Over two years in the making, a period that involved a multitude of revisions and delays, anger management therapy, drug rehabilitation, and a jail stay for parole violation,
X surfaced in September 2014 as
Chris Brown's sixth full-length studio release. In a way, the album is a corrective. The influence of European dance-pop, which resulted in some of
Brown's most forgettable material on
Fortune, is all but eliminated in favor of contemporary R&B and pop productions that tend to suit the singer better.
Brown does maintain his bad-boy image. It's on typically full display in the chintzy "Loyal" -- its hook a misogynist pleonasm -- and the part-clever/part-nonsensical string of
R. Kelly quotes that is the
Trey Songz duet "Songs on 12 Play" ("And I'm feelin' on yo booty, drivin' me crazy, half on a baby"). On "Drown on It," the pied piper of R&B himself joins in, and he and
Brown dole out an unsurprisingly cartoonish variety of metaphorical and/or explicit come-ons that include "Just like a male mermaid, baby."
Brown combines memorable hooks with some stellar production work on the rubbery disco-funk of "Add Me In" (courtesy of
Danja) and the blithe, swaying "Time for Love" (a collaboration with
Jean Baptiste and
Free School). In these and a few other songs, romantic affection, expressed with seemingly genuine sweetness, takes precedence over sexual aggression and petulance. More importantly,
Brown's voice, still boyish, sounds most natural and full of life in these settings. Additional guest appearances come from
Lil Wayne,
Rick Ross,
Usher,
Tyga,
Akon, and
Kendrick Lamar, but
Brown's lone spot reserved for a woman is his best collaboration here. On the darker but no less striking "Do Better," he and
Brandy continue a fruitful association that previously resulted in the Top Five R&B hit "Put It Down" and the phenomenal
Two Eleven album cut "Slower." It's one of the more compelling R&B duets of its time, with their vulnerable confessions as sharp as their aspersions. [The deluxe edition adds four tracks, including the pre-album singles "Fine China" (one of
Brown's best), "Love More" (featuring
Nicki Minaj), and "Don't Think They Know" (pieced together from
Digital Black's
Aaliyah-enhanced song of the same title, previously unheard elements recorded for it, and
Jon B.'s "They Don't Know"). The sticker on the cover of the compact disc version referred to these three singles, as well as "Loyal" and "New Flame," as "#1 hits." When the album was released, none of the five had topped
Billboard's Hot 100, Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs, or Hot R&B Songs charts, or any of the publication's charts that track digital sales, airplay, and streaming.] ~ Andy Kellman