You Wouldn't Want to Live in a Wild West Town!: Dust You'd Rather Not Settle

You Wouldn't Want to Live in a Wild West Town!: Dust You'd Rather Not Settle

by Peter Hicks, David Antram
     
 

View All Available Formats & Editions

Editorial Reviews

Children's Literature
The Wild West is a chapter in American history that has consistently captured the imagination of readers. In this selection, author Peter Hicks takes readers back into a western town as he chronicles the perils of a frontier sheriff. Yet, while this story provides some points of interest, the overall nature of this book is clearly open to question. All too many of the illustrations incorporate violence, gore, mayhem, and graphically offensive subject matter. Do younger readers need to see a moldered corpse riddled with bullet holes? Should blood splattered buffalo hunters be portrayed as they slowly skin a dead animal next to a wagon dripping in gore? Is it appropriate to scatter images of violence across virtually every page? The answer to these questions should be a resounding "NO." Thus, due to the misguided approach of the author, illustrator, and publisher, aimed at capturing children's interest through sensationalism, this book typifies the worst possible elements of history writing for younger readers. Additionally, this book features racially offensive representations of Native Americans that were common in literature printed in a far less enlightened era. Therefore, this is a book not only to avoid but one that crosses over the line of responsible scholarship. One in the "You Wouldn't Want to Be" series. 2002, Franklin Watts, Romaneck

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780531163672
Publisher:
Scholastic Library Publishing
Publication date:
03/15/2002
Series:
You Wouldn't Want to Series
Pages:
32
Product dimensions:
8.40(w) x 9.42(h) x 0.15(d)
Age Range:
8 - 11 Years

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >