- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Available on NOOK devices and apps
Want a NOOK? Explore Now
Want a NOOK? Explore Now
1. Hannah Lapp’s family believes that since she was born into an Amish family, it is God’s will that she join the Amish faith. Do you agree or disagree with that line of thought? What Scripture or Biblical principle do you base your thoughts on?
2. At the beginning of the book, Hannah faces a tragedy that would shake most people’s foundational beliefs. If you could have talked to Hannah at that time, how could you have encouraged her? What would you have done differently from the choices both she and her parents made?
3. As a Beachy-Amish Mennonite Paul had to gain special permission from his parents and local church to attend college. If his motives had not been based in helping others in a way that required a four-year degree, his request would have been turned down. Should parents have the right to dictate their child’s future? If so, when is it the child’s place to resist the desires of their earthly parents in order to pursue the dreams of their own heart? Discuss Matthew 10:37 in light of Paul’s situation: “Anyone who loves his father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; anyone who loves his son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me.” (NIV)
4. Sarah’s jealousy toward Hannah would have been easily seen and labeled as wrong had the people around her known her inner thoughts. But Sarah hid her true feelings and motivations under piousness as she pretended to only want to keep Hannah from going farther into sin. Can you remember a time when someone tried to gossip to you, using the façade of being concerned? Discuss ways that such a conversation could be kept from taking place. If you will, take a moment and, just between you and God, ponder the next question. Have you participated in spreading gossip under such a guise?
5. At one point, even believing in her innocence, Matthew avoids Hannah for months because to do otherwise might stir rumors and/or cause Elle to think he’s interested in Hannah. In 1 Thessalonians 5:22 it says to “abstain from all appearance of evil.” (KJV) Discuss times when abstaining from the appearance of evil is proper and times when it is just a copout.
6. Matthew was Hannah’s strongest supporter during a time when every other male in her life had washed their hands of her. For his effort he received no earthly reward. Can you imagine reaching out to someone that almost everyone else has turned their back on?
7. The bishop was a strong leader, but in his strength he had a tendency to rule unfairly. Discuss some of the spiritual leaders in your life. During what circumstances, if any, do you think a person should pull away from their spiritual leader? What Biblical principals or specific Scriptures do you use to help form your foundation for those beliefs?
8. Hannah was honest about how she conceived the child, but her dishonesty over other things eroded her father’s faith in her. If your child was caught telling some lies and then needed you to believe them on other things, what would your reaction be? Would you be more interested in finding peaceful ways to work through the issues or in finding absolute truth? If peace is your goal, how would you go about attaining that? If truth is your goal, what are some things you could do to try to discover what really took place?
9. Paul’s grandmother agreed to keep Hannah and Paul’s friendship a secret and even allowed her U.S. Postal address to be used as a way for Hannah and Paul to correspond. Do you think a person who is not a parent has the right to override what a parent wishes? If so, is this belief limited to certain ages of the child? Or certain circumstances?
10. Because of what people believed to be true about her, Hannah was trapped in a community that had no respect or compassion for her. Discuss ways a person could cope with the prejudice from rumors and the unjust anger it stirs in others without leaving the situation.
Hannah Lapp loves her neighbor Paul Waddell, but her father Zeb refuses to see any of his daughters married to an outsider. Paul returns Hannah¿s high regard, but knows that her father would never tolerate a Mennonite in his Amish family and so fears any efforts on his part would leave Hannah considered dead by her dad. Still before he leaves in his English car for his fourth year of college, he asks Hannah to marry him. --- That same day that she and Paul become engaged, Hannah heads home carrying a basket of blueberries, when a man driving a car stops, pulls her into his vehicle and rapes her. Already in shock that God allowed such a terrible thing to happen to her, Hannah turns introspective especially when she feels the Old Ways of her family and community have failed her, but still turns to prayer especially when she turns out to be pregnant. --- WHEN THE HEART CRIES is an interesting look at the differences and similarities between the Amish and the Mennonites. Hannah is a deep protagonist who finds no solace with the Old Ways, with her family, or with her beloved as she feels that everyone holds her culpable for the rape. The story line focuses on everyday Amish life mostly through her perspective as a pariah, but though insightful that can turn tedious to the reader. Still overall this is a fine entry, and her will want Cindy Woodsmall to provide the further adventures of Hannah. --- Harriet Klausner
4 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.When the Heart Cries literally takes you on a journey of the heart. You will become entranced with Hannah, feeling her love and her pain throughout the book. Through no fault of her own, her family pushes her aside and you will want to pull her back in, but that is not how it works in the Plain life. Once a decision is made, there is no turning back.
You wil be touched by Matthew, who constantly sticks his neck out for his friend, Hannah, regardless of what the Bishop has to say. He will become a loving brother to you and you will want only the best for him.
Although Mary Yoder is in love with Luke, Hannah's brother, her loyalty is to her best friend. She puts her relationship with Luke on the line to protect her friend and to show Luke his way of thinking is too narrow. She forces him to open his eyes to the truth about his sister, even though it goes against what his parents believe to be true.
Sarah is Hannah's younger sister. Forever in emotional turmoil, this girl turns on her sister and causes an uproar in the Amish community that can't be extinguished. She is quite proud of her accomplishments and truly believes Hannah deserves the pain that has been put on her.
Then there is Paul, the love of Hannah's life. A good, loyal man with strong values, but a soft heart which allows him to see both the beauty in the Plain and the value of some Englischer ways. His love for Hannah is shaken when he finds out the secret she has been keeping.
The need to find out where Hannah's journey in life is taking her is captivating. You will not be able stop reading and when this book is complete, you'll want more. I was not able to stop until I had read all 3 books in the series.
Fantastic reading! It takes you away from the problems plaguing the world today and makes the simpler life much more appealing than our materialistic world will have you believe.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Hannah is part of an Old Order Amish family. Still, she's in love with Paul, who's a Mennonite. When he asks her to marry him, she happily accepts, even though there's a very good chance that it means she'll lose her family. This would be enough for a novel, I'm sure, but what the book is REALLY about is what happens after she gets engaged. On her way home, she is raped. Her family knows, but no one else in the community does. Slowly, rumors begin to spread about what's going on with Hannah, and it affects her relationships with her family, friends and, eventually, with Paul.
This is a very entertaining book (the first in a trilogy) and it's very interesting to see how things are dealt with in the Amish community. I like to think---I hope---that we're a little more sensitive here, but that may not be true.
This is very different from most of the Amish books I've read, in that the heroine does a lot of soul searching and spends a decent amount of time angry---at herself, at her family and even at God. It's a welcome change. I look forward to reading the other two books in the series. I like Hannah a great deal, and am excited to know what happens to her. (This could be read as a standalone book, although the book is open-ended.)
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Miss_Scarlyt
Posted March 9, 2011
I wanted to love this book but I thought it was just ok. I typically breeze through books but this one took a while to read and I really had to force myself to finish it. It was horribly predictable. At the end of chapter 1 I already knew exactly how it would end. I don't mind some predictability in a book but for every bit and piece to be easily predicted? It makes the book far too boring. Not to mention the utter negativity of the whole story. I kept hoping I was wrong in my assessments and that there would be happier experiences for the characters. But page after page was filled with heartache. This also contributed to my not really being interested in reading the book much.
There are several plots within the story but none of them really developed nor were they resolved by the end of the book. As this is only the first book in a series I guess the point is for you to read the other books as well to find out how everything really wraps up. But at least some small sense of closure would have been nice, I think. The main character is 17 year old Hannah Lapp, a girl raised in an Old Order Amish community. She falls in love with her neighbor's grandson Paul who is a Mennonite. Naturally the families (particularly Hannah's) do not approve. Despite this Paul asks Hannah to marry him and she accepts. And this very brief joy of the story comes to an abrupt halt the very day Paul proposes when Hannah is a victim of rape. The story follows her struggles to deal with the event and how her family and community react, as well as a series of other events that challenge the girl and make her question everything she's ever known.
I received this book for free from WaterBrook Multnomah Publishing Group for this review.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.aimeemoore1981
Posted February 28, 2011
This book is rivoting. It tells what can destroy a family when an Amish goes outside of her family and marries outside her community. The author has the ability to authentically capture the heart of her characters because she has had real-life connections with Amish Mennonite and Old Order Amish families. This book was heartfelt and had me wanting more.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Laineee
Posted July 18, 2010
Such a heart warming book. I have been to Lancaster Amish country, they are amazing people. I haven't cried so hard with a book in a long time.
I hope there will be a sequel.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged._paige_
Posted July 7, 2010
I thought this book was a great read and began a fabulous trilogy of Hannah's life. It was a great insight into the Amish and Mennonite lives of the characters. Some of the characters struggled staying loyal to their upbringing while others knew they would never sway. I enjoyed this book very much and read straight thru the other two books. I hope you enjoy them too!
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.AverageReader
Posted June 26, 2010
I wanted to like this book but from the beginning, the writing style was amateurish. I didn't hate it and read it to the end but the characters were never fully given life and the story line took such conventional turns that it never really engaged you. So many times when the story line should have been strong, the author briefly explains the situation, then quickly side steps giving it any validation or making you really care.
It's like picking up a bad romance novel; it's quick reading and you don't miss it when it's done.
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted January 17, 2010
Very moving characters. Couldn't put the book down. Would love to read more.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.this book is a good book when reading I just couldnt put it down now Im done with it and Im passing the book on
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.CarLur
Posted June 2, 2009
I just finished When the Heart Cries and must say, "This is an awesome book and would recommend it to anyone who loves to read." I started the book last night about 5 p.m. and finished it this afternoon about 3 p.m. It is so good to read Christian books instead of a lot of smut, cursing, and violent stories. Keep up the awesome work.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.I love to read Beverly Lewis and Wanda E Brunstetter books because they show the positive and negative sides of Amish life. They have book series, but the main plot is resolved in each book so that you don't feel left hanging.
This book really disappointed me. The Amish community was portrayed in a one-dimensional, negative way. I had to search for postive indications of these people. There were several plot lines, but none were resolved by the end of the book.
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.This was probably one of the most difficult books I've ever had to read. Normally it'll take me a couple days to a week to finish a book. However this book took me a month and a half to finish. I usually devour Amish fiction like there's no tomorrow. It's one of my favorite genres. This book unfortunately did not make my favorites list in this genre. I just dreaded reading about the horrible things that kept happening to Hannah and seeing how badly she was being treated by everyone especially her parents. Without spoiling the entire story, I was very disappointed at the way Hannah's situation was treated. I know that the Amish do not like to bring attention to themselves and are willing to forgive even the most heinous of crimes. However, that is no reason to blame your daughter for her getting raped! Then to top it off, the family doesn't press charges on the guy even though he might very well go and do the same thing to other women in the community! Rape is something in books that I feel justice must be served. I really hate it when I read about how the victim is blamed for the attack. It's one thing for the girl to blame herself from feelings of self guilt, but it's totally wrong when the PARENTS blame her for what happened. Hannah's whole life seems to be doomed from the beginning with Murphy's law just waiting for her at every corner. I did not like her sister at all, I have a feeling that there will be more trouble making from her. Her relationship with Paul seems to have the problem of a lack of communication. I wish the author had simply allowed them to sit down, talk things through, and get everything out on the table so no one would get confused or suspicious. But I guess if that happened there wouldn't be a story then.
I will say though that if there's anyone in this story that is a positive influence to Hannah, it is her friend Mary. Even without knowing Hannah's problem and the fact that she's had a traumatic experience herself, Mary stays by Hannah's side throughout the book even to the point of defending her against the man she loves who happens to be Hannah's brother. I only wish Hannah's family could have acted in the same way. It was interesting to learn more about the Amish lifestyle but as I said, the subject matter in this book made me uncomfortable and did not help to entice me to read the book. I'm not saying that I needed a happy ending with the story, and I know that there are more books in the series. I just could not fathom being a parent, having your daughter be raped, blame her for it, refuse to do anything to help her, and then still call yourself a Christian. I do have the other two books in the series, and I know that things will eventually get better for Hannah. Hopefully it won't take me as long to finish those books.
1 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted September 22, 2008
Hannah was raised in a traditional Old Order Amish family. She was only 17-years-old when she fell in love with Paul, an educated Mennonite. They knew their different backgrounds would lead to problems. However, the romance of Paul and Hannah acts as only the scenery behind this story. Through no fault of her own, tragedy struck Hannah. Not only does her family turn against her, so does Paul. Only her faith can carry her through the following events. Hannah finds herself questioning the Old Ways of her people. This is a moving story of Hannah, her faith, and beliefs. Things are not always the way some people see them. You have to believe in yourself even when it seems that no one else does. God is always there for you. Cindy Woodsmall calls on her background in this story. When The Heart Cries is a sad story. This book needs a bit of editing. Woodsmall already has plans to follow up with a sequel.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted February 13, 2008
Cindy Woodsmall provides interesting insight into the lives of the Old Order Amish. The character of Hannah Lapp is intelligent, strong, and compassionate. Hannah, undergoing heart wrenching circumstances, perseveres despite many obstacles. The reader will be completely wrapped up in the story from beginning to end. The ending will then prompt the reader to begin the sequel, When Morning Comes, immediately!
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted March 30, 2012
I hate to read I picked this book up I could not put it down.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted February 27, 2012
B
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.Anonymous
Posted February 14, 2012
This is a story that you are pulled into. My heart was breaking for Hannah. I read the last few chapters alone so that noone would see me sobbing.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.fuzzyandwarm
Posted January 3, 2012
I received a complimentary copy of this book from WaterBrook Multnoma through their blogging for books program. This book is about an Amish girl named Hannah. She is in love with a Mennonite boy. She agrees to marry him and then on her way home she is raped. The story deals with the repercussions of this. Hannah does not know what to do, and her parents tell her to forget about it and pretend like it never happened. Hannah falls into a deep depression. When she is finally starting to feel better she discovers that she is pregnant. I really enjoyed the character of Hannah. She is a very believable person. I was interested in what happened to her, and found myself cheering her on. I felt like the author played with time in the book. The author would say that several weeks or months had passed, and then suddenly act like only a couple of weeks had passed. It made it hard to understand what the time frame of the story was. I would give this book 3.5/5 stars.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.3895724
Posted September 27, 2011
This was a terrific book be sure to read all three books in this series
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
When Hannah dares to love across the boundaries of tradition, will she lose everything?Despite being raised in a traditional Old Order Amish family, seventeen-year-old Hannah Lapp desires to break with custom, forgo baptism into the faith, and marry outside the cloistered community. She’s been in love with Mennonite Paul Waddell for three years, and before returning to college for his senior year, Paul asks Hannah to be his wife. Hannah accepts, aware that her marriage will change her relationship with her family forever.
On the evening of their engagement, tragedy strikes and in ...