Good book, but not the best X-Men book
This was a fairly good book, but not the best X-men piece I've read. The story is an intriguing one, and very action packed. However, with all the different titles in here (Uncanny X-men, X-Factor, Power Pack, New Mutants, Thor, and Daredevil) there is a bit of overlap. The issues do not lead into each other, rather they overlap and make it repetitive. This book tells the story of how the Morlocks were killed, and is important in the X-men continuity. I read this book due to seeing references to it in other X-men issues I recently read. It brings in many mutant characters and the Chris Claremont issues are top notch. That being said, the non-Claremont issues are lacking. The Power Pack issue was unreadable. I flipped through until I saw Morlocks or something related to the story. I also said to myself "Why did they make a comic based on the kids Thor helped in the previous issue? And why didn't they tell Thor they were the Power Pack? Oh, these are different kids, they just look pretty similar, and this has nothing to do with the previous issue." Overall my problems with this book were: 1) Too repetitive - Leave the Morlock tunnels already! You'll get killed down there!! 2) Issues I didn't care about - How/why did Daredevil and Thor get included with an X-men title. After you read those issues you'll say "why didn't they just have (insert name of mutant you like) do that? 3) X-Factor - Are they mutant hunters, or mutant criminals, or mutant heroes? Why are they pretending to be humans who hunt mutants?! And why don't they just tell their allies the truth?! (I suppose this is explained and resolved in earlier or later issues) 4) The non-Claremont issues - They just seem to be missing something compared to his issues. That being said, I am a Claremont fan and am biased towards his works. Overall, What I liked about the book: 1) Large Volume - 12 issues packed with characters you know, and hopefully love. It was nice to read a long story and see how it played out. 2) Great story - It's an interesting story that involves many mutants, and explains what happened to the Morlocks (why they are not in current comics, or even pre-House of M comics) 3) Great Writer - Chris Claremont makes this book worth it. Even if you skip past the Daredevil and Power Pack (the Thor issues are very key to the events, you can not skip them) you still get enough story/issues/action for it to be compelling. 4) Binding - This is a wonderful hardcover book. I love the hard cover books compared to the paperback. The pages are well bound and it seems well made. 5) Price - I bought it for $26.93. At or near that price, it is a bargain (Amazon currently has it for $26.39. At the $39.99 list price, you may want to pass. All things considered, this was a very good book and I would recommend it to any X-Men or Chris Claremont fan. I should also add the the cover is not the picture currently shown (Thor holding Angel in his arms, and Sabertooth and Wolverine staring down each other) but rather the one shown on Amazon (with Shadowcat, Rouge, Storm, Nightcrawler, Wolverine, and Colossus.)
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
The X-Men face off with some of their greatest foes in the latest edition from Marvel’s popular ESSENTIAL line. In this volume, the X-Men go up against the Juggernaut, Doctor Doom and the Hellfire Club’s newest recruits, the Hellions -- and team up with the Avengers, Spider-Man and Power Pack. Featuring the first appearances of Forge and Nimrod, and a chapter from the legendary SECRET WARS II crossover! Plus: Parts I & II of Claremont and Windsor-Smith’s unforgettable epic, "Lifedeath." Collects UNCANNY X-MEN #180-198 and X-MEN ANNUAL #7-8.When X-Men #1 first appeared in the fall of 1991 it shook comicdom to its core. This is a classic collection of the ...