Who's Sorry Now?

Who's Sorry Now?

by Howard Jacobson

View All Available Formats & Editions

Marvin Kreitman, the luggage baron of South London, lives for sex. Or at least he lives for women. At present he loves four women--his mother, his wife Hazel, and his two daughters--and is in love with five more. Charlie Merriweather, on the other hand, nice Charlie, loves just the one woman, also called Charlie, the wife with whom he has been writing children's

…  See more details below


Marvin Kreitman, the luggage baron of South London, lives for sex. Or at least he lives for women. At present he loves four women--his mother, his wife Hazel, and his two daughters--and is in love with five more. Charlie Merriweather, on the other hand, nice Charlie, loves just the one woman, also called Charlie, the wife with whom he has been writing children's books and having nice sex for twenty years. Once a week the two friends meet for lunch, contriving never quite to have the conversation they would like to have--about fidelity and womanizing, and which makes you happier. Until today. It is Charlie who takes the dangerous step of asking for a piece of Marvin's disordered life, but what follows embroils them all, the wives no less than the husbands. And none of them will ever be the same again.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly
In Man Booker Prize–winner (for The Finkler Question) Jacobson’s 2002 novel, only now being released in the U.S., Marvin Kreitman and Charlie Merriweather, friends for 20 years, meet once a week for dim sum. Kreitman, “the luggage baron of South London,” is married, has two teenage daughters, and any number of lovers. Charlie has always been faithful to his wife, also named Charlie, with whom he shares two children and a career—the two are coauthors of highly successful children’s books. One day Charlie shocks Kreitman by suggesting a bit of wife swapping. Kreitman doesn’t take his friend seriously until a random accident precipitates a series of farcical circumstances ending with a paradigm shift in the two couples’ relationships. Friends, lovers, and relatives are thrown into chaos as Jacobson hilariously chronicles what happens when Kreitman and Charlie look at life from new perspectives. This kind of schematic plotting might seem like the stuff of which Hollywood high-concept comedies are made. But Jacobson writes in a much looser vein and uses his situation to humorously examine various aspects of how we live now. Although the reader eventually grows weary of these solipsistic characters, Jacobson has a reliable penchant for garnering rude laughs at their expense. (July)
From the Publisher

“[A] ribald, intelligent and sneakily tragic novel.” —San Francisco Chronicle

“Comic genius.” —Booklist Online

“This kind of schematic plotting might seem like the stuff of which Hollywood high-concept comedies are made. But Jacobson writes in a much looser vein and uses his situation to humorously examine various aspects of how we live now.” —Publishers Weekly

“Jacobson is often likened to Philip Roth, but there's plenty of Isaac Bashevis Singer in [Who's Sorry Now]. Fans won't be disappointed.” —Kirkus Reviews

“Nominally the fare of stage comedy, in Jacobson's adroit hands the stuff of farce also becomes the instrument of ruin. It is both funny and painful, the mixture of which this novelist is a master.” —Haaretz

Library Journal
Charlie Merriweather has been married to the same woman, also named Charlie, for 20 years; together they write a successful children's book series. Feeling restless and trapped and looking for a no-strings-attached sexual encounter, he turns to his friend Marvin Kreitman, known for his promiscuity with women of various ages, none of them his wife. Charlie begs Marvin to "give" him one of his ladies. In a complex turn of events, and almost by accident, the men swap wives, causing chaos and confusion among families, friends, and lovers until Charlie and his wife reconcile. VERDICT Man Booker Prize-winning novelist Jacobson (The Finkler Question) draws unique and unusual characters upended by the confusion of middle age; the inner workings of their ambitions and motivations are revealed through dense and cerebral prose. His work will appeal to readers of complex fiction and those who like to explore the psychology behind human actions.—Joanna Burkhardt, Univ. of Rhode Island Libs., Providence
Kirkus Reviews
Another middle-age-angst–meets–sex-romp comedy from Jacobson (The Finkler Question, 2010, etc.), that great chronicler of modern rakery. Originally published in Britain in 2002, before news of its author crossed the waters to these shores, Jacobson's shaggy dog story is a little more descriptive and a little less conversational than his more recent work. Marvin Kreitman, South London's luggage purveyor par excellence, is a picaresque lothario who just can't help being who he is: He loves women unconditionally and unreasonably, so much so that besides the four women in his life--mother, wife ("When she wasn't Oedipus she was Jocasta"), two daughters--he is desperately attempting to juggle relationships with five others. Added to this busy schedule, he keeps a standing lunch date each week with a school friend named Charlie who's always been a bit of a schlimazel ("He drooped disconsolately, like a puppy who had grown too big for its owner and been thrown onto the streets"), even though he has a stable, apparently happy marriage of long standing and enjoys some success as the author of children's books. Yet Charlie, like Kreitman (Jacobson uses the first name for the former, the last name for the latter, as if to suggest the differences in emotional age and worldliness), is vaguely dissatisfied, and he proposes an arrangement that surprises even the ever-scheming Kreitman. Before things can go too far, fate intervenes in the form of a schlemiel ("Not merely Man with No Qualities but Man with No Prospects of Qualities") who complicates things dangerously, revealing Kreitman's fixations as being the silly but eminently harmful things that they are. Things cannot help but end--well, if not badly, then in a little more disarray than when the tale began. Jacobson is often likened to Philip Roth, but there's plenty of Isaac Bashevis Singer in his somewhat weary understanding of the human condition. Fans won't be disappointed.

Read More

Product Details

Bloomsbury USA
Publication date:
Product dimensions:
5.51(w) x 8.26(h) x 0.88(d)

Related Subjects

Read an Excerpt


You can learn a lot about a man from the sorts of bedtime stories he tells his children. Marvin Kreitman, archivist of himself, put his daughters to sleep — when he was at home — with reminiscences so painful to him, they might have been designed to hurry the girls out of childhood altogether.

This was one of them:

Every Thursday, Friday, Saturday night, come wind, come rain, small squishy-hearted Marvin Kreitman — that's me — watched his father, the Purse King — that's your grandfather — shake from his leather apron, like rats from a rat-catcher's sack, the takings from his market stall. Spellbound, he watched the crumpled notes creak like sand crabs in a huddle, slowly open, move sideways and come apart. Every Thursday, Friday, Saturday night the same. And every Thursday, Friday, Saturday night, small squishy-hearted Marvin Kreitman was excluded from the count.

'Go up to your room and do your homework.' Your grandmother talking.

'I've done my homework.'

'Marvin, you can never do too much homework!'

'Can't I just stay to straighten the fivers?'

'Fivers! Fivers!' Theatrically, like a woman concealing a terrible secret, a crime or a deformity, Mona Kreitman interposed herself between her only child and the contents of the sack. 'Do you know what my dream for you is?' she asked. I did, but I waited for her to tell me anyway. 'My dream for you is that you won't ever have to touch money. My dream for you is that you will be above money. Look what money does to you.' She showed me how dirty money was, how it got into the grains of your skin, how it stained the palms of your hands and blackenedthe tips of your fingers the way newspapers did, only worse. Had she been able to tear open her chest for me, and show how money discoloured the soul as well, of course she would have done so.

'So why do you touch it then?'

'Ha!' A bitter laughless laugh, full of narrative promise. Once upon a time . . . But a grown-up story with no good fairies in it. Unless the good fairy was her. She lowered herself into the notes, a mermaid in a sea of creaking crabs, until we were the same size. 'We do what we do, Marvin,' she sang to me, on her knees, making 'we' a tragical and lonely word, 'because we have no choice. You, on the other hand, have a choice. We have given you that choice. You ask me why we touch money? So that you won't ever have to. Now do your homework and become Prime Minister.'

Not to be argumentative, but because I wanted to stay swimming in the warm pools of her eyes, I said, 'Prime ministers get to touch money.'

'Oh, do they now! So what do you think the Chancellor of the Exchequer is for?'

'Then I'll be Chancellor of the Exchequer.'

'See! There only has to be money on the floor and already you're thinking small. Listen to me . . . A little boy as clever as you are doesn't ever have to settle for second-best. You just do your homework and become Prime Minister.' Whereupon she put her arms around me and kissed me, more as if I were a little king than a politician, the king Cophetua and she, with her blazing black Caspian eyes, her gold hooped earrings and her filthy fingertips, the beggar-maid.

'If you want to count something,' my father chipped in, a croak from the house of the dead, 'count your blessings.'

But blessings are less easy to count than money and Marvin Kreitman never did learn to count his.

'Not even us, Daddy?' the girls were too young, in those days, to have asked.

Which might have given him pause for thought. As it was, determined to be a better parent than his own father, loving if a little absent, at his most comfortable with them once they'd actually gone to sleep, he rose from the tiny toadstool chair by their beds, put his cheek to each of theirs, smelled their hair, as sharp as Chardonnay, kissed the tangy gristle of their ears, and wished them sweet dreams.

'And tomorrow night, if you're good' — and if he happened to be home — 'I'll tell you what they did to Daddy next . . .'

Charlie Merriweather, on the other hand, a father who was always at home, sprawled on the bed with his children and invented stories calculated to make them splutter into each other's necks and slither about all over him like sea lions.

For example:

One day, Timmy Hyphen Smelly-Botty Farnsbarns, brother of Kitty-Litter Farnsbarns, was hiding in the school lavs reading the Financial Times — as he did every morning in summer, preferring to keep the Daily Telegraph, which, as you know, is warmer, for the winter months — when suddenly the headmaster, who also happened to be his father, the Right Reverend Doctor Arty-Farty Farnsbarns, hammered at the door with a dire warning. 'If you don't come out of there in the next seven and a half hours, Timmy Hyphen Smelly-Botty, you won't only end up being flushed away along with your dooh-dahs, you will miss the school outing to Feelgood Hall. And you know what that means, don't you?'

Timmy Hyphen Smelly-Botty knew only too well what missing the school outing to Feelgood Hall meant. It meant missing a ride in the school bus, singing 'Ten Green Bottles'. It meant missing sitting next to his girlfriend, Dymphna No Hyphen Droopy Drawers and stealing dolly mixtures from her socks. It meant going without isosceles triangles of cucumber-and-cream-cheese sandwiches, and trapeziums of treacle tarts, and rhomboids of hot rhubarb crumble drowning in lumpy-dumpy custard, to say nothing of his favourite — lemon meringue pie, served in crystal icosahedral dishes with the arms of Feelgood Hall engraved into their bottoms. But above all it meant not seeing the First Lord Felix Very Very Feelgood, who also had the family coat of arms engraved into his bottom, and who was often to be found by the lily pond with one leg tucked under him like a duck, reciting the poem Timmy Hyphen Smelly-Botty Farnsbarns loved best in all the world —

I'll tell thee everything I can:

There's little to relate.

I saw an aged, aged man.

A-sitting on a gate.

But then Charlie Merriweather was a professional, one half of the team who wrote the much-loved (if these days . . . but to hell with these days) C. C. Merriweather books for children. Whereas Marvin Kreitman, despite all the eloquent interventions of his mother, only sold purses.

Why Kreitman saw selling purses as an 'only', considering the number of them he did sell - his father's boy, after all, the luggage baron of south London in his own right now, with not-quite-prime- site shops all the way from Battersea to Peckham — only someone who has been groomed to be Prime Minister, but has never stood for Parliament, can understand. And as he had once tried to explain to his children, lying stiff and startled, if not downright terrified, in their beds, he was not a man gifted with the grace to count his blessings.

Read More

Meet the Author

Howard Jacobson was born in Manchester, England. His novels include The Mighty Walzer (winner of the Bollinger Everyman Wodehouse Prize), No More Mr. Nice Guy, Kalooki Nights (longlisted for the Man Booker Prize), The Finkler Question (winner of the 2010 Man Booker Prize), and most recently, Zoo Time. Jacobson lives in London.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >