A Huntard's review of The Shattering
I recently finished reading Christie Golden's "The Shattering: Prelude to Cataclysm," and in the spirit of actually working on this blog again, I'm reviewing it for your edification. Or annoyance. Whatevs.
The novel follows Thrall's quest to understand what's happening to Azeroth, and his pain at the torment his beloved elements are enduring. It also shows the internal strife present in the Horde, and the treachery of the Grimtotem clan, and chronicles Cairne's death, Thrall's more permanent appointment of Garrosh as warchief, and Moira's return to Ironforge and the death (I'm assuming he's dead) of our pal Magni.
Off the bat, a few things got me hopping mad about the book, none of which can be blamed on the author. First, Cairne's death. Dammit, I liked him. Second, Magni's death. Huh!? Two of my favorite leaders, gone. The horde being led by a hothead, and Ironforge ruled by a sociopath. Regardless of why she became one, the fact remains that she's a sociopath. No good can come of this.
Now that that's out of the way, on to the novel itself. One thing that comes through time and again is the balance Christie Golden is able to walk while bringing major lore characters to life. Do too much, and they change materially. Too little, and they seem as though they're cardboard cutouts with no personality. Personally, this is my chief complaint with some of Knaak's work. it seems as if he's scared to approach the major lore figures, and as such they come off very wooden. As in Arthas, Christie's treatment of Thrall, Anduin, and others does not disappoint. It manages to be true to the existing lore of the characters while giving a perspective on each of their inner turmoils and struggles.
Anduin in particular is wonderfully done. His simultaneous love and disdain for different aspects of his father's personality shines through, and we get to see what he's become: a developing leader with a great amount of empathy for others. I loved this guy.
I also think that the novel, particularly later in the story, has done a great job of undoing some of the general dislike towards Garrosh. Garrosh, from in-game sources, has come across as a jerk. In the novel, although we see that he's hotheaded and sometimes stupid, we also see his great sense of honor at being robbed of a proper kill in his battle with Cairne. We also see humility, when he realizes the losses the Horde has suffered, and the consequences of his brashness.
Golden's descriptions of Thrall's struggles in Nagrand were particularly revealing. You sense the pain he feels at his world's suffering, and his reluctant mentor Aggra eventually feels it too. Thrall casting off the plate armor and taking up the traditional Shaman garb marked what I think will be a drastically different direction for the character, although like others I am disappointed that his romantic interest ended up being someone other than Jaina, although I understand why it had to be that way.
I think it's probably tough to write a novel when most of the major points of the story are already laid out for you. That said, Christie Golden did as great a job as she did on Arthas. Her ability to bring major characters to life without changing their essence is extremely valuable in this genre, and separates her work from the heaps of trash in the Warcraft and Star Wars universes that I can only describe as glorified fanfic.
I enjoyed the book immensely!
5 out of 6 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
The book World of Warcraft fans have been clamoring for—the true story behind one of the Warcraft universe’s most terrifying villains, Arthas the Lich King. Author Christie Golden does for Arthas what she once did for the Orc Lord Thrall in the bestselling Warcraft: Lord of the Clans, in another epic exploration of one of the key characters from the eleven-million subscriber massively multiplayer online role-playing game.