2008

      Total Page Turner

      One of the best books I¿ve read in a long time. Took me only 2 days to read it, I couldn't put it down. I enjoyed how the author described everything down to the very detail, Made me have a very clear picture in my mind about where and what the characters were all doing. This is my first Luanne Rice book that I have just finished up and can't wait to read more of her books. Amazing Book!

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted July 17, 2008

      Another Cloud Nine Disappointment

      Why, through the ages, is it considered romantic for a couple to be parted by death? Anyone want to define 'romance novel' for me? It was bad enough Tom and Bernie were separated by her visions, but this story was a complete and utter disappointment. I kept waiting for Bernie to see the light and realize that nothing much mattered if it couldn't be shared with a soul mate. Her angst just made me angry. Luanne, get a clue. You are a wonderful author, but I keep on wanting to rewrite the ending of this story just about as much as I did the ending of Cloud Nine.

      0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted May 12, 2008

      A page turner

      I agree with the prior reviewer who said to read Sandcastles first. Tom and Bernie are wonderful characters and their story of committment, faith, love and doubt is wonderful. There was an easy 'cop out' ending that the author could have taken. I'm glad she didn't. The ending was sad, but appropriate.

      0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted January 29, 2008

      Disappointed

      I have read all of Rice's novels to date. Very disappointed in this one. Have not paid much attention to Catholic church policy, but now understand the grand problem with their priests. Am now very hesitant to read another of her novels.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted November 4, 2007

      This story touched me deeply

      This is a story about Bernie and Tom, former lovers, with a subplot involving James (their young adult son) and Kathleen. It is a story of love and yearning. It is also a story of faith and overcoming obstacles. I found each of the main characters, humanly flawed, yet so likeable. Imagining these characters in Dublin, in Newport RI and in Ct just added to the enjoyment of reading a great story.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted October 14, 2007

      Wonderful book

      This book was one of the best books I have ever read. It pulls you in from the moment you start reading it. I would suggest reading Sandcastles first since this book is somewhat of a continutation of it. This would make a great movie !

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted August 6, 2007

      Loved this story

      I really enjoyed this book.I love Bernie and Tom.It was nice to read about other characters from the last, also wonderful, book sand castles.A defenit must read

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted September 9, 2007

      WHAT A GREAT STORY

      This was a great book. I had a lump in my throat for most of it. It was beautiful but sad all at he same time. I've been reading luanne's books and am becomng a big fan! i'd like to see this book as a movie.

      Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
    • Anonymous

      Posted December 21, 2009

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted January 30, 2010

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted June 12, 2011

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted January 1, 2011

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted January 19, 2011

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted March 14, 2013

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted January 28, 2010

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted April 17, 2011

      No text was provided for this review.

    • Anonymous

      Posted September 9, 2011

      No text was provided for this review.

    See All Sort by: Showing 1 – 20 of 28 Customer Reviews

    If you find inappropriate content, please report it to Barnes & Noble
    Why is this product inappropriate?
    Comments (optional)