Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question
This book examines Richard Whately's classic book Historic Doubts Relative to Napoleon Buonaparte. After considering its textual development, the analysis focusses on Whately's idea of the ‘Preliminary Question’; the idea that in the debate about Jesus’s miracles there is a more basic question that has been overlooked and which invalidates the debate. It is asked whether the notion of a Preliminary Question might not illuminate other philosophical disputes. Finally, a variant of the Preliminary Question is proposed in which both positions in a dispute are shown to be true and this form of the question is invoked to shed light on the debate between metaphysical monists and dualists and to revisit the debate about miracles.

This book is essential reading for all scholars of the philosophy of religion and British 19th century philosophy. It is also of interest to scholars researching David Hume and Bertrand Russell.

1146670131
Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question
This book examines Richard Whately's classic book Historic Doubts Relative to Napoleon Buonaparte. After considering its textual development, the analysis focusses on Whately's idea of the ‘Preliminary Question’; the idea that in the debate about Jesus’s miracles there is a more basic question that has been overlooked and which invalidates the debate. It is asked whether the notion of a Preliminary Question might not illuminate other philosophical disputes. Finally, a variant of the Preliminary Question is proposed in which both positions in a dispute are shown to be true and this form of the question is invoked to shed light on the debate between metaphysical monists and dualists and to revisit the debate about miracles.

This book is essential reading for all scholars of the philosophy of religion and British 19th century philosophy. It is also of interest to scholars researching David Hume and Bertrand Russell.

44.99 In Stock
Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question

Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question

by David Berman
Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question

Whately's Historic Doubts about Napoleon's Existence and the Preliminary Question

by David Berman

Hardcover

$44.99 
  • SHIP THIS ITEM
    In stock. Ships in 1-2 days.
  • PICK UP IN STORE

    Your local store may have stock of this item.

Related collections and offers


Overview

This book examines Richard Whately's classic book Historic Doubts Relative to Napoleon Buonaparte. After considering its textual development, the analysis focusses on Whately's idea of the ‘Preliminary Question’; the idea that in the debate about Jesus’s miracles there is a more basic question that has been overlooked and which invalidates the debate. It is asked whether the notion of a Preliminary Question might not illuminate other philosophical disputes. Finally, a variant of the Preliminary Question is proposed in which both positions in a dispute are shown to be true and this form of the question is invoked to shed light on the debate between metaphysical monists and dualists and to revisit the debate about miracles.

This book is essential reading for all scholars of the philosophy of religion and British 19th century philosophy. It is also of interest to scholars researching David Hume and Bertrand Russell.


Product Details

ISBN-13: 9783031826924
Publisher: Springer Nature Switzerland
Publication date: 04/19/2025
Pages: 86
Product dimensions: 5.83(w) x 8.27(h) x (d)

About the Author

David Berman is Fellow Emeritus of Philosophy at Trinity College Dublin. He has published more than 90 peer-reviewed articles and 6 scholarly books.

Table of Contents

Chapter One: Textual Developments of the Historic Doubts.- Chapter Two: Whately's Critique of Hume.- Chapter Three: Whately on the Preliminary Question.- Chapter Four: No Truth answers to the Preliminary Question.- Chapter Five: Double Truth.

From the B&N Reads Blog

Customer Reviews