Worried Sick: A Prescription for Health in an Overtreated Americaby Nortin M. Hadler
Nortin Hadler's clearly reasoned argument surmounts the cacophony of the health care debate. Hadler urges everyone to ask health care providers how likely it is that proposed treatments will afford meaningful benefits and he teaches how to actively listen to the answer. Each chapter of Worried Sick is an object lesson on the uses and abuses of common/i>
Nortin Hadler's clearly reasoned argument surmounts the cacophony of the health care debate. Hadler urges everyone to ask health care providers how likely it is that proposed treatments will afford meaningful benefits and he teaches how to actively listen to the answer. Each chapter of Worried Sick is an object lesson on the uses and abuses of common offerings, from screening tests to medical and surgical interventions. By learning to distinguish good medical advice from persuasive medical marketing, consumers can make better decisions about their personal health care and use that wisdom to inform their perspectives on health-policy issues.
Hadler (medicine & microbiology/immunology, Univ. of North Carolina-Chapel Hill) amplifies and updates his 2004 book, The Last Well Person: How To Stay Well Despite the Health-Care System, here writing another clear message on his prescription pad: "Rx: less is more." Challenging conventional medical wisdom, he advises a healthy skepticism about the benefits of drugs, routine tests, and many common medical procedures-dubbing what he describes as impeccably performed but medically unnecessary treatments "Type II Medical Malpractice"-and he makes the unfashionable assertion that aches and pains are a normal part of the aging process. Topical chapters provide information on heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and other common conditions as well as discussions of how mental states and socioeconomic factors affect health; "shadow chapters" offer additional, specialized information on each topic. Though the book may not convince readers to forgo their annual prostate-specific antigen (PSA) tests or mammograms, it will educate them on being far better health-care consumers. This often densely written but provocative look at the U.S. medical system is worth the effort; recommended for larger public and academic libraries.
Description: This is a guide for consumers to better understand healthcare options, navigate throughout the maze of jargon, and advocate for their own health.
Purpose: The book presents the common issues that most consumers face in healthcare today. Its purpose, though, is to assist the public in making informed healthcare decisions. These worthy objectives are met.
Audience: Although the audience is consumers, health professionals can benefit from looking at healthcare issues from a consumer perspective.
Features: Topics range from the aging population and healthcare needs through interventionists in cardiology as cash drivers in healthcare, to the disease du jour such as cholesterol, breast cancer, and dying. The topics of alternative therapies and insurance are thrown into the mix. Using a teaching approach of a healthcare professional having a conversation with a patient sets the stage. Each chapter contains scientific support for the argument presented. Then a so-called "shadow chapter" follows that presents important scientific papers for more in-depth review of the material. The only shortcoming is that little acknowledgement is given to the Institute of Medicine (IOM) core competencies that drive healthcare today.
Assessment: There is no direct competition for this book. Its unique perspective is a breath of fresh air for critically examining healthcare topics such as cardiac problems and the new specialization of interventionists. It presents options to consumers and encourages them to make informed decisions about their own health. The physician author makes clear the consumer has rights to demand good healthcare.
What People are saying about this
A serious diagnosis of what ails modern American medicine which will surprise and educate even the most savvy reader. Hadler exposes the fallacies that drive unnecessary and often harmful treatments and offers a hard-hitting series of remedies that could benefit us all.Jerome Groopman, M.D., Harvard Medical School, author of How Doctors Think
Meet the Author
Nortin M. Hadler, M.D., M.A.C.P., M.A.C.R., F.A.C.O.E.M., is professor of medicine and microbiology/immunology at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and attending rheumatologist at UNC Hospitals. He is author of several books, including Stabbed in the Back: Confronting Back Pain in an Overtreated Society and Rethinking Aging: Growing Old and Living Well in an Overtreated Society.
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >
This tome on the over-treated, over diagnosed, over drugged world of America is interesting. The author's premise is that we are beset with rampant Type II Medical Malpractice - the performance of unnecessary testing, diagnosing, and prescribing. He seems to perceive that we are, as a culture, drug addicts of the first order, responding to the programmed prescription of pharmaceuticals by doctors who mindlessly follow the lead of drug companies and studies financed by the same folks. In the course of this herd-like plunge off the cliff, we are engaged in a huge wealth transfer from all of us to the medical establishment. What is our reward? The lowest life expectancy of any major country! Of course, this is the issue of the moment for our new President Obama, who seems obsessed with expanding this process. Whether your concern is cholesterol, blood sugar, blood pressure, breast cancer, prostate cancer, dietary supplements, hormone replacement therapy, osteopenia, backaches, over or under-working, or whatever, Dr. Hadler offers a critical evaluation of the practical realities of studies, most of which are read to mean that current treatments are no better than placebos. Dr. Hadler's view seems to be that we all live, on average, to be about 85. By that time, we will all have our fair share of diseases and will die from one or more of them. We will be best advised if we have a trusted physician who will evaluate our maladies, advise of the realities of the treatments, and then let us take a proactive role in our own self-medication. He nowhere exactly says this, but the result seems clear enough. This is a marvelous book that should be must-reading for anyone who is concerned about any of these things - which is all of us. For me, Dr. Hadler's excellent analysis made me revisit my own mother's breast cancer treatment in the 1950s. I think that she endured a mutilation that was probably needless, did not extend the length of her life, and surely devastated the quality of her life. I hope that you are all spared such a fate. Read about being worried sick!